Amara Cay Resort

todo

I liked the location of the property.

The property had lots of good amenities, you don’t even need to leave the resort to have a good time.

Location was great. Shuttle made things much easier. Great view, and things to do on site

The people working here were amazing! So friendly and kind. property very relaxing, beautifully kept. wonderful people perfect weekend.

Location

MK was so helpful and kind. She put us at ease going out on paddle boards.

Ask if the are under necessary repairs before you go ... we had the worst experience ever. We have visited Islamorada many times before and have tried different hotels ... I recommend the rest of them not Amara Cay Resort.

Flood damaged! Go to Cheeca Lodge. It’s way better. The hotel is flooded by a sprinkler: ceilings are down, carpets wet and a bit smelly; noisy multiple dehumidifiers are going constantly in first, second and third floors with workmen removing skirtings etc,. After booking a seaview with loveholidays, we were gives a very limited partial seaview. Nice enough but not what was booked. We were then told there would be a $75 a day resort charge! This was to cover pool, kayaks, paddleboards etc ., but no reduction was given when we could only use them one day in six. We were told that there was more going on at the two sister hotels, so went on our first full day to the Three waters. However, on arrival, I cut my foot on glass at the pool area. Staff were helpful and gave first aid to stem the bleeding and gave butterfly stitches to close the wound. This meant I could not use the pool and as the glass had been embedded deeply, spoiled the holiday due to risk of infection. Staff were mostly helpful , resort nice enough but not nearly as nice as many others in the area and a total dump inside at the moment. Our tv was also not working either and had to get maintenance to fix it. Guests should not be expected to stay in this and definitely not be expected to pay a resort fee ! A refund should be given instead.

Great place for you to take time off and relax. The staff were very nice and welcoming. The food at the restaurant was the best so far. We would come back again.

Excellent customer service provided by Chloe and Nosipno. They helped my husband plan the best possible experience for a milestone birthday. The resort was a clean and family friendly.

The room was more than I expected. The whole property was so relaxing and the staff was amazing. They always greeted me with a smile and were so helpful.

We had a wonderful stay! The rooms were beautiful, and having access to all three resorts gave us so many options. There were endless activities and amenities to keep the kids entertained.

A special shout-out to MK and Emanuel, who were absolutely fantastic with the kids! They helped with kayaking, building sand castles, running obstacle courses, bikes, and tie-dye activities, making our stay even more memorable.

If you’re looking for an unforgettable snorkeling experience, be sure to book with Captain Jordan at Amara Cay. He took us to the lighthouse. He was knowledgeable, friendly, and made the trip fun for everyone while helping us safely explore the incredible marine life and crystal-clear waters.

The location is unbeatable, with breathtaking views of the lighthouse, and the hotel itself is spotless. Every staff member we encountered was warm, welcoming, and incredibly friendly. We can’t wait to come back!

so nice and peaceful ! mk and elijah were a big help!

Pillows and.bed were comfortable

We had our first family vacation in years and Amara Cay was a solid choice to stay. Great suite with good amount of room, solid view despite facing the parking lot. Pool, beach area and tiki bar had awesome vibes.
Big shout outs to Lynn in the restaurant as well as Alton and Luis at the bar.
Coming from service industry, watching Lynn engage with guests with such a pleasant personality and offering suggestions to local hotspots was great to see in an era where customer service has been on a decline in recent years.
Alton and Luis at the bar area were amazingly friendly, greeting our party with kind smiles each visit. They were both great with our kids repeatedly going up for Shirley Temples and virgin Pina Coladas and always granting the extra cherries to keep them happy.
Food was great when we ordered from the restaurant or room service with healthy portions and reasonably priced for a resort.
Overall amazing few days in Islamorada thanks to the staff and accommodations at Amara Cay!