Islander Inn

Hotels
8.3 (624 reviews)
225 Erie Street , Put-in-Bay , us

listing image 1
Show all photos
Children allowed

Facilities

WiFi available
Free WiFi
Parking
Non-smoking rooms
Air conditioning
Swimming pool
Heating
Lift / Elevator
Luggage storage
Bar
See all facilities

Review Highlights

Pros:
Friendly staff
Great location
Cons:
Cleanliness issues
Lack of amenities

Categories

Cleanliness
6.88
There were issues with hair in the shower, vomit in the entrance, and cleanliness concerns.
Service
9.35
The staff was described as amazing and friendly, providing helpful service.
Location
9.39
The location was noted as good and convenient, being walkable to downtown.
Room Quality
8.34
Rooms were comfortable, but some reviews mentioned issues like soft beds and too much furniture.
Amenities
7.87
Some necessary amenities were lacking, like a microwave and coffee maker.
Value for Money
8.33
Generally considered good value, though some thought the pricing was a bit high for the experience.
Food and Beverage
7.38
Guests expressed a wish for a continental breakfast and some noted additional dining options were lacking.
Overall Experience
8.85
The overall sentiment was positive, with many expressing a desire to return.
* This sentiment is summarized by AI based on user reviews.
Updated at: 2026-01-16 07:41

Property Description

Luxurious Amenities
Islander Inn, located in Put-in-Bay, offers a range of luxurious amenities including a seasonal outdoor pool, hot tub, and a bar. The private bathrooms, flat-screen TVs, and air conditioning in guest rooms ensure a comfortable stay.

Convenient Location
Situated just 1.2 km from Perry's Cave, Islander Inn provides easy access to nearby attractions. Private parking on site adds to the convenience for guests exploring the area.

Modern Comfort
With free WiFi, non-smoking rooms, and balconies in selected rooms, Islander Inn combines modern comforts with a touch of elegance. The hotel's attention to detail, from bed linen to towels, guarantees a relaxing experience.

Book your stay at Islander Inn for a perfect blend of luxury and convenience.

Important information:

Guests are required to show a photo ID and credit card upon check-in. Please note that all Special Requests are subject to availability and additional charges may apply.
Guests under the age of 18 can only check in with a parent or official guardian.
Please inform of your expected arrival time in advance. You can use the Special Requests box when booking, or contact the property directly using the contact details in your confirmation.
A deposit may be required at the property.

Check-in and check-out hours:
Check-out: 11:00 AM

Property Policies

  • Parking

    Private parking is possible on site (reservation is needed) and costs USD 15 per day.

  • Children and extra bed policy

    Children of any age are allowed.
    You haven't added any cots.
    You haven't added any extra beds.

  • Internet

    WiFi is available in public areas and is free of charge.

  • Pets

    Pets are not allowed.

Location

Guest Reviews

8.3
Based on 624 reviews
Cleanliness: 6.88
Service: 9.35
Location: 9.39
Room Quality: 8.34
Amenities: 7.87
Value for Money: 8.33
Food and Beverage: 7.38
Overall Experience: 8.85
B
Bradley • family_with_children • us
9
2026-06-20 • via Nuitee
L
Lester • extended_group • us
10
2026-06-18 • via Nuitee
L
Loran • couple • us
10
2026-06-17 • via Nuitee
D
Darnikka • couple • us
3
Bad
Pros:

It wa a island

Cons:

It was fresh blood
On my bed and power went out also half of the island things to do was not working

2026-06-16 • via Nuitee
L
Latonya • couple • us
6
Overall it was a good stay.
2026-06-15 • via Nuitee
J
Jeremy • family_with_children • us
1
It sucked
Pros:

Horrible experience. Went for the pool and it was closed. The gift shop was closed. Room was ehh. We went for the “resort” and the resort wasn’t open. Bad time

Cons:

Room, the pool being open, staff wasn’t friendly.

