Peace and Plenty Resort

So we have been traveling all the islands via our Cessna 206 flying & island hopping! It’s been a blast! Today we rented a boat and played the beaches along all the cays. Stopped at Peace & Plenty Beach Club on Stocking Island. Great stop! The beach is just right, the floating hammocks were perfect the swings, loungers, paddle boards & kayaks were perfect as well. But nothing beat the staff! Except the Mahi Tacos - we fish and catch & cook our our & were from California where we can get some of the best fish ever - however these ladies beat almost all grilled/blackened Mahi I have ever had! Wow do yourselves a favor and stop here!

The trip began how it ended, full of smiles! The resort is located in a town square area on the island where it is easy to get to the marina, the market, the yacht club or the perfect little breakfast spot across the road all by foot. The staff is more than welcoming starting with Ash near the front entrance to help with bags, offer advice and get the vibe of your group. When you make your way over to the private beach which is a peaceful boat ride away enjoying the crystal blue waters of the island you are greeted by vibrant personalities such as LaTroy and resort staff that will feel like family by the time you leave like Ro-Shawn.

Our 5th stay at the hotel. Missed seeing many of the employees I've come to know over the years! Disappointed my regular cab driver wasn't there #87 Metia whom was consider a friend as she was my first contact on the island.luckily we found her and she was happy to see her us! Always happy to see Ash he is family to the us and Kay is by far the best receptionist! The restaurant is much better

My experience at this hotel was very disappointing for several reasons.
First of all, the staff was not friendly. At no point did we feel welcomed.
Cleanliness was also a problem. The room was not in adequate condition, and on one occasion we left at 7:20 AM for an excursion and returned at 3:00 PM only to find that the room had still not been cleaned. I consider this a basic service that should be guaranteed.
Another important issue is the hotel’s beach. It is located on an island across from the hotel, which requires transportation by boat. On two occasions, the service was inefficient: the first time, despite having a scheduled time, our transfer was postponed by one hour, causing us to lose valuable beach time. The second time, we waited 25 minutes and the boat never arrived, without receiving any clear explanation.
Also, at the Beach Club we ordered food at the beach bar and waited over an hour to be served, which was excessive and disappointing.
In summary, the organization, cleanliness, and customer service did not meet our expectations.
Exuma is an incredible destination, and I will definitely return because the place itself is truly beautiful. However, I would absolutely not choose to stay at this hotel again.

Peace and Plenty is an awesome place. The staff is absolutely amazing—warm, attentive, and genuinely welcoming. The food is hands down some of the best in Exuma. Every visit feels special, whether you’re stopping in for a meal or spending the day enjoying the atmosphere. Highly recommend!

First of all this was an amazing stay and staff are exceptional.

One thing that stands out at this hotel is the amazing staff, everyone we had interaction with were super friendly and make you feel part of the family.

Huge shout out to Captain Charles, Rowshaun (sorry if mispelled) and of course Ashva - the life and soul of the P&P!

We booked an ocean view and the views are incredible; the room was big, modern and well equipped. There were some furnishings missing (handle on the cupboard), but it is so minor that it did not affect our stay at all. Lovely shower with views of the ocean and ample hot water.

We ate at the restaurant for breakfast and in the evening and the food is great; service is also friendly and attentive. The bar was also great with Mo, who grafts to service both the bar and the diners.

One thing which wasn’t advertised is the resort fee of approx €50 per day for amenities, I think this covered the use of beach towels and the shuttle boat to the beach club on stocking island. We would have paid this in any-case, but came as a surprise to us. There is also an 18% charge on dining as opposed to the usual Bahamian rate, but again I would have been happy to pay this to the amazing staff.

The hotel arranged taxi’s when and as requested, including for our departure to the airport - little things matter!

The beach club is simply paradise, with boats leaving every hour from the hotel and returning every half an hour from the club. Staff on the boats and on the beach club really go out of their way for you and should be commended. Even on busy days staff managed to get additional loungers. The use of free water-sports was very good. There may be some competition from the newly opened hotel which is accessible from the beach club and often saw hotel guests dining there for lunch, it may be an idea to offer something different to rival that, such as a open grill/BBQ!

There were some minor communication issues which is the only thing preventing a 5*. On one day with the weather being slightly choppier, the boat had not filled with fuel and there were 12 of us waiting for over an hour until we were later told of the reasons why, it would have been nice to know from the start so we could have maybe spent an hour elsewhere. We also found the pool had been drained for renovation on the last day and again weren’t given any heads up.

