AmericInn by Wyndham Fort Atkinson

Hotels
•
Wyndham Hotels & Resorts
8.2 (201 reviews)
1225 Janesville Ave, Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin, 53538 , Fort Atkinson , US

Pets allowed

Facilities

Fireplace in lobby
Television in common areas
Free breakfast
Smoke-free property
Wheelchair accessible parking
24-hour business center
Free self parking
Computer station
Free continental breakfast
Water dispenser
See all facilities

Review Highlights

Pros:
Excellent location next to Fireside Dinner Theatre
Friendly, helpful staff
Nice pool, hot tub and gazebo area
Many guests found rooms clean and comfortable
Free breakfast often praised
Safe neighborhood
Cons:
Recurring cleanliness and odor problems (mold/mildew, damp sheets, chemical smell)
Room maintenance issues (peeling paint, cracked/peeling tub, sticky floors, broken curtains/shades)
Inconsistent breakfast quality; some spoiled items reported
Complaints about extra/unexplained charges and refund handling
Occasional severe issues forcing guests to leave

Categories

Cleanliness
6.5
Mixed reports: several guests praised clean rooms, but multiple serious cleanliness issues reported (mold/mildew smell, damp sheets, bugs, yellowing bathroom, peeling tub and paint).
Service
9.6
Generally very positive: staff repeatedly described as fantastic, pleasant, excellent and accommodating in multiple reviews.
Location
9.8
Strongly positive: repeatedly noted as ideal and convenient next to the Fireside Dinner Theatre and in a safe neighborhood.
Room Quality
7
Mixed: some rooms described as roomy and nice, but several reports of upkeep issues (sticky floors, malfunctioning AC, curtains, cracked/peeling tub, damp/chemical smells).
Amenities
9.5
Positive mentions of pool, hot tub and gazebo; pool area popular for families and frequently praised.
Value for Money
7
Mixed to negative: some guests felt the price was too high for the room condition and noted unexpected deposit/charges; others found rates reasonable.
Food and Beverage
7.2
Variable: breakfast was described as delicious by some and minimal or with spoiled items by others; generally adequate but inconsistent.
Overall Experience
9
Generally positive experiences reported (clean/comfortable rooms, friendly staff, great location and amenities) but tempered by several serious incidents (health-affecting AC/odor issues, refunds/charges problems) that impacted some stays.
* This sentiment is summarized by AI based on user reviews.
Updated at: 2026-11-05 14:16

Property Description

Recreational Amenities for Relaxation: Enjoy the indoor pool and spa tub for a relaxing stay. The hotel also offers a picnic area and complimentary wireless internet.

Convenient Services: Benefit from amenities such as 24-hour room service, a complimentary continental breakfast, and free self-parking during your stay.

Comfortable Accommodations: Unwind in one of the 58 air-conditioned rooms with modern conveniences like flat-screen TVs and deep soaking bathtubs. Stay connected with complimentary wireless internet access.

Book your stay at AmericInn by Wyndham Fort Atkinson to enjoy a perfect blend of relaxation and convenience during your visit!

Important information:

  • Pool access available from 9:00 AM to 10:00 PM.
  • Contactless check-in and contactless check-out are available.

A deposit may be required at the property.

Check-in and check-out hours:
Check-out: 11:00 AM
Airport code: MSN

Property Policies

  • Pets

    Only dogs and cats are allowed

  • Pets

    Service animals are exempt from fees/restrictions

  • Noise policy

    Noise-free rooms not guaranteed

  • Check-in & Check-out

    Contactless check-out is available

  • Guest type

    Essential workers only - NO

See all policies

Location

Guest Reviews

8.2
Based on 201 reviews
Cleanliness: 6.5
Service: 9.6
Location: 9.8
Room Quality: 7
Amenities: 9.5
Value for Money: 7
Food and Beverage: 7.2
Overall Experience: 9
8
892lovep • NONE
10
Awesome Stay
Pros:

I simply wanted to express my appreciation for such a wonderful stay. The location next to the Fireside Dinner Theatre was ideal and incredibly convenient.

The team was fantastic, our room was clean and roomy, and we thoroughly enjoyed the pool, hot tub, and the delicious breakfast.

We truly valued the entire experience and will absolutely choose to stay again!

2026-02-20 • via Tripadvisor
3
351nancid • Couples
8
Don’t judge a book by its cover!
Pros:

We almost cancelled our reservation when we drove up. The outside is really shabby looking. The window curtains were horrible looking from the outside.

But the hotel was very nice inside. Clean. Friendly. Nice pool area. Excellent location if your are going to the Fireside Theater.

