Carlisle Inn Sarasota

Hotels
3727 Bahia Vista Street , Sarasota , us

Free
Children allowed

Facilities

Fitness facilities
WiFi available
Free WiFi
Parking
Free Parking
Non-smoking rooms
Air conditioning
Fitness center
Swimming pool
24-hour front desk
See all facilities

Review Highlights

Pros:
Cleanliness
Friendly service
Spacious rooms
Good value
Cons:
Location can be a bit far from amenities
Breakfast could be improved

Categories

Cleanliness
10
Consistently mentioned as exceptionally clean across multiple reviews.
Service
10
Staff described as super friendly and accommodating, often going above and beyond.
Location
10
Some negative comments regarding distance to amenities, but the comfort compensated.
Room Quality
10
Rooms were described as spacious and comfortable in many reviews.
Amenities
10
The presence of complimentary cookies and a good breakfast were well appreciated.
Value for Money
10
Positive sentiments regarding pricing compared to the quality of the hotel.
Food and Beverage
10
Breakfast experience needed improvement in a few reviews, but complimentary cookies were a positive highlight.
Overall Experience
10
Overall positive experiences shared with a few mentions of minor drawbacks.
* This sentiment is summarized by AI based on user reviews.
Updated at: 2026-01-07 13:06

Property Description

Luxurious Accommodation
Carlisle Inn Sarasota offers elegant rooms with free WiFi access, some featuring kitchenettes with modern appliances. Relax in comfort with a flat-screen TV and enjoy a private bathroom with bath or shower facilities.

Fantastic Amenities
Indulge in a complimentary hot breakfast each morning and savor delicious American cuisine at the on-site restaurant with options for every diet. Take a dip in the outdoor pool, work out in the fitness center, or unwind in the hot tub for ultimate relaxation.

Convenient Location
Located just 3.9 km from Sarasota, Carlisle Inn Sarasota provides easy access to nearby attractions like Siesta Key and its beautiful public beach. With a range of activities available, including cycling, your stay promises to be unforgettable.

Book your stay at Carlisle Inn Sarasota for a perfect blend of luxury and convenience.

Important information:

Guests are required to show a photo ID and credit card upon check-in. Please note that all Special Requests are subject to availability and additional charges may apply.
A deposit may be required at the property.

Check-in and check-out hours:
Check-out: 11:00 AM
Airport code: SRQ

Location

Guest Reviews

Cleanliness: 10
Service: 10
Location: 10
Room Quality: 10
Amenities: 10
Value for Money: 10
Food and Beverage: 10
Overall Experience: 10
H
Heather solo_traveller us
10
2026-08-29 via Nuitee
G
Gabriele family_with_children it
10
Struttura moderna, pulita, con personale gentilissimo e bella piscina.
Pros:

Struttura moderna, pulita e accogliente, con piscina e parcheggio gratuito. Eccezionale il servizio per la spiaggia: teli, ombrellone e sedie gratis. Biscotti offerti dalle 16.00 alle 21.00. Acqua e caffè disponibile h 24. Servizio lavanderia in loco. Personale disponibile e gentilissimo.

Cons:

Posizione non centrale. Necessario avere un’auto.

2026-08-26 via Nuitee
F
Fernando couple ar
10
Pros:

Lo amplio de todo y la gente que trabaja es de primera

2026-08-24 via Nuitee
S
Sebastien family_with_children fr
10
Super
Pros:

Super

2026-08-24 via Nuitee
J
Joel couple us
8
2026-08-22 via Nuitee
G
Gustavo solo_traveller br
10
2026-08-21 via Nuitee
G
Guillermo family_with_children us
10
Fabulous
Pros:

The cleanness

Cons:

Nothing

2026-08-20 via Nuitee
P
Paul couple us
10
Very highly recommend this hotel to any and all travelers, who appreciate a well cared for hotel!
Pros:

Room was VERY comfortable, very tastefully decorated and above all CLEAN! Breakfast was great with lots of choices. Staff were friendly and helpful, offering us a coupon to eat at der Deutschmann. I personally enjoyed all the pictures of Amish life hanging in the hallways.

Cons:

Our stay couldn't have been better!

