Comfort Inn, Erie - Near Presque Isle

Hotels
Comfort Inn
8.2 (233 reviews)
3041 West 12th Street, Erie, Pennsylvania, 16505 , Erie , US

Facilities

Free breakfast
Free WiFi
24-hour front desk
Luggage storage
Continental breakfast
Wheelchair accessible
Outdoor pool - seasonal
Picnic area
Elevator
Free breakfast
See all facilities

Review Highlights

Pros:
Friendly staff
Good breakfast
Convenient location
Cons:
Dated property
Cleanliness concerns
Maintenance issues

Categories

Cleanliness
7.7
While many reviews mention clean rooms, several comments highlighted maintenance issues and dirty areas.
Service
9.2
Staff consistently praised for being friendly and helpful across multiple reviews.
Location
8.7
Convenient location near Presque Isle and food options, generally positive sentiment.
Room Quality
7.7
Mixed reviews regarding room quality; concerns over outdated facilities noted.
Amenities
7.7
Limited amenities noted; broken equipment and sparse vending options mentioned.
Value for Money
8.2
Generally good value for the price paid, although some aspects could improve.
Food and Beverage
8.2
Breakfast was praised for quality; some concerns raised about variety.
Overall Experience
8.2
Overall experience was pleasant, but several guests expressed disappointment in specific areas.
* This sentiment is summarized by AI based on user reviews.
Updated at: 2026-01-06 15:50

Property Description

Discover a serene getaway at Comfort Inn, Erie - Near Presque Isle, where relaxation meets convenience.

Recreation and Relaxation: Dive into fun at our seasonal outdoor pool, or unwind in our scenic picnic area. Recharge with delicious offerings at our two coffee shops or savor a drink in one of our six vibrant bars and lounges.

Comfortable Accommodations: Our 98 guest rooms feature plush pillowtop beds and modern amenities, including complimentary Wi-Fi and satellite programming, ensuring a restful retreat.

Convenient Amenities: Enjoy a complimentary continental breakfast every morning and take advantage of services like dry cleaning and 24-hour front desk assistance. With free self-parking and proximity to attractions like Waldameer & Water World, your stay will be as hassle-free as it is enjoyable.

Don't miss your chance to experience exceptional comfort and hospitality—book your stay today!

Important information:

  • The seasonal pool will be open from May 27 to September 12.
  • Children 18 years old and younger stay free when occupying the parent or guardian's room, using existing bedding.
  • The property has connecting/adjoining rooms, which are subject to availability and can be requested by contacting the property using the number on the booking confirmation.

Check-in and check-out hours:
Check-out: 11:00 AM
Airport code: ERI

Property Policies

  • Pets

    Pets not allowed

  • Children and extra beds

    No rollaway/extra beds available

  • General

    Professional property host/manager

  • Children and extra beds

    No cribs (infant beds) available

Location

Property Accessibility

Total Disability Score: 35.71
Public Area
  • Ramp: Yes
  • Entrance Leveled: Yes
  • Pet Friendly: No
Reception And Restaurant
  • Reception Hearing Accessible: No
  • Reception Wheelchair Accessible: No
  • Restaurant Wheelchair Accessible: No
Elevator
  • Elevator Audio Signals: No
  • Elevator Braille Numbers: No
  • Elevator Contrasting Buttons: No
  • Elevator Visual Signs: No
Show all accessibility features

Guest Reviews

8.2
Based on 233 reviews
Cleanliness: 7.7
Service: 9.2
Location: 8.7
Room Quality: 7.7
Amenities: 7.7
Value for Money: 8.2
Food and Beverage: 8.2
Overall Experience: 8.2
K
Kim solo_traveller us
9
Pleasant stay
Pros:

Cleanliness, cost and great staff, especially Rudy! He was exceptional. When in Erie, I will always be staying there.

Cons:

Even though this was out of their control, my zen time is lounging by pool. However, due to the heat the pool closed for quite a bit due to chemical imbalances. Again, no fault of theirs...just disappointed (I did get pool time in eventually)

2026-07-03 via Nuitee
J
Joyce extended_group us
7
2026-07-03 via Nuitee
L
Loretta couple us
8
It was good. Will stay there again.
Pros:

Breakfast
Location

Cons:

X

2026-07-03 via Nuitee
M
Magdalena family_with_children us
1
The place should be condemned.
Pros:

We left after 10 minutes because we didn't think it was safe to stay with our children, trying to get money back from booking.com because the hotel refused our cancellation despite multiple huge issues. Arrived to an hotel overgrown with weeds, lights hanging off the sides of the building, outdoor locks ripped off, a man standing outside in a tank top and cargo shorts smoking a cigarette asking me "are you trying to check in?", which after a few minutes inside, I realized he was the front desk staff. First room we were given was unmade, not cleaned, no sheets, I informed the front desk and he argued with another staff member for a few minutes over whose responsibility it was to clean, who then complained about having to put her shoes on, and both acted like I was lying about it being unmade, then eventually checked and only then apologized. He handed me another room key with no apologies, which we entered to a horrible stench of bodies, every single surface stained, dust and hair everywhere, the fire alarm not on, sprinklers hanging out of the ceiling, mold clearly visible on all surfaces of the bathroom with paint peeling, and best of all, no door lock. So no exterior locks, no door lock, and on the first floor with 2 toddlers with staff who clearly don't monitor the goings on. I went back immediately and asked for a cancellation and Rudy said "you can leave, but you're still going to have to pay." So, in the interest of safety, we left, immediately called booking.com.