2026-01-10 • via Tripadvisor
R
R4408KVbethm • NONE • West Allis, Wisconsin
10
Hotel experience
Pros:

Good hotel especially for staying if utilizing The Fireside entertainment center. Good neighborhood, felt very safe.

2025-11-09 • via Tripadvisor
3
374hungp • NONE
4
Interrupted Trip
Pros:

Nice, clean room. Pleasant staff. Easy check-in. Reasonable rates for quality of room. The bads: Air conditioner was not working properly, causing the room to be very hot and made us really sick, affecting our planned activities the next day. We had to cut short our trip and went home so disappointed. Breakfast was very minimal and some food items were already spoiled, inedible.

2025-10-28 • via Tripadvisor
C
christied671 • Family • Orland Park, Illinois
8
Clean, safe, friendly. A little run down.
Pros:

Clean, safe, friendly. Comfy beds. Free breakfast. Really nice gazebo area. Pool that was active - great for families. Good effort from the staff, but definitely run down and in need of renovations. Bathroom had mild yellowing from age. There were a few bugs flying around (hoping fruit flys).

2025-10-22 • via Tripadvisor
S
Scott
8
Pros:

Our room was nice except the curtains let in a lot of light from the parking lot. The pool area was nice. Breakfast was good with a small variety.

2025-10-12 • via Nuitee
J
Jamie
6
Pros:

the hotel has some updating needed. my bathroom was missing paint on the walls. The tub had some cracking or peeling on the floor. Wouldnt wven use the shower. The bed had a cloth skirt and at the corners by the headboard you could see it was all dusty. I would probably not go back because we were charged 179.00 and this is a 90 at best room! The breakfast area was nice and the offerings were decent. The front desk staff was very nice and accommodating.

2025-10-12 • via Nuitee
A
Aidan • family
8
Pros:

Good hotel for one night, still some room for improvement.

2025-10-10 • via Nuitee
M
marvin
6
Pros:


2025-10-09 • via Nuitee
D
Desiree • partner
2
Pros:

Walked in our room and slaps you in the face with mold in mildew smell. The sheets felt damp. We called to move rooms, but because of the whitewater event nothing was available. The hotel desk attendant said they would talk to the manager to give a refund and we still have not seen it or been contacted. Immediately our allergies and having total stuffy noses made it even worse and uncomfortable to sleep there. We couldn’t leave. It was too late to drive and we live far

2025-10-06 • via Nuitee
M
Mary
10
Pros:

Great stay

2025-10-06 • via Nuitee
B
Betty • partner
6
Pros:

The staff was excellent, but for what I payed for the room I was expecting it to be nicer. The bathroom door was sticking and the floor was sticky.

2025-10-05 • via Nuitee
R
Ronald • partner
10
Pros:

Fine

2025-10-03 • via Nuitee
L
Linda • partner
2
Pros:

Room had the smell of a strong chemical that was so bad we decided we could not stay. Booked through Expedia but management of the hotel refused to refund our stay. We had to find another room at 12:30 am and ended up paying for two hotel rooms for 5 nights. If you care about your health and well being. Do not book this hotel.

2025-10-02 • via Nuitee
B
Bryan
4
Pros:

Getting slapped with an addition charge when checking in for no realistic reason is very bad customer relations. Desk staff also was not thorough in explaining what this "deposit" was for. This was not revealed in the reservation info and will affect me considering Amercinn in the future. Also, window shades were ripped and did not function properly.

2025-09-29 • via Nuitee
R
Rebecca
6
Pros:

Nothing special. A place to rest our heads after a family event.

2025-09-26 • via Nuitee
K
Katelyn • family_with_children
2
Pros:

Bathrooms were terrible. Floors disgusting, showers didn’t drain, mildew in bathroom. Bedding had multiple yellow stains on both beds. Shower curtain was stained purple in multiple spots. Spiders in the rooms. Service was fast though when needed. Lock to the door broke and toilet stopped working but they were quick to fix both. Outside of building is run down and needs major touch ups. Hallways smell really bad, like smoke.

2025-09-22 • via Nuitee
J
JILL • partner
10
Pros:

Property has been recently renovated. Room was clean and comfortable. Pool area very nice. Staff was very accommodating. Will definitely stay there again when in the area.

2025-09-21 • via Nuitee
G
GERALDINE • family
10
Pros:

walking distance to the Fireside Theater.
Ver clean an

2025-09-13 • via Nuitee
J
Jacqueline
10
Pros:

The staff were

2025-09-12 • via Nuitee