I can’t end this review without giving a huge shout out the islands very own Barry White, Mr ASHVA. Ashva runs the karaoke night on a Tuesday and he is not only an incredible singer but he brings the vibes and got a whole heap of us talking and interacting. He is also the life and soul of the hotel, whether it’s a smiling good morning or a spontaneous song as you leave on the boat, a truly one of a kind character. It would be great for more evening entertainment from Ashva, with maybe an additional night of him just performing - it wont be long before he is snapped up and singing around the island!

We would be back in a heartbeat, despite a few communication issues, staff are more than amenable to rectifying any issue!

Absolutley loved our stay at P&P! The location is central to everything and the beach club is super chill, also love the boat ride over, feels very James bond!
Huge shout out to the staff!
Ash is the man! So friendly, knowledgeable and his Karaoke night was really a great time! He is truly the GOAT.
Also shout outs to Rashad and Mo the nicest bartenders!! Our server Lendesha
Who was fantastic!
The view from our room was epic! We definitely got the bang for our buck!
Highly recommend staying here!

Everything was amazing. Staff is fantastic and friendly. Especially Ash that hooked us up with ice for our cooler everytime we requested. Couldn’t recommend more.

Hotel amenities were good. Pool was never busy. Restaurant was convenient and good food. King room was newly renovated with great balcony and view of Stocking Island. Beach club was relaxing and fun and boat easy to get you there. Staff went above and beyond with arranging a private candlelight dinner on their beach for our 25th wedding anniversary! Thank you!

Excellent food and a variety of menu and cocktail options. Service was very friendly. I appreciate that there were several vegetarian options

Flight home was canceled, Peace & Plenty was so friendly and accommodating with our last minute needs. Highly recommend!

The staff could not have been more pleasant with everything that they did.
Brand new ocean view room was immaculate with perfect house cleaning every day.
Beautiful dining room with artfully present great food.

This was our first time here and the food was wonderful and ambience was amazing. Highly recommend this restaurant and will be back.

Had an incredible dining experience at Peace and Plenty! Zamaria took excellent care of us and her suggestion of the conch fritters was fabulous. The salmon cakes were also a personal fave! Not only was the food delicious but the staff was very attentive. Highly recommend!

Wonderful experience! Staff was amazing and very personable and helpful at all times. Went out of their way to help and set up trips, meals, etc. Will definitely be coming back. The Oceanview King Suite was very nice and has recently been remodeled. Highly recommend. Also very convenient location to both ends of island and across the street from awesome boat rental - Minn’s!

Nakeisha the general manager was excellent and really enjoyed the help from Kawanchia who arranged our private boat outing and Latroy who was always helpful!

Lex was our boat captain taking us on the shuttle across bay and always available and very helpful to find places to snorkel and visit.

We went in early October and it rained most of the time. There was a mosquito infestation which made staying outside impossible. There was very limited things to do because businesses were closed and the ones that were open. Oddly enough felt like they were doing you a favor When they waited on you, rang your groceries or took your drink order. Everything was extremely expensive. I would think that a place that relies on tourism would try harder to keep people happy but I can assure you I will never be back. This is not just the resort but the entire Area.

Peace and Plenty came to the rescue when our accommodation at St Francis Resort was cancelled due to a storm then power and water issues.

We stayed in a beautiful room overlooking the ocean. The team here are friendly, professional and warm.

The food is great as is the tequila.

Thank you to all the team for looking after us so well during a challenging time on the island.

I cannot warn you enough to NOT stay at this property. On July 4, 2025, they mistakenly charged me $2,202.44. I called them, and they admitted their mistake. They told me I would get a refund on my card in 10 - 14 days. It is now Sept 11, 2025 and counting, and I still do not have my money back. I have called several times, and Expedia has also tried to help by calling them several times. Each time, they admit their mistake, promise they will be issuing a refund that day, and I will of course receive it in another 10 to 14 days. We have been told that 4 times now, and nothing has been done. I strongly advise you to choose another hotel. This one has zero integrity and zero urgency to help someone recover over $2,000 that they admit they mistakenly charged me. I know I will never return to this property.

I cannot warn you enough to NOT stay at this property. On July 4, 2025, they mistakenly charged me $2,202.44. I called them, and they admitted their mistake. They told me I would get a refund on my card in 10 - 14 days. It is now Sept 11, 2025 and counting, and I still do not have my money back. I have called several times, and Expedia has also tried to help by calling them several times. Each time, they admit their mistake, promise they will be issuing a refund that day, and I will of course receive it in another 10 to 14 days. We have been told that 4 times now, and nothing has been done. I strongly advise you to choose another hotel. This one has zero integrity and zero urgency to help someone recover over $2,000 that they admit they mistakenly charged me. I know I will never return to this property.

Beautiful place. Staff was great. Extremely Friendly.