Facilities

Offsite parking discounted rates available
Parking
Non-smoking rooms
Air conditioning
Family rooms
BBQ facilities
Express check-in/check-out
Non-smoking throughout
Private check-in/check-out
Shared lounge/TV area
See all facilities

Review Highlights

Pros:
Exceptional hospitality
Delicious breakfast
Charming atmosphere
Cons:
Limited dinner options nearby
Some amenities as listed were missing

Categories

Cleanliness
9.82
The room was immaculately clean and well maintained.
Service
10
The level of care was exceptional, with wonderful staff providing friendly service.
Location
9.92
Wonderful location, charming home with easy access.
Room Quality
9.82
Rooms were comfortable, spacious, and full of character.
Amenities
9.42
The breakfast and overall amenities were above expectations.
Value for Money
9.42
Offering comfort, authenticity, and outstanding hospitality.
Food and Beverage
10
Breakfast was excellent, fresh, and generously prepared.
Overall Experience
10
A unique, welcoming, and truly memorable experience.
* This sentiment is summarized by AI based on user reviews.
Updated at: 2026-01-07 05:55

Property Description

Historic Charm and Modern Comforts

Luxurious Accommodations: Benn Conger Inn offers elegant rooms with flat-screen TVs, air conditioning, and private bathrooms. Some rooms even feature balconies for a picturesque view.

Convenient Location: Situated near top attractions like Cornell University and Ithaca College, guests can easily explore the area. Plus, with free WiFi and private parking, travel is stress-free.

Tranquil Setting: Nestled in a non-smoking property, guests can unwind in a peaceful environment. From the shared lounge to the cozy rooms, every corner exudes relaxation.

Experience a blend of history and luxury at Benn Conger Inn. Book now to enjoy a serene getaway near Groton's finest attractions.

Important information:

Guests are required to show a photo ID and credit card upon check-in. Please note that all Special Requests are subject to availability and additional charges may apply.
A deposit may be required at the property.

Check-in and check-out hours:
Check-out: 11:00 AM

Location

Guest Reviews

9.8
Based on 535 reviews
Cleanliness: 9.82
Service: 10
Location: 9.92
Room Quality: 9.82
Amenities: 9.42
Value for Money: 9.42
Food and Beverage: 10
Overall Experience: 10
J
Jody solo_traveller us
10
Wonderful
Pros:

We liked everything ! Drew and Shelly are very helpful and the house is amazing, historic art everywhere and the breakfast is made to order and yummy. We'd definitely go back!

Cons:

Can't think of anything.

2026-06-10 via Nuitee
L
L9307BApamelar Family
10
Great venue for family event
Pros:

Terrific job helping us host a family event. The suites at the Dempsey House were perfect for our group, and the parts of the Inn where we hosted our reception were beautiful. The food was great! Drew and Shelly were very easy to work with.

2026-06-01 via Tripadvisor
C
ctuzzwerb Business Merrick, Long Island, New York
10
A Superb Spot in New York’s Southern Tier
Pros:

This was a combo work and relaxation trip, and the Benn Conger really delivered. We used it as a base for work-related visits in the area. It also has an ideal location for exploring waterfalls, wineries and more.

We were greeted by Shelley, a manager who welcomed us, answered many questions, made and served delicious breakfasts and greatly enhanced our stay. Our suite was spacious and quiet. It had a fridge, microwave and keurig. Outside our suite was a large siting area and window seat. The Benn Conger is a place that makes you feel at home, if home is a multi-room mansion! It’s not pretentious; in fact, it’s quite cozy.

Fun fact-Groton was the home of the Smith-Corona typewriter factory. The BC Inn celebrates this by having vintage typewriters displayed throughout.
Check out the local antique stores, delicious bakery, Bun Appetite, local provisions, Good Neighbor—heck, even the Groton library is terrific!

2026-05-31 via Tripadvisor
Z
Zobago solo_traveller fr
9
Pros:

Site exceptionnel, petit déjeuner très complet et produits frais, faits maison ( gaufres, quiches...)

Cons:

Bain remous ne fonctionnait pas ou bien n'avons nous pas trouvé comment ?

2026-05-25 via Nuitee
J
Jenni solo_traveller fi
8
Jenni
Pros:

Hieno vanha rakennus. Paikka oli viihtyisä ja tunnelmallinen, henkilökunta oli ystävällistä. Aamiainen oli hyvä.

