Comfort Inn Eureka

Hotels
Comfort Inn
8.4 (185 reviews)
4260 Broadway St, Eureka, California, 95503 , Eureka , US

Facilities

Free breakfast
Fitness facilities
Free WiFi
24-hour front desk
Wheelchair accessible
Elevator
Fitness facilities
Free breakfast
Free newspapers in lobby
Smoke-free property
See all facilities

Review Highlights

Pros:
Friendly staff
Good breakfast
Heated pool
Cons:
Issues with cleanliness
Noisy air conditioning
Deposit complications

Categories

Cleanliness
7.63
Some reviews mentioned issues like dirty carpets and a non-smoking room that smelled of cigarette smoke.
Service
9.1
Overall positive mentions of friendly and helpful staff, and quick service.
Location
8.64
Positive notes about the hotel's location being near amenities, though the city itself has some issues.
Room Quality
8.09
Rooms are noted to be updated and comfortable, but there were some complaints about noises.
Amenities
8.12
Hot tub and pool noted positively; however, issues raised about limited fitness equipment.
Value for Money
8.58
Good value cited, but complications with deposits affected perception.
Food and Beverage
8.63
Breakfast options received good reviews; generally perceived as noteworthy.
Overall Experience
8.4
Mixed experiences with some complaints but also multiple praises received.
* This sentiment is summarized by AI based on user reviews.
Updated at: 2026-01-09 20:03

Property Description

Indulge in Recreation
Unwind with our indoor pool, spa tub, and fitness center. Stay connected with complimentary Wi-Fi and enjoy a delicious buffet breakfast.

Convenient Amenities
Benefit from free wired internet, a business center, and newspapers in the lobby. Relax in our well-equipped rooms with complimentary toiletries.

Explore the Area
Discover nearby attractions like Fort Humboldt State Historic Park and Bayshore Mall. Enjoy easy access to various landmarks during your stay.

Book your stay at Comfort Inn Eureka for a relaxing and convenient experience.

Important information:

  • Children 18 years old and younger stay free when occupying the parent or guardian's room, using existing bedding.
  • The property has connecting/adjoining rooms, which are subject to availability and can be requested by contacting the property using the number on the booking confirmation.
  • Contactless check-in and contactless check-out are available.

Check-in and check-out hours:
Check-out: 11:00 AM
Airport code: ACV

Property Policies

  • Pets

    Pets not allowed

  • Sustainability Certifications

    Property confirms they are implementing guest safety measures

  • Pets

    Service animals are exempt from fees/restrictions

  • Check-in & Check-out

    Contactless check-out is available

  • General

    Staff temperature checks are conducted regularly

See all policies

Location

Guest Reviews

8.4
Based on 185 reviews
Cleanliness: 7.63
Service: 9.1
Location: 8.64
Room Quality: 8.09
Amenities: 8.12
Value for Money: 8.58
Food and Beverage: 8.63
Overall Experience: 8.4
K
Krista family_with_children
10
Pros:

We have stayed multiple times with my family. The pool is always clean and warm. The hot tub is also nive. There are always plenty of towels.

The breakfast is pretty basic, but enough to get the job done.

This particular visit i was very happy with the staff. We had an embarrassing incident involving some vomit blankets and towels due to a suck kiddo on our way up. They alliwed us to use the outsude water to rise items off.

Having been there before, i know the pool opens at 9am. We lime to swim early and the hotntub isn't warm yet. This time i went up at breakfast time and kindly asked if they could.prep it so it will be warm. They totally did and it was so.niceto have a warm hot tub.

The rooms is pretty basic. I have some irritating things about the room, there is one hook. I think there should be more and have even brought a command strip hook before.

There is 2 dresser drawers. The closest is RIGHT when you walk in the room and the closet door is hard to open. But leaving it open means you cannot get in the door....soooo i wish the closet either didnt have a door orn
one easier to open.

The bed....I personally am not a fan.squeaky, not soft at all, the linen sucks but the pillows are pretty nice.