2026-06-14 • via Nuitee
M
Mack • couple • us
8
Pros:

Location, and security

2026-06-08 • via Nuitee
D
David • solo_traveller • us
10
2026-06-07 • via Nuitee
K
Kelly • couple • us
7
We were only there one night. It was a good experience. I’m sad I couldn’t enjoy the pool.
Pros:

If I stayed longer I’m sure I could have enjoyed it.

Cons:

I didn’t stay longer enough to have a bad thought.

2026-06-06 • via Nuitee
4
416tracieg • Friends getaway
10
Friends birthday trip
Pros:

Let me start by saying this Inn was very clean and smelled amazing! It's has a nice pool area,2 pools, a jacuzzi and a swim up bar. You can rent a spacious cabana poolside. The staff is dedicated to making your stay as comfortable as possible. You can rent a golf cart at the front desk. And its conveniently located in a central area..I'll definitely go again and I highly recommend it!

2026-06-05 • via Tripadvisor
E
Elizabeth • family_with_children • us
4
I would have booked for a later date
Pros:

the staff was nice.

Cons:

my room ended up being in the middle of the buildings construction project.
The lazy river wasn't up and running.
The wifi didnt work in my room.
The hot tub wasn't even warm.

2026-06-05 • via Nuitee
R
Renota • couple • us
9
Outstanding experience overall! No complaints
Pros:

Location, friendly staff, clean rooms and the hot tub!

Cons:

It was a little costly but… it was also a last min booking.

2026-06-04 • via Nuitee
M
Melissa • couple • us
8
2026-06-01 • via Nuitee
J
joseph • couple • us
9
We had a great time and will most likely be back.
Pros:

Close to the main drag. Friendly and helpful staff. Clean facilities. Well secured.

Cons:

My room was in the back building. It was not connected to the main structure and there was construction going on, so had to walk around the property to get to the front or pool area.

2026-06-01 • via Nuitee
P
Penny • family_with_children • us
9
Great short getaway!
Pros:

Our stay was great except for the running in the halls and yelling in the middle of the night!

Cons:

Quiet time was non existent!

2026-06-01 • via Nuitee
T
Toni • couple • us
2
Pros:

Nothing

Cons:

Overall experience.

2026-06-01 • via Nuitee
G
Gary • couple • us
2
Way better places to stay would choose a different place next time
Pros:

It was under construction nobody makes you aware of that before you book still charge the same price as they normally do. I would make sure you call before you stay at this place.

Cons:

They were doing construction at 7:30 in the morning, making a bunch of noise outside of our room cutting with chopsaws it was ridiculous and very upsetting did let them know didn’t seem to care too much

2026-05-31 • via Nuitee
O
Odyssey09106504689 • Friends getaway
2
Pool under construction! No transparency! No bar available!
Pros:

We stayed at Islander Inn for a bachelorette trip specifically because of the advertised pool and swim-up bar amenities. Before arriving, I called the day before check-in because it was early in the season and temperatures were only around 70 degrees. I was told the pool would not be open due to the weather.

However, when we arrived, it became clear that the issue was not weather at all — the entire pool and swim-up bar area was under heavy construction and essentially torn apart. We paid full price for a hotel that heavily advertises these amenities, yet they were completely unavailable during our stay. This should have been clearly disclosed before booking or at minimum before arrival.

To make matters more frustrating, other nearby hotels had their pools open, including the hotel directly next to us, so the explanation we were given felt misleading.

The rooms themselves were clean, and the hotel overall was decent aside from this issue. However, we were also charged overnight parking fees, which felt excessive considering visitors already have to pay to park virtually everywhere on the island.

Overall, the lack of transparency about the construction and unavailable amenities was very disappointing, especially for a trip planned around the pool atmosphere.

2026-05-19 • via Tripadvisor
C
Charlene • family_with_children • us
10
2026-05-19 • via Nuitee
D
Dave • couple • us
6
Pros:

It was clean and the staff were very pleasant and helpful

Cons:

The bed was very uncomfortable and the pool area was not ready and along with the insurance on the back side of the construction was not lit up hardly at all after hours.

2026-05-18 • via Nuitee