Comfort Suites Downtown Carlisle

Hotels
Comfort Suites
8.5 (486 reviews)
10 S. Hanover Street , Carlisle , us

Paid
Children allowed

Facilities

WiFi available
Free WiFi
Parking
Non-smoking rooms
Air conditioning
Fitness center
24-hour front desk
Restaurant
Room service
Business center
See all facilities

Review Highlights

Pros:
Friendly staff
Central location
Excellent food
Cons:
Room cleanliness issues
Challenging vehicle access during loading

Categories

Cleanliness
7.89
Some reviews mentioned that the rugs were quite dirty, indicating the need for improvement.
Service
8.86
Numerous reviews highlighted the friendly and helpful staff, especially Eddie at the front desk.
Location
8.9
The hotel is centrally located, making it convenient for guests.
Room Quality
8.35
Rooms are spacious and generally comfortable, though some felt dated.
Amenities
8.38
Amenities such as the breakfast and dog-friendly policies were well received.
Value for Money
8.34
Guests found the value consistent with the high quality of service and amenities.
Food and Beverage
8.89
Food quality has been praised highly compared to usual hotel standards.
Overall Experience
8.36
Overall experience is positive with many guests returning multiple times.
* This sentiment is summarized by AI based on user reviews.
Updated at: 2026-01-10 13:03

Property Description

Luxurious Accommodations

Comfort Suites Downtown Carlisle offers spacious suites with modern amenities like executive desks, mini refrigerators, and flat-screen TVs. Upgrade to a whirlpool suite for a touch of luxury with extra perks like plush robes and dual flat-screen TVs.

Full-Service Amenities

Enjoy a range of complimentary services including a free continental breakfast, high-speed Internet access, and weekday newspapers. Stay active at the fully-equipped fitness center, grab essentials at the convenience store, or indulge in room service. Plus, this pet-friendly hotel ensures no family member is left behind.

Dining Excellence

Savor a unique dining experience at the 1794 Whiskey Rebellion Restaurant, known for its extensive whiskey selection and farm-to-table dishes. Whether you're a business traveler or leisure guest, the culinary delights and beverage specialties will surely impress.

Book your stay at Comfort Suites Downtown Carlisle for a perfect blend of comfort, convenience, and culinary delights.

Important information:

Guests are required to show a photo ID and credit card upon check-in. Please note that all Special Requests are subject to availability and additional charges may apply.
A deposit may be required at the property.

Check-in and check-out hours:
Check-out: 11:00 AM
Airport code: MDT

Location

Property Accessibility

Total Disability Score: 42.86
Public Area
  • Ramp: No
  • Entrance Door Width: 82
  • Entrance Leveled: Yes
  • Pet Friendly: No
Reception And Restaurant
  • Reception Hearing Accessible: No
  • Reception Wheelchair Accessible: No
  • Restaurant Wheelchair Accessible: No
Elevator
  • Elevator Audio Signals: No
  • Elevator Braille Numbers: Yes
  • Elevator Contrasting Buttons: No
  • Elevator Visual Signs: No
Show all accessibility features

Guest Reviews

8.5
Based on 486 reviews
Cleanliness: 7.89
Service: 8.86
Location: 8.9
Room Quality: 8.35
Amenities: 8.38
Value for Money: 8.34
Food and Beverage: 8.89
Overall Experience: 8.36
L
Lutz solo_traveller de
7
2026-08-15 via Nuitee
S
Scott solo_traveller us
10
Will stay again
Pros:

Convenience to town town and fair grounds

Cons:

Nothing

2026-08-13 via Nuitee
G
Gail solo_traveller us
9
Pros:

Location, room, clean, restaurant

2026-08-10 via Nuitee
A
Alan couple us
9
Carlisle, as witnessed by this hotel, is for travel pros and travel lovers.
Pros:

