Coconut Mallory Resort and Marina

Hotels
8.5 (308 reviews)
1445 South Roosevelt Boulevard , Key West , us

Paid
Children allowed

Facilities

WiFi available
Free WiFi
Parking
Non-smoking rooms
Air conditioning
Swimming pool
Heating
BBQ facilities
Lift / Elevator
Fishing
See all facilities

Review Highlights

Pros:
Spacious, well-organized room
Convenient location
Cons:
Moldy smell inside property
Severe roach infestation in kitchen (15 roaches)

Categories

Cleanliness
3.5
Guest reports a moldy smell inside the property and a severe roach problem (killed 15 roaches in 3 days); cleanliness rated very poor.
Service
9.92
Standard quality for this hotel tier
Location
9.9
Guest said "Location wasn’t bad," indicating the location was generally acceptable.
Room Quality
9.92
Guest liked the space and how it was organized, though the kitchen/room was affected by the pest issue noted separately.
Amenities
9.92
Standard quality for this hotel tier
Value for Money
9.92
Standard quality for this hotel tier
Food and Beverage
9.92
Standard quality for this hotel tier
Overall Experience
5
Overall negative — headline states "Roaches ruined our stay" and mold smell noted, so the stay was significantly impacted by cleanliness issues.
* This sentiment is summarized by AI based on user reviews.
Updated at: 2026-08-11 22:39

Property Description

Luxurious Amenities and Convenient Location

The Coconut Mallory Resort and Marina offers a luxurious escape just 2 miles from the vibrant Duval Street and a mere mile from the Key West International Airport. Guests can indulge in the property's 2 outdoor pools, hot tub, and fully-equipped kitchens in each apartment.

Endless Recreational Opportunities

At Coconut Mallory, guests can enjoy a range of activities from hiring bicycles to exploring water sports equipment. The property also provides easy access to the Coconut Mallory Marina for a day out on the water.

Nearby Attractions

Conveniently situated, the resort is a short drive away from popular attractions like the Key West Shipwreck Museum and the Audubon House and Gardens. Experience the best of Key West at Coconut Mallory Resort and Marina.

Important information:

Upon check-in photo identification and credit card is required. All special requests are subject to availability upon check-in. Special requests cannot be guaranteed and may incur additional charges.

Guests under the age of 21 are only allowed to check in with a parent or official guardian.

Please note that a resort fee of USD 8.00 per night is not included in the price.Guests are required to show a photo ID and credit card upon check-in. Please note that all Special Requests are subject to availability and additional charges may apply.
A deposit may be required at the property.

Check-in and check-out hours:
Check-out: 10:00 AM
Airport code: EYW

Location

Guest Reviews

8.5
Based on 308 reviews
Cleanliness: 3.5
Service: 9.92
Location: 9.9
Room Quality: 9.92
Amenities: 9.92
Value for Money: 9.92
Food and Beverage: 9.92
Overall Experience: 5
L
Lorella solo_traveller pe
8
2026-07-16 via Nuitee
S
Stela extended_group us
8
Pros:

I like the space and how was organized.

Cons:

The property smells like a mold inside.

2026-07-06 via Nuitee
T
Thomas solo_traveller us
3
Roaches ruined our stay
Pros:

Location wasn’t bad

Cons:

I killed 15 roaches in 3 days in kitchen
Majority was if the roaches were on the counter and in and under the coffee pot

2026-07-02 via Nuitee
M
Mathias family_with_children ch
10
2026-03-25 via Nuitee
G
Gerald couple us
10
Great quiet location.
Pros:

Location is great.

Cons:

Nothing

2026-01-15 via Nuitee
W
Western couple us
7
Comfortable, clean, fairly quiet housing
Pros:

Spacious and comfortable responsive staff on site for issues, nice pool and hot tub

Cons:

The bathrooms were all upstairs, which would be a problem for people who have trouble with doing stairs
I would not stay in one of the units close to the road again as it was quite noisy with traffic

2026-01-12 via Nuitee
A
Anna extended_group us
8
2026-01-07 via Nuitee
M
michelle family_with_children gb
10
Super clean, comfortable and friendly! Recommend staying here with a car.
Pros:

Lovely apartment, everything we needed, very clean. Staff friendly, location nice and convenient.
Jenny the manager was excellent and kindly put on a Thanksgiving lunch for all the people staying there. So kind and considerate.
The pools were nice, the balconies big with good space for outdoor eating. The beds were super comfortable.
Staff very accommodating. Parking was included which is such a bonus in Key West as very expensive and hard to find. We would leave the car and get an Uber into town.

