Quality Inn Sidney

Hotels
Choice Hotels International
6.6 (124 reviews)
1959 W Michigan Ave, Sidney, Ohio, 45365 , Sidney , US

Children allowed
Pets allowed

Facilities

Free breakfast
Fitness facilities
Express check-out
No single-use plastic straws
Comprehensive recycling policy
No single-use plastic stirrers
No single-use plastic soda bottles
Sustainability/community reinvestment (10% revenue or more)
Free WiFi
24-hour front desk
See all facilities

Review Highlights

Pros:
Close to Eldora
Some nice staff
Cons:
Cleanliness issues
Poor room quality
Disappointing amenities

Categories

Cleanliness
4.81
Multiple reviews mention dirtiness, including bugs and a bad smell.
Service
8.28
Some staff were reported as nice, but overall service was poor based on guest interactions.
Location
8.82
Conveniently located near Eldora, which was mentioned positively.
Room Quality
4.77
Numerous issues reported with room conditions including old furnishings and malfunctioning equipment.
Amenities
5.8
The pool was reported closed and other amenities were disappointing.
Value for Money
7.26
Guests felt the price reflected the subpar quality experienced.
Food and Beverage
6.81
Breakfast was minimal and not thoroughly impressive.
Overall Experience
6.28
Negative feedback dominated reviews, with many stating they would not return.
* This sentiment is summarized by AI based on user reviews.
Updated at: 2026-01-07 12:30

Property Description

Discover a charming stay at Quality Inn, conveniently located near Green Tree Park in Sidney.

Comfortable Accommodations
Relax in one of our 71 well-appointed guestrooms, featuring kitchenettes with refrigerators and microwaves, where you can unwind after a day of exploring. Enjoy jetted bathtubs in partially open bathrooms, and stay connected with complimentary Wi-Fi.

Delicious Dining Options
Start your day with a complimentary buffet breakfast to energize your adventures. For those late-night cravings, take advantage of our room service, available during limited hours.

Recreational Amenities
Dive into relaxation with our seasonal outdoor pool or unwind in the hot tub. Stay active in our fitness center, ensuring you maintain your routine while away from home.

Book your unforgettable stay at Quality Inn today!

Important information:

  • Children 17 years old and younger stay free when occupying the parent or guardian's room, using existing bedding.

Check-in and check-out hours:
Check-out: 11:00 AM
Airport code: DAY

Location

Guest Reviews

6.6
Based on 124 reviews
Cleanliness: 4.81
Service: 8.28
Location: 8.82
Room Quality: 4.77
Amenities: 5.8
Value for Money: 7.26
Food and Beverage: 6.81
Overall Experience: 6.28
M
Matthew
4
Pros:

Spent $160 on a jacuzzi room only for the jacuzzi jets to be broken. Just a large bathtub. Then, when I woke up at 4am to dry mouth, the vending machines were broken. Order DoorDash instead, and they won’t allow the delivery driver to enter the building. So the front desk calls the room when they arrive and wakes the whole room up.

Go to try and get it from the front desk and the door to the lobby is locked. I have to go outside to get to the front desk, and then am locked out myself.

I have been to many hotels. It doesn’t feel like customer service should be that difficult. I won’t be back.

2025-10-10 via Nuitee
K
KRISTAL family
10
Pros:

Nice too

2025-09-18 via Nuitee
J
Jerry
8
Pros:

Good rates. Rooms and building need updating/remodeled

2025-09-08 via Nuitee
K
Kyla family
4
Pros:

Although I liked how close it was to Eldora which is why we came… the facility needs some major upgrades. Caulking in the bath tub, wall paper peeling off, left over ice cream in the fridge. Oh and I wanted a non smoking room that I reserved months ago but they didn’t have any available which is bull. The employees need to look at their bookings before giving out rooms that were already booked. So we had to stay in a smoking room. Definitely will not be staying here again.

2025-09-07 via Nuitee
L
Lindy partner
4
Pros:

We got the king size bed with the jacuzzi tub. Jets in the tub didnt work.
We were not told the pool was closed. Went to use it and the water was green.
Had blood stains on the comforter.
I talked to the lady who was working Saturday and she was on the phone with another customer. I waited and she told them to hang on a second. Asked me what i needed so i let her know the jets in the tub didnt work. All while this other guest was on the phone.
Not impressed at all. And hoping once my payment clears it really clears for a discounted rate as i was told it would be.

