The Audubon Inn

Hotels
Independent
8.8 (75 reviews)
45 North Main Street, Mayville, Wisconsin, 53050 , Mayville , US

Pets allowed

Facilities

Meeting rooms
Fitness facilities
Express check-out
Area shuttle (surcharge)
24-hour front desk
Luggage storage
Express check-in/check-out
Concierge service
Picnic area
Elevator
See all facilities

Review Highlights

Pros:
Beautiful place
Comfortable beds
Great location
Historical building
Spacious rooms
Friendly staff
Cons:
Limited parking
Expensive breakfast
No spa services
Minor maintenance issues
Long wait times for service

Categories

Cleanliness
8
Guests consistently mentioned cleanliness as a positive aspect.
Service
8.1
Service was generally appreciated, although a few guests had complaints about wait times.
Location
8.3
The hotel is located in close proximity to many key landmarks and public transport.
Room Quality
7.8
Rooms were spacious and comfortable, although some guests mentioned minor maintenance issues.
Amenities
7.2
The amenities provided were satisfactory, with some guests highlighting the gym and pool, while others mentioned the lack of spa services.
Value for Money
6.9
Some guests felt that the price was a bit high for the services offered, while others thought it was reasonable given the location.
Food and Beverage
7.3
Breakfast and restaurant services were generally well-received, although a few guests thought there could be more variety.
Overall Experience
8
Most guests had a positive overall experience and would recommend the hotel to others.
* This sentiment is summarized by AI based on user reviews.
Updated at: 2025-06-28 01:29

Property Description

Luxurious Spa and Fitness Center
Indulge yourself with massages, facials, and a relaxing spa tub. Stay fit at the fitness center during your stay at this Victorian hotel.

Fine Dining and Room Service
Savor delicious meals at NOLA North Grille or opt for cozy room service. Enjoy your favorite drink at the on-site bar/lounge for a complete dining experience.

Elegant Rooms with Modern Amenities
Relax in one of the 18 stylish guestrooms with private spa tubs and LED TVs. Stay connected with complimentary Wi-Fi and enjoy designer toiletries and daily housekeeping services.

Experience a blend of luxury and convenience at The Audubon Inn in Mayville. Book your stay now for a memorable upscale retreat.

Important information:

  • Reservations are required for massage services. Reservations can be made by contacting the hotel prior to arrival, using the contact information on the booking confirmation.
  • Up to 2 children 4 years old and younger stay free when occupying the parent or guardian's room, using existing bedding.
  • The property allows pets in specific rooms only and has other pet restrictions (surcharges apply and can be found in the Fees section). Guests can arrange to bring pets by contacting the property directly, using the contact information on the booking confirmation.

Check-in and check-out hours:
Check-out: 11:00 AM
Airport code: OSH

Property Policies

  • Pets

    Maximum number of pets per room 2

  • Pets

    Only dogs and cats are allowed

  • Pets

    Service animals are exempt from fees/restrictions

  • Pets

    Pet max weight (per pet) in kg is 50

  • Children and extra beds

    No rollaway/extra beds available

See all policies

Location

Guest Reviews

8.8
Based on 75 reviews
Cleanliness: 8
Service: 8.1
Location: 8.3
Room Quality: 7.8
Amenities: 7.2
Value for Money: 6.9
Food and Beverage: 7.3
Overall Experience: 8
J
Jimmy
2
Pros:

They called me and told me my reservation was canceled because they were going out of business.

2019-10-28 via Nuitee
V
Verified traveler
2
Pros:

The place was locked up when we got there. Apparently the owner had left town about 3 weeks ago. Very disappointed that everything looked ok online in terms of reservation and confirmations. Not sure who to blame.

2019-08-10 via Nuitee
V
Verified traveler partner
10
Pros:

Very unique property. was very sad to learn we're some of the last customers.

2019-06-02 via Nuitee
V
Verified traveler partner
4
Pros:

Found toys and scraps of paper on the ground from the previous guest, bed seemed too small to be a Queen, air conditioning did not work and our room was at 79 degrees at 10PM. Staff downstairs was not working past 8PM so nothing would be done about it.

Bathroom was very nice.

Will not be coming back.

2019-05-06 via Nuitee
V
Verified traveler self
6
Pros:

Restaurant was closed for remodeling and not disclosed when booking.

2019-05-01 via Nuitee
V
Verified traveler self
10
Pros:

A great, beautiful, historical property, but with great amenities on property or very close by.
The gathering areas on each floor are wonderful and beautiful on their own and the room was peaceful and quiet.
I will definitely stay again to take in the historical sights and Horicon Marsh Wildlife area as I was visiting relatives on this trip. A definite Must Stay!