Cons:

No bar but there was an area in reception where people could meet and make coffee.

2025-12-06 via Nuitee
M
Mark couple us
10
From our room to the property grounds everything was very good!! The people were friendly! We really enjoyed our stay!
Pros:

The property was very nice! We loved going to the dock every morning for sunrise and relaxing later!!

Cons:

Clean, cute and loved all the roosters!

2025-11-10 via Nuitee
C
Calancea family_with_children us
9
2025-10-14 via Nuitee
S
Sandra couple us
10
Great place
Pros:

Very cute and quaint. 2 pools. Great location. Love being on a marina

Cons:

No storage or shelves in bathroom no where to put toiletries

2025-09-06 via Nuitee
Y
Yvenson family
2
Pros:

The property manager Jenny" was very rude and disrespectful. She claiming we were making noises was not even the room.

2025-09-01 via Nuitee
D
Danny couple us
10
2025-08-22 via Nuitee
C
Carlyon family_with_children us
9
2025-08-14 via Nuitee
L
Lauren couple us
9
Pros:

Property is nice and the amenities are great. Location is perfect and quiet.

Cons:

The check in takes longer than necessary and the office has moved down to the bar area. It is made clear with signs but had many guests confused upon arrival.

2025-07-26 via Nuitee
J
Jamie family
6
Pros:

This was a very middle range option in terms of a stay. Not the fanciest one but when on a budget this is a good option. There was a few things we were unhappy with but overall I would stay again if I had to.
We were promised on the listing we could park 2 cars and when we get there, they then told us it would cost us $25 per day for an extra pass. The room was okay and clean but not the best. Wifi was slow, beds were uncomfortable and there was limited ac upstairs. Like I said, not the fanciest, but gets the job done. I enjoyed the pool and the dock areas a lot. It’s definitely not a “resort” in terms of the services or amenities but it’s a place to stay.

2025-07-21 via Nuitee
M
Mary family_with_children us
5
Pros:

It is very nice,clean and great location

Cons:

Was not told about paying additional for additional car. It wasn't on their website either. When I told the property manager she pretty much dismissed it. And had to pay tax on a parking spot as well.

2025-07-10 via Nuitee
J
Javier family_with_children us
10
2025-07-10 via Nuitee
M
Marzena
10
Pros:

For me and my family it was perfect place to stay -easy access to roads-good quiet location which I loved-easy access to elevator and to our apartment . Our Boys loved fishing at the dock -loved kitchen for making breakfast in the morning and nice clean pools at evening after hot days, nice and clean rooms -little problem with ac but resolved in a minutes - thank you for having us and for all hard working people-appreciate everything 💕

2025-07-08 via Nuitee
S
Shpresa family_with_children us
5
It was quiet… not vacation friendly list of vacation chores was not pleasant.
Pros:

It was quiet and not as busy… I suppose now I understand why. Was pleased they had smoking areas as some family members do smoke.

Cons:

The “sunny pool” floor was cracking on the far corner my child actually had a minor cut on the bottom of their foot. The amount of chores that were expected and enforced as threatened to not refund the deposit was ridiculous at checkout day. I had stayed at coconut Mallory approximately 10 yrs ago and was excited to return but my experience was not as pleasant as before. I felt bad because I had more family book an additional room and we immediately regretted our decision. I regret to say that when I do return to Key West I will not be looking at coconut Mallory to book a stay. It’s best to book elsewhere where you could actually feel like you are on vacation instead of thinking and stressing about checkout chores. Also Booking something closer to old town where the attractions are is smarter as parking costed a lot. Wishing Kees vacations the best.

2025-07-08 via Nuitee