Amara Cay Resort

MK and Tanya were very friendly and helpful when we rented fishing poles to fish off the dock.

…

Amazing!! Moya Kay was so helpful and sweet. Gave my 3 year old a snow cone afterwards.

Wonderful people, amenities and location. Miss Lilly was super helpful at the restaurant. MK helped us make beautiful tie dye t-shirts to take our memories of the blue/aquamarine waters home!

Customer service was amazing from chk-in at the front desk to tiki bar. Everyone was super friendly

Beware if you expect consistent value within the Islamorada Resort Collection. My wife and I rented a pool cabana at Amara Cay, only to discover that their sister property, Three Waters, charges the exact same price but includes a massive $250 food and beverage credit. Amara Cay provides absolutely zero credit.

When I brought this $250 value disparity to the Front Desk Manager, her excuse was that Three Waters is a bigger property and can 'afford to do more.' As a paying guest, that is an insulting justification for a corporate double standard.

I emailed leadership and the sales team (Cart Code: RC-IPJVAE) requesting they at least credit the $100 we spent out-of-pocket on food. They ignored me for days, and then sent a generic template email refusing to do anything about it.

If you are going to spend premium money in Islamorada, book at Three Waters or somewhere else that respects its guests. Amara Cay’s management would rather protect a few dollars than fix a glaring, unfair policy.

Words can not describe how amazing the time we had at this resort. Every employee greeted us with a smile and was extremely helpful. The hotel felt like we were on a tropical island. Rooms were so spacious and clean. And the best part was all the amenities including utilizing the other two sister resorts. We didn’t want to leave the resort areas because of how beautiful each one was.

Can’t wait to come back again. Sad I’m leaving a part of my heart here. 🥰

We had a wonderful experience dining here! The food was delicious, the atmosphere was great, and the service really stood out.

A special thank you to Alexis the complex manager for being so welcoming and making sure everything went smoothly. Luis, the restaurant manager, was also very attentive and professional. Our waiter, Damien, provided excellent service — friendly, helpful, and checked on us throughout the meal.

Everyone worked together to make the experience enjoyable, and we truly appreciated the hospitality. We would definitely come back again!

We had a great breakfast at Amara Cay restaurant. Our server Verline was attentive and sweet.

My husband and I had the good fortune of meeting Alona at the front desk. Not only was she friendly and helpful, but she also got rid of a gekko that was in the lobby! Pretty sure that wasn’t in her job description. Thanks, Alona, for making our stay memorable.

Chloe from the front desk was so helpful.. everyone there was friendly!!

Chloe from the front desk made us feel at home. She hooked us up with a ride and had cookies for us when we got back...

Had a great stay at Amara Kay— the hotel was clean, comfortable, and well maintained, making it an easy choice for a relaxing visit.

The highlight of our stay was Chloe at the front desk. She was absolutely the best — welcoming, professional, and incredibly helpful with anything we needed. Service like that really sets a place apart.

Overall, a great experience and we’ll definitely be back. Highly recommend!

We had a terrible experience with this property, we checked in and the pool pump was broke, internet was down, they had no idea when either would be fixed, staff was unable to help with any of the issues. We spent our first day/night fighting with the front desk, calling around trying to find another hotel, driving around to find another hotel, missed our dinner reservations, the beach area is a joke, you have to walk down concrete steps to seaweed, slime & oil slicked filled water from the boat slip next to swimming area.
The conditions of the rooms & halls were disgusting, dirty is not a strong enough word to describe the conditions.
Do NOT stay here, do not be fooled by paid reviews and fancy marketing like I was, this place is a scam.
Over $500 a night - please take the time to look at my pictures.

Chloe was amazing great in making us feel right at home she was very positive always.

Exceptional customer service

We had a beautiful stay to celebrate Mother's Day. We enjoyed everything about our stay. The smash burger was the best. We will definitely be back so that we can experience all the other amenities that we didnt get to experience this time. Kediesha was very helpful with the golf experience. My sons had so much fun with it and it was awesome knowing we were feeding the fish with the golf balls.