Cons:

Sängyt olivat vähän kovat.

2026-05-23 via Nuitee
E
Efrain solo_traveller ec
9
2026-05-12 via Nuitee
1
17haroldk Couples
10
A lovely Weekend Stay in Groton
Pros:

My husband and I traveled from New Hampshire to attend a wedding in Groton, and we were delighted to find weekend availability at the Benn Conger Inn, where we stayed in the beautiful Dutchman Suite.

From the moment we arrived, we were warmly welcomed by manager Shelly, who made us feel immediately at home. Our suite was immaculate, spacious, and exceptionally comfortable. The bed provided a wonderful night’s sleep, and despite the inn being fully occupied, the historic home was remarkably quiet and peaceful.

Each morning’s breakfast was outstanding, featuring cooked-to-order eggs, breakfast meats, waffles, pastries, and on our second morning, a delicious Quiche Lorraine that was truly memorable.

A heartfelt thank you to Shelly, Drew, and owner Chris for making our weekend stay so special. Their hospitality and attention to detail made all the difference, and we would gladly return again.

2026-05-11 via Tripadvisor
H
Howe couple us
1
2026-05-11 via Nuitee
T
Tomohiko couple us
10
2026-05-04 via Nuitee
L
Lisa couple us
10
Beautiful Inn!
Pros:

Cozy, clean and comfortable historic inn, close to the action of Ithaca but in a quiet town, with easy access to Syracuse and the Finger Lakes as well. Lots of outdoor spaces. Beautiful rooms with all amenities. Common areas inside are wonderfully appointed. Dining areas, reception rooms all beautiful. Shelley the innkeeper is great!

Cons:

Nothing!

2026-05-03 via Nuitee
S
Sorin couple ca
10
A great mansion for a traveller stopover or a superb centre for discovering the region
Pros:

Beauty’s
Staff
Location
Comfort

2026-04-18 via Nuitee
H
Holidaymaker family_with_children gb
9
A Charming Country Inn
Pros:

Definitely one of the more memorable places I've stayed. The rooms are furnished in keeping with the historic style of the house and Shelley – the innkeeper – was a very welcoming and helpful host. Groton itself is charming village with many more amenities than I was expecting – there's bar, a couple of restaurants and even a few interesting shops. We only stayed one night but very much enjoyed our visit.

2026-04-17 via Nuitee
J
Jennifer couple us
10
2026-04-15 via Nuitee
V
Viktoriya family_with_children us
10
Pros:

Unique historical building. Clean bedding and very comfortable beds. Staff is very friendly, good breakfasts. Close easy commute to Ithaca. Sadly only stayed there for one night, but nightly recommend it!

2026-04-09 via Nuitee
F
Fanni Zsófia extended_group hu
10
Pros:

We had a lovely stay at Benn Conger Inn. Drew was very helpful and Shelley made an amazing breakfast! Thank you for everything!

2026-04-07 via Nuitee
A
Anna couple gb
9
2026-04-05 via Nuitee
N
nas778 Couples Weston, Broward County, Florida
10
Gorgeous Benn Conger Inn
Pros:

Absolutely beautiful Inn. Drew and Shellley were fabulous hosts. Very friendly!
Shelley cooks an amazing breakfast with lots of options. The location is in a very quiet neighborhood. The rooms are Spacious and very clean. With breakfast cooked to order the cost was less expensive than a hotel. It was too cold to enjoy the fire pits with other friends and family. We need to visit in late spring, summer or early fall.

2026-03-31 via Tripadvisor
B
Brenda couple ca
10
2026-03-30 via Nuitee
R
Rinalds couple lv
10
2026-03-22 via Nuitee
S
S4138MJstephaniet Couples
10
My Favorite BnB
Pros:

The Benn Conger Inn is just a short drive from Ithaca , Cortland , Homer and less than an hour to Syracuse . The rooms are very clean and decorated to make you feel cozy , comfortable and very relaxed especially with the jetted garden tubs and gas fireplace features . Many rooms have french doors leading to a lovlie quiet porch over looking the greenery of the property . I have stayed at the Benn Conger 7 times now and find it to be very reasonably priced . Breakfast made by Shelly the Inn Keeper is always a treat . Shelly and Drew are always helpful with any questions we have and have been known to take you on a tour of the Main House if it iant too busy . I already can't wait to go back .

2026-03-09 via Tripadvisor