Atlantic Inn

Hotels
8.9 (107 reviews)
359 High St , New Shoreham , us

Facilities

Offsite parking discounted rates available
Non-smoking rooms
Air conditioning
Restaurant
Terrace
Family rooms
Luggage storage
Non-smoking throughout
Board games/puzzles
Concierge service
See all facilities

Review Highlights

Pros:
Great staff
Wonderful property
Excellent service
Stunning views
Cons:
Lack of amenities
Limited breakfast options
Noise issues

Categories

Cleanliness
8.23
No mention of cleanliness, but issues highlighted with maintenance and oversight.
Service
9.9
Service was excellent with friendly staff eager to help.
Location
9.74
Stunning views from the porch and lawn, great location overall.
Room Quality
9.19
Room felt fresh and up-to-date with modern upgrades.
Amenities
8.52
Amenities were lacking, notably the absence of coffee and breakfast options.
Value for Money
7.68
Perceived value was low given the price without key amenities.
Food and Beverage
8.23
Breakfast was minimal and coffee service lacking, but the restaurant looked inviting.
Overall Experience
9.7
An immensely satisfying weekend with great first impressions.
* This sentiment is summarized by AI based on user reviews.
Updated at: 2025-12-12 01:18

Property Description

Charming Accommodation in New Shoreham
Nestled in New Shoreham just steps away from Ballard's Beach, Atlantic Inn offers a serene retreat with a garden, free parking, and a delightful restaurant.

Convenient Location
Explore nearby attractions like Baby Beach and Fred Benson Town Beach, all within walking distance from the hotel.

Comfortable Rooms with Amenities
Relax in rooms featuring private bathrooms, free toiletries, and some with kitchenettes. Enjoy a cozy stay with quality bed linen and towels provided.

Ready to experience a relaxing getaway at Atlantic Inn? Book your stay now for a memorable vacation.

Important information:

Guests are required to show a photo ID and credit card upon check-in. Please note that all Special Requests are subject to availability and additional charges may apply.
Guests under the age of 18 can only check in with a parent or official guardian.

Check-in and check-out hours:
Check-out: 11:00 AM

Location

Guest Reviews

8.9
Based on 107 reviews
Cleanliness: 8.23
Service: 9.9
Location: 9.74
Room Quality: 9.19
Amenities: 8.52
Value for Money: 7.68
Food and Beverage: 8.23
Overall Experience: 9.7
R
Robert partner
10
Pros:

Classic New England Inn with wonderful views and service. Great hotel bar and drinks on the lawn out front was a highlight. Dinner in the restaurant was excellent.

2025-10-10 via Nuitee
I
Isabella extended_group us
9
2025-09-29 via Nuitee
T
Thomas partner
10
Pros:

Great staff wonderful property

2025-08-31 via Nuitee
V
Verified traveler
10
Pros:

Service was excellent! All staff were so friendly and eager to help. Room exactly as described. Small but well appointed. Such a great environment that I wish they also served breakfast.

2025-08-28 via Nuitee
N
Nicole family
10
Pros:

Simply amazing. Highly recommend

2025-08-23 via Nuitee
K
Kristina
8
Pros:

Everything was great. I had a charge that I have to look into, but other than that we had a great experience.

2025-08-17 via Nuitee
K
Kenneth partner
8
Pros:

Great view well kept property. Nice place to sit outside have a cocktail and look out over the water. Boasts a high quality restaurant yet did not put out coffee in the morning or have in room coffee service despite the nearest location was fifteen minutes away For avg price of 400 plus per night cannot even put out coffee and a continental breakfast for guests. Please cheap.

2025-08-16 via Nuitee
N
Nicole partner
6
Pros:

Very little aid to a first time visitor to block island. No mention of beach towels; had to ask specifically for key and room number when it wasn't offered after we checked in. Music in bar started at 5am on a Tuesday morning and no one was around to turn it off. Could be heard for hours in our room with no one around to open up the bar and turn it off. No accommodation or apology given. No food or coffee around. Better to stay across the street at Spring House Hotel where you could find a breakfast sandwich and coffee. Beautiful space for drinks on the lawn but that doesn't make up for the very, very laid back nature of everyone who works here.

