Mayfair New York

Great location, just off Broadway and Times Square. Great staff, building a little bit run-down but my room was kept spotlessly clean - wonderfully comfortable bed. Good bolthole for an amazing city.

A great location and very friendly front desk. Small but just fine

The staff were some of the friendliest and most helpful I have come across in a long time. Location is excellent. Rooms tired and dmall

Welcoming and friendly staff. Had a back room which was quiet. Very close to time square and major theatres, situated next to the book of mormon. Hotel itself is run down, threadbare carpet etc but its fine if you all you want is a bed for the night.

This wouldn't be for everybody. Elevators don't always stop on the floor, you had to have the front desk get ice from the restaurant....but I wanted a New York experience....and this was EXACTLY what I wanted. Loved it. Great staff. Room was small, but again... that's what I wanted!

Loved the design of the rooms. Beautiful wallpaper and bed spreads to match!

Very small room.not properly insulated that we can feel the wind and very cold weather from outside through the windows. Definitely needs some updating..saw several permits for construction posted on the door.
Few blocks from Times square and subway is a big plus.

I knew it was an older hotel, but i like historic. However, wall paper was falling off in my room and TV was locked behind a glass enclosure. Felt a bit sketchy. Luckily the sheets were clean.

The staff was beyond rude while checking in and the room is outdated and cold!!

The location..
Fast check in and out..
Staff was friendly..
.

The room was very small and just looked worn. The doors to the entrance of the hotel had missing handles.

Very quaint. One elevator that is rickety enough to cause concern that it probably breaks down regularly enough. (Wasn't scary or a fear it would break down at anytime--just that it probably does happen.)

Nice bathroom and good soap. Some room-specific disappointments show a potential overall lack-of-attention: clock wasn't plugged in and set (and the radio function broken); desk worklight inoperable; toilet seat did not stay up.

Bed comfy and room, although tiny, is worth the tradeoff for location and price.

Very well located and nice hotel. I recommend.

The room was stifling hot and there was no temperature control. I spoke to the front desk and was told to turn on the air conditioner, which was several feet over my head, above the window. The remote for the AC did not work, so the desk gave me new batteries - which also didn’t work. I stood on the edge of the bed and tried punching buttons. They were barely in reach and I couldn’t read what each one did (they were both faded and above my eyeline even when I stood on the bed). On the first night, the AC unit rumbled and roared so loudly, I couldn’t sleep. So I turned it off and slept on top of the covers - in January! The second night, I managed to find a quieter setting so instead of two hours sleep, I managed four and a half. NYC was in the middle of a heat wave, so there was no reason to run the heat at all this weekend. I had been told after night one that they wouldn’t run it the following night. Well, they did. I expected the room to be basic as the building is old, but I couldn’t make it work for me.

Great location. Room was small but the location and the price point for the area made up for it. Fit my needs. Room was comfortable.

Lovely very homely fantastic location. Rooms dated but perfect Collin price range

Much better quality than the price deserves, very good value for price, A lot more amenities included in room than expected.

This hotel is in a great location — within walking distance of most of the touristy things and the subway. The room itself is small but mostly comfortable. I don’t know if the single is large enough for two people but it was perfect for a solo traveler. My only negative with the room was that there wasn’t a way to control the heat. A staff person advised that I would need to turn on the AC if I wanted to cool the room. However, the bed was comfortable and the room and bathroom were tidy, so I would recommend.

We are very impressed with this hotel. It’s very comfortable, the bathroom is awesome.! Night shift in front desk (Lee and Mike) are very professional and very accommodating to our needs. The room was very clean all the time. Santos (lady who cleaned my room) was very friendly with us and made an excellent job all the time. Location is the best!!!
We love this hotel and absolutely next times we return to NY of course we will be here!!!
We recommend this amazing hotel to family, couples or business people!

Traveled alone to see shows and catch up with friends. The location is perfect and the price was great. Despite being near Times Square, the room was extremely quiet. The radiator heat was too much, so I slept with the window open. The bed was comfortable and the shower had good pressure with lots of hot water. But the decor is very dated and it’s a bit run down.