2026-08-19 via Nuitee
D
David H solo_traveller za
8
Cons:

Typical American breakfast. It’s average for most USA hotels, but way below standards elsewhere. The only cooked food is eggs and processed sausage. No vegetarian options except buns and white bread and a bit of fruit. But this is expected in USA where breakfast standards are very low.

2026-08-17 via Nuitee
M
Mitchell couple us
10
Clean,comfortable,excellent staff when traveling we always look for a safe area, we felt very safe.
Pros:

Always feel safe and a convenient location. Clean and comfortable.

Cons:

Clean comfortable and a welcoming staff.

2026-08-16 via Nuitee
C
Carlo solo_traveller us
9
Super-clean hotel with spacious, very quiet rooms.
Pros:

Super-clean facilities in the Amish-Mennonite community of Pinecraft, with a very friendly front desk and quiet, spacious, spotless rooms. There’s a simple, soothing vibe the moment you walk into the lobby—a vibe that seems to discourage obnoxious behavior, which is wonderful if you’re looking to relax!

This is a hotel that clearly takes great pride in its cleanliness and upkeep. The “fancy” hotels closer to downtown could learn a lot from Carlisle Inn.

And despite being a little removed from downtown, Bahia Vista is just a short drive to downtown Sarasota.

Cons:

Rather uninspired breakfast maybe a step above Holiday Inn Express.

2026-08-16 via Nuitee
J
Jonathan couple us
10
2026-08-14 via Nuitee
E
Elizabeth couple us
10
Wonderful stay & friendly staff.
Pros:

Beautiful room, comfortable bed and very clean. The staff are very friendly and helpful if you need something. Nice variety of food for breakfast.

2026-08-10 via Nuitee
A
Aurelie family_with_children be
9
2026-08-10 via Nuitee
W
William solo_traveller us
10
Pros:

N/A

Cons:

N/A

2026-08-10 via Nuitee
R
RhodeIsland-DinaD Couples Narragansett, Washington County, Rhode Island
10
Exceptional & Outstanding Hospitality at its BEST!
Pros:

Exceptional service from the moment you arrive until you leave. Excellent cleanliness, excellent value, excellent comfort. This hotel’s proximity is in an ideal location just 20 minutes from the Sarasota airport, close to major roads/ highways, all beaches, shopping (UTC), restaurants, and downtown Sarasota without all the tourist congestion!
On site includes: breakfast buffet every morning and fresh baked cookies in the evening, outdoor pool opened early until 10pm, 24 hr fitness gym, business center with internet and printer access, laundry in the hotel for guests (buy a $1 detergent pod at the front desk!), umbrellas for those downpours, spa (get a 1 hr massage at the chiropractor office in their plaza on premise), or go for breakfast/lunch/dinner at their famous Amish restaurant “Der Dutchman”—it includes a cafe, bakery, takeout, and gift store!!! Don’t forget to check out the handcrafted Amish furniture at their store in the plaza also!
Janet, the hotel manager, will accommodate all your needs! Everyone in the hotel treats the guest with exceptional service, including the front desk (Thank you, Misa) to the breakfast staff (thank you, Misako for your smile and hellos every morning!).
This hotel is highly recommended for families, events, and extended stays.
Thank you, Janet and all staff for making our stay feel like home! We appreciated your exceptional kindness and generosity and hope to return in the future.

2026-08-09 via Tripadvisor
G
Graham couple gb
9
Ideal stopover before flying from Tampa
Pros:

Large, spacious with excellent facilities and friendly staff. Good pool area. We will use again next year.

Cons:

Nothing really.

2026-08-09 via Nuitee
C
Cheryl couple us
10
When staying in Sarasota we will always choose to stay at Carlisle Inn.
Pros:

Very spacious rooms, friendly staff and everything was clean!

Cons:

Nothing

2026-08-08 via Nuitee
F
Felicia couple us
10
Was the perfect place for me to stay
Pros:

Very nice, clean and quiet.

Cons:

Nothing

2026-08-08 via Nuitee
L
Leyton family_with_children gb
9
Awesome!
Pros:

Great hotel. Returning customer and we stayed and extra night!

2026-08-08 via Nuitee