2025-08-04 via Nuitee
P
Paul family
10
Pros:

very nice stay, hard working group, 2 keys to the room would have been nice

2025-08-03 via Nuitee
K
Katelynn partner
10
Pros:

Friendly staff

2025-08-03 via Nuitee
K
Kelly
10
Pros:

It was great

2025-08-02 via Nuitee
K
Karen family
10
Pros:

Loved staying at the Atlantic inn.

2025-07-28 via Nuitee
A
Anonymous family with young children us
9
An unforgettable long weekend on Block Island anchored by the allure of a revamped historic property
Pros:

Arrived earlier than check-in time (only so many ferries to choose from) and the front desk was kind enough to store our bags until the room was ready, which was a great first impression, as were the stunning views from the porch and lawn. This really is a special location. The room felt fresh and up-do-date, with noticeably modern upgrades to the air conditioning and bath amenities, but also charming in the way that long-lived and well-worn structures are. The same goes for the entry living room which, while small, was pleasantly furnished for a pause to refresh. I can't speak to the restaurant or the bar in terms of service or meals since we had other dining obligations but both spaces seemed inviting. The breakfast, which we opted to add to our booking only one morning, was minimal in its preparation but plentiful in basics, and felt like more than enough to get the day started. I thought it was actually well worth it given the alternative of seeking out a meal in town, but note that the fare is cold (except for the coffee!) We wanted to chance a swim on our last day as the weather was struggling to clear up and warm up so it was great to learn that beach towels are readily available for use since we didn't pack our own. All said, this was an immensely satisfying weekend and I truly enjoyed my stay. Many thanks to the kind and helpful staff for the experience!

Cons:

The check-in and check-out process felt a bit cramped in the office room, especially as other guests queued up and the luggage began to pile up. Other than that, no real issues!

2025-07-16 via Nuitee
S
Susan solo traveller us
9
Beautiful historic hotel amazing restaurant downstairs gentle easy staff room is a little small for the price.
Pros:

The location perched on top of the hill overlooking town Harbour and the small farm below was very nice. As long as you’re a walker, you can get around town from this location. My room is a little small even though I knew it was going to be small. It was a little smaller than I expected just navigating around. The bed was a little difficult, but this was the smallest room they offered. Otherwise it’s a very old building and they had a split system AC that cooled and worked wonderful pillows, bedding everything else was great. There was an absolutely amazing restaurant which was unexpected with a great bar and beautiful balcony and patio to dine on.

Cons:

There wasn’t much I didn’t like about the property other than the coffee service in the morning. The machine was difficult to use. The pods often fell through and if the machine was working properly, it would’ve been good, but it wasn’t and it frustrated many of the visitors there. You gotta give us coffee in the morning. Rooms at the Springhouse hotel, right next-door were less priced and that property more grand. I found 2 bugs in my room that I killed and reported to the front desk.

2025-07-14 via Nuitee
M
Maud friends
10
Pros:

This property is stunning. One of the statement places on the island. The staff is very courteous and accommodating. We had an issue with our room, they upgraded us for one of the most beautiful rooms, no questions asked!

2025-07-13 via Nuitee
D
Dan family
10
Pros:

Exquisite charm, elegant, fun, delightful….shall I go on? The Atlantic Inn a must stay on Block Island.

2025-07-10 via Nuitee
S
sarah
10
Pros:

Beautiful property. Amazing staff. Lovely stay

2025-07-09 via Nuitee
M
Mehwish family_with_children
6
Pros:

Over all it was a good and clean place. However, keep it mind there are no elevators and fridage and microwave in the rooms. We booked a suite. It was extremely tight space.

2025-07-09 via Nuitee
E
Erin partner
10
Pros:

This is a very beautiful hotel and we had a very enjoyable stay.

2025-07-08 via Nuitee
E
Erica F
10
Pros:

This is a beautiful place to stay on Block Island. The room (while a bit tiny) was well-appointed with modern facilities and products and all comforts. The staff is friendly and helpful, and the The Atlantic restaurant is excellent.

2025-06-26 via Nuitee