The floors are also super dirty. Walking are barefoot our feet got dirty.

But overall, pretty nice spot and we will choose this place each time we visit Eureka.

2025-10-10 via Nuitee
D
Dale
8
Pros:

There were a few limitations to the physical facilities that were annoying but not deal breakers. The parking was a bit tight, the breakfast room was cramped, there were no usb outlets in the room so if charging of devices one would need a charger. Also, there was construction equipment going all night outside our room and was very noisy!

2025-10-08 via Nuitee
J
John
8
Pros:

Quite a few homeless in the area but seems ok

2025-10-07 via Nuitee
C
Cathy family
6
Pros:

Cost is high

2025-10-06 via Nuitee
C
Craig friends
8
Pros:

great for us while passing through

2025-10-06 via Nuitee
C
Crystal
6
Pros:

Room was fine. Slightly run down, but nothing horrible. The real issue was the smell. We woke up to the strongest stench of bacon permeating our room! Apparently, the staff leaves to door open to the kitchen and the smell travels up the stairway. It was horrible!

2025-10-02 via Nuitee
B
Brian
8
Pros:

The area outside often stunk like raw sewage. Not the hotels fault though. The bed could have been a little softer (just my preference, not everyones). I called the front desk the evening before checking out to ask for a late checkout and was told I can check out at noon but they did not let the next shift know so we got a call at 11:15 asking if we were extending. I explained we were told we could have a noon checkout. She said no one marked that down but it was okay.

The hot tub was wonderful and my son and I had it all to ourselves. The breakfast was pretty good, waffle maker, cereal, bananas and apples, mini muffins, scrambled eggs, bacon or sausage, hash brown patties.

I'd stay again, it was priced pretty decently.

2025-09-29 via Nuitee
C
Cindy
10
Pros:

The room was good for a night stay on the road

2025-09-28 via Nuitee
Z
Zachary
2
Pros:

They said I had to give 100 deposit which they said Expedia states which they don’t. Ok fine but they would only except credit card for deposit witch I didn’t have. I offered cash or debit card. No they said. And they wouldn’t refund me. They just kept my 141 dollars. And then sold room to someone else. So they got paid twice. Worst place ever. And Expedia is the worst as well.

2025-09-27 via Nuitee
J
jeffrey family
10
Pros:

Nice place the hot tub and pool are inside and nice the pool is heated probably 80 degrees.

2025-09-27 via Nuitee
M
Mary family
8
Pros:

Morning front desk, male, was very detailed oriented. Friendly and polite.

2025-09-24 via Nuitee
R
Robert
8
Pros:

No laundry

2025-09-23 via Nuitee
W
william
10
Pros:

Very quick check in and friendly staff.

2025-09-23 via Nuitee
J
Jennifer family
10
Pros:

Honestly, great customer service.We needed an extra bed cuz.My kids didn't want to share last minute, and it really came in handy to separate them.And the front office brought a bed very quickly and pretty late at night.Great customer service and truly appreciate the good clean stay.. if I could recommend anything, it would definitely be to add-on to your breakfast area.!

2025-09-22 via Nuitee
J
Judy
8
Pros:

Clean, good pillows, adequate breakfast

2025-09-21 via Nuitee
J
James E partner
10
Pros:

Everything was great even the breakfast was the best I have had at a motel.

2025-09-20 via Nuitee
K
Karen
10
Pros:

Clean.

2025-09-19 via Nuitee
G
GAIL friends
4
Pros:

Didn’t have any luggage transfer racks at the front area. Turns out they only had one that was not in sight when we checked in or when we checked out but also not being in use by anyone else in sight either. No water in lobby, cookies unavailable. Needed a $100 deposit even though I had already paid for the room. Air conditioner extremely noisy.

2025-09-17 via Nuitee
A
Andrew partner
10
Pros:

Everything was fine

2025-09-17 via Nuitee
E
Edmund
8
Pros:

Could have more fitness equipment-room too small

2025-09-17 via Nuitee