2019-04-21 via Nuitee
V
Verified traveler
8
Historic, Comfortable, Clean and Quiet
Pros:

I really loved this place. The building was interesting to look at, the bed was soft, and the room was very clean--including the comforter, which apparently some hotels in Wisconsin definitely do not do. The only thing that wasn't perfect was that some parts of our room needed some maintenance. For example, one of the switches on the whirlpool tub was kind of broken, and we had to try it like 10 times before the tub would turn on. The bathroom door was stuck in the doorjamb--which meant that I was actually stuck in the bathroom once until my husband could come and open it. That said, we will 100% return to this hotel if we are ever staying in the area again. My husband and I were kind of sad that we probably won't be coming through Wisconsin again any time soon!

2019-04-11 via Nuitee
R
ROBERT
6
By ourselves!
Pros:

Nice place. A little spooky. We were the only ones staying at hotel. Girl at front desk very nice and showed us to our room.Room was nice and clean. She left and nobody came back that we know about. Even when we left in the morning at about 10 am there still was no one there.We did have a key to the front door but no one else was in the hotel. Nice lounge on each floor. Had trouble working some light in room. Place was nice. Hotel was on corner of the downtown area. Could walk to some of the restaurants.

2019-04-08 via Nuitee
V
Verified traveler
8
Pros:

This is a very unique place to stay. We had a very relaxing time. Enjoyed the jetted tub. I would recomend they add safety handles in the shower. Was difficult getting in and out.
Parking is an issue you have to park on the street but not allowed to park on Main Street overnight in front of the hotel.

2019-03-31 via Nuitee
B
Badger family
10
Pros:

An excellent experience. Quaint setting in a neat town. Walking distance up and down the main street including local cafes and coffee. Rooms neat and tidy.

2019-03-28 via Nuitee
V
Verified traveler family
8
Pros:

It was a historic building and was very tastefully decorated to give a feeling from a different era. The receptionist was very pleasant and helpful.

2019-03-28 via Nuitee
R
Renee
4
Pros:

Cozy room, comfy bed.
We were made to feel unwelcome into the bar for a beverage unless we agreed to a $100.00 dinner!
So we went elsewhere for beverage and meal.

2019-03-24 via Nuitee
V
Verified traveler partner
10
Pros:

Charming in an old fashioned way.
Reasonable.
Jacuzzi.
TV was small screen, but okay.
Right in town, but parking okay.

2019-03-22 via Nuitee
V
Verified traveler partner
8
Pros:

The rooms are large and clean bathtub was wonderful. Infused ice water waiting for us in the room. Bed was a little saggy but still comfortable. Cute small town.

2019-03-16 via Nuitee
V
Verified traveler partner
6
Pros:

Staff were very accommodating and pleasant. Place is a little outdated but to be expected for a historical building. Zero breakfast options. Has the feel of a bed & breakfast, without the breakfast. Would have loved a basket of muffins at the door in the morning. Very cozy and spa options were a plus. Facility charges prior to your stay, including any added services which was a little bit of a surprise.

2019-02-18 via Nuitee
G
Gary
10
Audubon Inn - February 2019
Pros:

Authentic old time hotel with retro style and a great attached restaurant and bar. Enjoyed the unique food prepared by a 4 star chef. Very convenient to Horicon, WI, home to a large employer. Would recommend it to anyone.

2019-02-16 via Nuitee
K
Karen
10
Hoilday Happiness !
Pros:

The Inn absolutely deserves your attention! My stay was amazing for Holiday traveling. The room was very spacious, bed was fantastic, and each levels lounge areas made it feel like your own little home. Staff was wonderful, they were right there if you needed anything or quietly in the back round letting you explore and relax. Historic charm and beauty. Only draw back was the town itself not having more shops in those historic buildings of their main street. Still the Inn is worth a stay.

2019-01-01 via Nuitee
J
John
10
You should stay in the romantic place
Pros:

The room and bathroom very nice. Comfortable surroundings in the hotel. Love the atrium. The full course dinner is worth it.

2018-11-19 via Nuitee
V
Verified traveler
10
Pros:

Charming historic Inn beautifully decorated with antiques. Warm, welcoming staff and nice touches, like a cafe of fruit infused ice water on bedside table.

2018-11-05 via Nuitee
C
Carol
10
Pros:

This is a beautiful hotel. It has a great ambiance, and you feel like you have stepped back into time, all while being very pampered! I loved it.

2018-11-05 via Nuitee