This hotel has a latent New Orleans vibe, especially with the restaurant's bar and restaurant extensions under an awning on Hanover Street. The brick facade completes its Southern appearance. Downtown Carlisle is filled with historic sites and cozy little shops (bookstores abound in a college town), and the campus of Dickinson College is a ten-minute walk away. Municipal parking, partially subsidized by the hotel, is only $5.50 per 24-hour period. We had a fourth-floor suite, suggested at the desk, that was totally quiet. The sofa was welcome as a staging area, and the bed was luxurious and an Emperor, rather than a King, size given its roominess and plush bedding. The 1794 Restaurant pulled off the theme elegantly, and the staff was repeatedly challenged by this historian about their knowledge of the Whiskey Rebellion, although whiskies are a house specialty and we are much lighter drinkers. The restaurant alone will get us back to Comfort Suites Downtown next time we're in the area. I had Pennsylvania Trout Friday night while my wife had two generous Chesapeake Bay crab cakes. On Saturday, we both had Bison burgers, a little oilier and tasting a tad like wild game. They were a savory experience, too. Waitstaff refills iced tea glasses without being called for, and service is always with a smile. A buffet breakfast is also included in the 1794, although it is much closer to standard motel fare than the restaurant's exotic and scrumptious lunch and dinner fare. All in all, with a very attractive overnight price point, this was one of the best hotel bargains we've ever gotten in a LONG travel career around the world. Every aspect of the hotel was positive; most were well beyond that. Consider visiting this gem in a town with plenty to see and do.

Cons:

Nothing, although my hope that the 1794 would be directly involved in breakfast, was dashed. Just one overworked waitperson and lots of thawed pastries and entrees. If the hotel did get the restaurant involved in breakfast preparation, this hotel would soar off the charts in my diary.

2026-08-04 via Nuitee
C
Casson solo_traveller us
8
Pros:

Great place to stay!

2026-07-24 via Nuitee
A
Ange solo_traveller us
10
2026-07-13 via Nuitee
L
Lisa couple us
6
It was fine.
Pros:

The location

Cons:

Honestly, we stayed here 4 years ago and loved it. The last few years we stayed at a cheaper hotel. This year, I decided to splurge and was very disappointed. We checked in on the 4th of July and the woman at the desk set the tone. She handed me the key folder and said key and WiFi. When I said what? She just pointed to the room number on the folder. She didn’t tell us where our rooms were, if/when/where breakfast was, where the parking garage was, where the room was or even what the room number was. She really made me feel unwelcome. I never used any of the amenities including breakfast because she made me feel so unwelcome. The room was comfortable but the bathtub could have used a thorough cleaning.

2026-07-10 via Nuitee
N
Nadia family_with_children us
10
Staff was amazing. Especially the gentleman who took care of the breakfast bar! Shout out to him! Wish I got his name. 😃
Pros:

Situated in a good spot

Cons:

Getting into the parking garage and going down a narrow ally

2026-07-06 via Nuitee
C
Chelsea family_with_children us
10
2026-07-06 via Nuitee
J
Jonathan D. Rose solo_traveller us
10
2026-07-06 via Nuitee
J
Jonathan D. Rose solo_traveller us
10
2026-07-06 via Nuitee
M
Mallory couple us
8
Pros:

The staff was amazing and so kind to me and my family

2026-07-04 via Nuitee
D
Diane couple us
8
Charming staff including front desk and housekeeping who were also dog friendly
Pros:

Every single staff person I interacted with was helpful and upbeat. Dog friendly to boot.

Cons:

Terrible pillows stuffed into little squares extremely high. Just a normal flat pillow would be nice. didn’t expect to have one window that looked out over a dim concrete sunken Alley but we were only there to sleep so all right.

2026-07-01 via Nuitee
T
Teresa couple us
10
2026-06-26 via Nuitee
J
John solo_traveller us
10
Loved it
Pros:

Loved it

Cons:

Great

2026-06-23 via Nuitee
B
Beáta family_with_children hu
6
2026-06-18 via Nuitee
L
Lachlan couple us
9
2026-06-17 via Nuitee
S
Simon family_with_children de
9
2026-06-15 via Nuitee
E
Elizabeth couple us
10
we would stay here again in a heartbeat
Pros:

The beds were so comfortable. The bathrooms are great. The rooms were big. The breakfast was delicious and we love the location.

Cons:

We loved it

2026-06-08 via Nuitee
T
Theresa solo_traveller us
10
Great stay as usual!
Pros:

Staff was great!

2026-06-04 via Nuitee