2025-08-10 via Nuitee
D
Donald
8
Pros:

Had to get key programed everyday other than that it was fine

2025-08-05 via Nuitee
A
Amber
4
Pros:

The bed was ok. The breakfast was minimal, but did have something to eat. Not thoroughly impressed, but you get what you pay for.

2025-08-03 via Nuitee
R
Richard
4
Pros:

Room was smelly. Cobwebs, bathroom missing bars.

2025-08-03 via Nuitee
V
Verified traveler
2
Terrible hotel
Pros:

When we arrived our room had gnats flying around in it and it smelled bad. The pool was green so we couldn't get in it and the ice machine was broken. Staff were not friendly and were irrited when we asked for clean towels.

2025-07-23 via Nuitee
C
Clint family
2
Pros:

Pool was closed middle of Summer beds were hard will not Bo there again breakfast was trash

2025-07-20 via Nuitee
A
Anthony
2
Horrible hotel
Pros:

We did not stay at the Quality Inn last night because of bugs in the room. We found a dead bed bug and 2 live cockroaches in the restroom. The rooms are old and and dirty.

2025-07-20 via Nuitee
A
Alexandra family_with_children
2
Pros:

The overnight front desk lady was nice. Our room door handle only opened when you lift up, ac never worked as it was 20⁰ cooler outside than in the room, humidity was through the roof in the room. Desk lamp switch broken. Entire place reeked of cigarette smoke and even in a non-smoking room, smoke was getting in. Fire alarms went off at 4:30 in the morning. We brought this to the attention to the front desk but she said there weren't any other rooms available. We packed up and slept the remainder of the night in our truck. I will require a refund.

2025-07-18 via Nuitee
J
Judy partner
4
Pros:

Room fairly clean, shower worked well. Toilet did not work and my husband had to continually try to fix it. Staff said there was no plumber available. There was air flow in room but not air conditioning. It was humid in the room and my clothes felt damp. Breakfast was ok. Will not stay again.

2025-07-14 via Nuitee
D
Donna
2
Pros:

Mine was the 6th room reviewed. 2 not cleaned, 1 adjoining door not able to be locked, 1 electric didn't work, 1 smelled of mold/mildew. 6th I took found the TV didn't work toilet ring old/disgusting, no stopper in the tub, wallpaper pealing. They gave a discount on a future visit would do nothing for this visit.

2025-07-12 via Nuitee
C
charles partner
2
Pros:

the only thing that was fair was pillows

2025-06-30 via Nuitee
S
shelly friends
4
Pros:

Smelly, not clean bathroom. Cockroachs seem in the bathroom at night me no pool or hot tub as advertised. Outside area was dirty.

2025-06-29 via Nuitee
J
Joyce family
4
Pros:

The bands were only full size. They weren’t queen as they advertised. The blankets were old and ratty. The shower floor was stained and dirty. I just want it out of there.

2025-06-13 via Nuitee
K
Kristen
10
Give it
Pros:

I see so many people saying bad things about this hotel however my experience was very good. They took care of everything I needed and very quickly. I will definitely be coming back!

2025-06-13 via Nuitee
L
Laura
4
Really Old and Really Dirty
Pros:

The employees are kind and helpful but this hotel needs a major revamping. No elevator so be prepared to haul your luggage up stairs. The room look clean at first glance but the counter tops were not wiped down, they were sticky and had fingerprints on them. The bathroom was pretty filthy. It looked like someone had brought their clippers and gotten a haircut in there. The shower was actually dirty and had pubs in it. The fridge didn't seal so keeping things cold wasn't an option. I felt better about the room after wiping everything down with antibacterial wipes. The bed was clean and comfortable fortunately. The biggest disappointment is that the pool is closed. My 11 year old was hoping to swim but after inspecting it I probably wouldn't have let him anyways, it was nasty. If you really don't care about where you're staying and just need to crash for the night in a cheap hotel it's fine but two nights was too much for us.

2025-06-08 via Nuitee
A
Allen
6
Pros:

It was ok.

2025-05-27 via Nuitee