Cons:

We left after 10 minutes because we didn't think it was safe to stay with our children, trying to get money back from booking.com because the hotel refused our cancellation despite multiple huge issues. Arrived to an hotel overgrown with weeds, lights hanging off the sides of the building, outdoor locks ripped off, a man standing outside in a tank top and cargo shorts smoking a cigarette asking me "are you trying to check in?", which after a few minutes inside, I realized he was the front desk staff. First room we were given was unmade, not cleaned, no sheets, I informed the front desk and he argued with another staff member for a few minutes over whose responsibility it was to clean, who then complained about having to put her shoes on, and both acted like I was lying about it being unmade, then eventually checked and only then apologized. He handed me another room key with no apologies, which we entered to a horrible stench of bodies, every single surface stained, dust and hair everywhere, the fire alarm not on, sprinklers hanging out of the ceiling, mold clearly visible on all surfaces of the bathroom with paint peeling, and best of all, no door lock. So no exterior locks, no door lock, and on the first floor with 2 toddlers with staff who clearly don't monitor the goings on. I went back immediately and asked for a cancellation and Rudy said "you can leave, but you're still going to have to pay." So, in the interest of safety, we left, immediately called booking.com.

2026-07-02 via Nuitee
V
Valerie couple us
8
Clean and cozy with acess near restaurants and other businesses
Pros:

Everything in the room was neat and clean.
There was plenty of parking and a side entrance near the rooms for easy unpacking. There is a pool area, closes at 9:00pm. The staff are lovely and ready to help you with any of your concerns or needs. Breakfast begins at 6:30am and ends at 9:00am. There is usually coffee available near the breakfast area even after 9:00am until supplies lasts. Berto the breakfast staff member kept all food fully stocked and was really kind. Wonderful place to stay.

Cons:

The LG televisions in the rooms are really outdated. I wish there was a gym in the facility.

2026-06-30 via Nuitee
M
Mary family_with_children us
3
Disappointing, dirty, would not recommend.
Pros:

The front desk person was helpful in trying to resolve the issue when we arrived and found our room to be unacceptably dirty

Cons:

The room was dirty - a roach was crawling across the desk, other people's left behind items were in the drawers (making me wonder if any real cleaning had been done), there was trash on the floor under the desk, squished blueberry muffin (I think) on the bathroom floor. Second room had sheets on one bed that were stained yellow and also had mildew stains on the side.

2026-06-30 via Nuitee
L
Laurie solo_traveller ca
3
2026-06-29 via Nuitee
G
Giles couple us
8
High price $400. for okay room.
Pros:

Comfortable bed.
Good view.
Breakfast good.

Cons:

Some mechanical issues.
Bathroom not completely clean.
Carpets dirty.
Order of room musty.

2026-06-29 via Nuitee
M
Marla couple us
9
Our stay was good
Pros:

We had a very nice stay

Cons:

My fiance couldn't eat the eggs, he said they weren't cooked enough.

2026-06-29 via Nuitee
K
Karas solo_traveller us
7
Pros:

The location is perfect for Presque Isle, breakfast was great, staff very helpful. room and furniture a little worn

2026-06-27 via Nuitee
S
Sharon family_with_children us
5
Wouldn’t recommend because of the dampness
Pros:

Location and management was accommodating to requests. Overall, the facilities were clean and orderly.

Cons:

Bathrooms had no exhaust fans so showers left the rooms terribly humid and never dry. After 3 days everything felt damp. The walls in the bathroom were always damp.

2026-06-26 via Nuitee
M
Maria solo_traveller us
9
Pros:

Very clean , very comfortable beds. Staff was friendly. Excellent location close to beach and theme park. Good variety of restaurants in walking distance.

Cons:

No complaints.

2026-06-25 via Nuitee
K
Kalp family_with_children us
5
Pros:

Location

Cons:

Dated, patched hole in bathroom, lack of signage. Grass not cut around picnic tables, cloudy pool water.

2026-06-22 via Nuitee
J
Joe couple us
8
Pros:

Staff were all friendly and competent.

Cons:

Fresh fruit wasn’t available when we had breakfast.

2026-06-21 via Nuitee
P
Prairie couple ca
5
2026-06-19 via Nuitee
A
Amanda solo_traveller us
10
2026-06-18 via Nuitee
M
Megan solo_traveller us
8
Pros:

The staff was very friendly, polite and helpful! The location was great!

Cons:

A/C in room seemed to struggle to keep up to cool off the room but other than that everything else was good

2026-06-18 via Nuitee
S
SULLIVAN couple us
9
Would stay there again, but would things differently. From booking to room service
Pros:

Location was perfect, room was comfortable, breakfast was very good. The place was good for the time of the year and for what we were doing.

Cons:

Room service was not what we expected, bed was not made, towels ere not changed. We had to go to the service desk for fresh towel

2026-06-14 via Nuitee
A
Ahvrile couple us
9
Worth it
Pros:

Great staff and clean

Cons:

It’s a little bit noisy but I don’t expect anything cause it’s not a 5 star hotel

2026-06-10 via Nuitee
J
Janette couple us
10
2026-06-09 via Nuitee