Faraway Sag Harbor

Hotels
8.9 (247 reviews)
31 W. Water Street , Sag Harbor , us

Free
Children allowed

Facilities

Free beach shuttle
Offsite parking discounted rates available
Electric bicycle charging station
Fitness facilities (surcharge)
Air conditioning
Swimming pool
Restaurant
Room service
Terrace
Family rooms
See all facilities

Review Highlights

Pros:
Great location
Friendly staff
Comfortable amenities
Good food and beverage options
Relaxing atmosphere
Cons:
Musty smells in rooms
Some staffing issues reported
Limited food availability at times

Categories

Cleanliness
7.98
Several reviews mentioned musty smells and issues with room cleanliness.
Service
9.45
Staff is noted as friendly and attentive, providing a good overall service experience.
Location
9.49
Consistently praised as convenient and charming; very walkable.
Room Quality
8.44
Mixed reviews on room quality with mentions of mustiness but also comfort.
Amenities
9.47
Amenities were highlighted positively, including the pool and restaurant.
Value for Money
8.43
Some complaints regarding pricing, but overall good value for quality.
Food and Beverage
8.98
Food quality was praised, though some items were unavailable.
Overall Experience
8.95
General consensus reflects a pleasant stay with some minor issues.
* This sentiment is summarized by AI based on user reviews.
Updated at: 2025-12-11 21:39

Property Description

Luxurious Accommodations
Baron's Cove in Sag Harbor offers elegantly furnished guest rooms equipped with modern amenities, including flat-screen TVs and luxurious bathrobes. Select rooms even provide stunning views of the sea or garden, ensuring a memorable stay.

Gourmet Dining Experience
Indulge in a culinary journey at the on-site restaurant, where you can savor fresh American cuisine for lunch and dinner daily. Treat yourself to a delightful breakfast and brunch on the weekends, promising a delectable start to your day.

Leisure and Activities
From relaxing by the seasonal saltwater swimming pool to exploring the picturesque surroundings on a bike hired from the hotel, Baron's Cove provides ample opportunities for leisure and recreation. The 24-hour front desk is always ready to assist, ensuring a seamless and enjoyable stay.

Book your stay at Baron's Cove in Sag Harbor today for a luxurious and unforgettable experience.

Important information:

Our seasonal outdoor swimming pool is open from Memorial Day and closes on the Sunday of Columbus Day Weekend *Weather permitting.Guests are required to show a photo ID and credit card upon check-in. Please note that all Special Requests are subject to availability and additional charges may apply.

Check-in and check-out hours:
Check-out: 12:00 PM

Property Policies

  • Parking

    Free private parking is possible on site (reservation is not needed).

  • Internet

    WiFi is available in all areas and is free of charge.

  • Pets

    Pets are not allowed.

  • Children and extra bed policy

    Children of any age are allowed.
    Children up to and including 1 year old stay for US$25 per person per night when using an available cot.
    Children up to and including 5 years old stay for free when using an existing bed.
    Children up to and including 11 years old stay for free when using an available extra bed.
    People 12 years old and over stay for US$25 per person per night when using an available extra bed.
    Any type of extra bed or child's cot/crib is upon request and needs to be confirmed by management.
    Supplements are not calculated automatically in the total costs and will have to be paid for separately during your stay.

Location

Guest Reviews

8.9
Based on 247 reviews
Cleanliness: 7.98
Service: 9.45
Location: 9.49
Room Quality: 8.44
Amenities: 9.47
Value for Money: 8.43
Food and Beverage: 8.98
Overall Experience: 8.95
P
Philip family_with_children gb
10
2026-01-19 via Nuitee
K
Katherine
10
Pros:

Parking was free and really easy. Great proximity to the main street of town—you can easily walk, but it's not too close where it gets loud at night. The front staff and cleaning team were all lovely and super helpful. We loved the coffee bar in the mornings.

2025-10-01 via Nuitee
A
andrew partner
8
Pros:

staff seemed tired and fed up of people staying!

2025-09-25 via Nuitee
I
Ivonne
10
Pros:

Quaint hotel in town. It’s perfect!

2025-09-24 via Nuitee
R
richard
6
Pros:

Very standard
Not an extra bottle of water
Nothing more than what is offered
Basic, just fine

2025-09-21 via Nuitee
J
john partner
4
Pros:

Sadly in need of a renovation. Extremely poor value but front desk staff was super nice. You will be underwhelmed by the rooms. The “garden rooms” overlook the parking lot. I would not stay there again.

2025-09-20 via Nuitee
A
andrew couple gb
10
2025-09-16 via Nuitee
S
Sam couple gb
9
2025-09-16 via Nuitee
N
natasha family_with_children us
6
2025-09-13 via Nuitee
D
Donald couple us
9
2025-08-27 via Nuitee
M
Marano couple ar
8
Sag Harbour Top!
2025-08-26 via Nuitee
E
Ellena family
6
Pros:

One of our two rooms smelled like a dirty wet sock. Requested management move us to another room. Got moved after the first night.

Housekeeping good but rooms need some new ventilation units. It would be nice to have turndown service for the average daily rate



2025-08-22 via Nuitee
A
Andrea couple us
8
Pros:

Location

Cons:

No complaints

2025-08-21 via Nuitee
J
James
6
Pros:

-

2025-08-17 via Nuitee
L
Lisa couple us
9
A low key relaxing stay with great food and drinks
Pros:

This was our 6th or 7th time here and we always look forward going at least once a summer.

Cons:

The only negative thing would be that at dinner there was a few things not available. Maybe a little short staffed at the bar, pool and front desk. Housekeeping is always excellent!

2025-08-15 via Nuitee
C
Christine partner
10
Pros:

Barons Cove Inn is very well located i.e. walkable to pretty much everything. It’s also charming, somewhat quirky, clean, comfortable, has very nice room amenities and internet access, a friendly attentive staff, a nice bar and restaurant, a lovely pool, is waterfront and has a great front porch with rockers. What’s not to like? We’ll definitely be making return visits.

2025-08-11 via Nuitee
G
Glorie
8
Pros:

The privacy factor.

2025-08-09 via Nuitee
R
Robert couple us
10
We had a wonderful stay and look forward to another visit
Pros:

Onsite dining, friendly staff

Cons:

What’s not to like?

2025-08-08 via Nuitee
M
Margaret family
8
Pros:

Baron’s Cove is small but charming; the staff are very pleasant and helpful. If you want to see more of the Hamptons I recommend renting a car before you come!

2025-08-08 via Nuitee
R
rick
2
Pros:

Room smelled awful musty mgmt didn’t move us until next day

2025-08-04 via Nuitee