Oddfellows Hotel Bar & Restaurant

Hotels
Independent
8.8 (50 reviews)
High Street, Carlton DN14 9LY, Goole, England, DN14 9LY , Goole , GB

Facilities

Free breakfast
Front entrance ramp
Free WiFi
Terrace
Designated smoking area
Television in common areas
Free breakfast
Wheelchair accessible parking
Free reception
Free self parking
See all facilities

Review Highlights

Pros:
Friendly staff
Nice breakfast
Good location
Cons:
Inflexible chef
Misleading breakfast pricing
Poor room condition

Categories

Cleanliness
8.19
Concerns about cleanliness and maintenance due to issues with the door and general state of the room.
Service
9.66
Friendly and helpful staff but issues with the owner regarding pricing left a negative impression.
Location
9.7
Ideal location for wedding events and convenient parking.
Room Quality
7.65
Small and windowless room with concerns about entry due to door issues.
Amenities
9.18
Standard amenities available, but the breakfast situation was misleading.
Value for Money
8.14
Initial booking value diminished by unexpected surcharges and lack of included amenities.
Food and Beverage
8.69
Good food but limited menu options.
Overall Experience
9.16
Mixed feelings due to both positive staff interaction and disappointing issues.
* This sentiment is summarized by AI based on user reviews.
Updated at: 2026-01-10 04:22

Property Description

Scenic Terrace Views and Modern Amenities
Take in the breathtaking views from our terrace and enjoy complimentary wireless internet access throughout the property. Relax in our common area with a television, ideal for unwinding after a day of exploration.

Delightful Dining and Social Events
Indulge in a satisfying meal at our on-site restaurant and mingle with fellow guests at our daily complimentary reception. Quench your thirst with a refreshing drink at the bar/lounge and start your day right with a cooked-to-order breakfast served each morning.

Luxurious Room Features and Nearby Attractions
Retreat to one of our 9 guestrooms with Smart televisions and Select Comfort beds dressed in Egyptian cotton sheets. Refresh in private bathrooms with rainfall showerheads and designer toiletries. Explore nearby attractions like Carlton Towers Estate and Selby Abbey, located just a short drive away.
Book your stay at Oddfellows Hotel Bar & Restaurant for a memorable countryside retreat.

Important information:

  • Contactless check-in and contactless check-out are available.

Check-in and check-out hours:

Property Policies

  • Pets

    Pets not allowed

  • Check-in & Check-out

    Contactless check-out is available

  • Accessibility

    No elevators

  • General

    Professional property host/manager

  • Check-in & Check-out

    Contactless check-in is available

See all policies

Location

Guest Reviews

8.8
Based on 50 reviews
Cleanliness: 8.19
Service: 9.66
Location: 9.7
Room Quality: 7.65
Amenities: 9.18
Value for Money: 8.14
Food and Beverage: 8.69
Overall Experience: 9.16
G
Gail
6
Pros:

I’ve marked this down as the fire alarm was going off for well over an hour, everyone was out in the corridor as no-one could get hold of the owner. We were tired after being out for the evening and to come back to this was a nightmare!!! No apology nothing!! The chef was inflexible, the menu was incorrect.

2025-09-19 via Nuitee
A
Anatolii partner
8
Pros:

Ok for couple of nights. Nice breakfast. Very friendly staff.

2025-09-10 via Nuitee
M
Mark
8
Pros:

Friendly staff, great food

2025-08-22 via Nuitee
G
George
6
FYI: Not a free Breakfast
Pros:

Had been looking forward to the free breakfast as advertised, but told this was not included in the standard rate room. Staff suggested this is a common source of confusion for other guests too.

Otherwise ideal location for wedding at Camblesforth Hall. Good amount of parking and was pleasantly surprised by the interior of the bar as we walked in. Staff were friendly and showed us to the room which was nice enough, although the door needed a good barge to get in.

2025-08-18 via Nuitee
V
Verified traveler
2
Pros:

I booked a room 4 months in advance at a cheap rate with a hotels.com platinum membership discount and used my onekey credit.
On arrival, the owner made me "top up" the rate to 160% of the cost due to double occupancy instead of single (a genuine booking error), making my small, windowless room much less of a bargain.

I have no issue paying a surcharge for double occupancy, but am upset that my onekey cash was disregarded and mainly that the owner was so deeply unpleasant about the situation.

Watch out for the menu too - the one on offer doesn't match the website, there are no veggie options and the response on questioning was "that's the menu".

2025-08-18 via Nuitee
P
Philip
10
Pros:

Very welcoming and clean
Food excellent and choices vast
A good stop over

2025-06-11 via Nuitee
V
Verified traveler
8
Pros:

Worrying start when we arrived and the premises were closed. We didn’t arrive until 2.30 pm but no one arrived until 2.54 pm. The breakfast was very good, on both days. Very well presented.

2025-05-25 via Nuitee
T
thomas
6
Poor service and zero atmosphere
Pros:

Whilst the rooms have been recsently renovated to very high standard. The service was terrible. There were four of us staying from our company, the first 2 arrived and we're told that there was no food available this week because the owner was away. When I arrived a little later this was not explained to me by the staff nor was the situation with breakfast. Other than being walked to my room there was no other interaction from the staff.

The breakfast which was not dropped to my room but rather left with a colleague consisted of a packet of crisps and plain white bread premade sandwich a bottle of water and I think another couple of items. Presented to us in a paper bag. To quote my colleague " it looks like a child's party take home bag"

All of this is pretty disappointing if this was planned by the owner to be away this week and no food available we only booked last week and should have been made aware of this.

When I arrived the bar was completely empty and had zero atmosphere other than the 3 staff being there, having gone out for dinner we returned just after 9 pm to find that the bar was completely shut up curtains drawn.

Couldn't and wouldn't recommend this place to anyone, such a shame given the money spent on the rooms

2025-04-29 via Nuitee
D
David
10
Pros:

Nice room and fabulous food

2025-03-27 via Nuitee
M
Maureen
10
Pros:

Nice!

2025-03-24 via Nuitee
B
Ben
10
Pros:

Fantastic rooms great staff very friendly would definitely stop here again

2025-02-11 via Nuitee
L
Lawrence
8
Pros:

Would stay again if I was in the area

2025-01-25 via Nuitee
C
Chris
10
Pros:

Good room good food good service

2025-01-24 via Nuitee
M
Mark
8
Comfortable Stay
Pros:

We had a comfortable 2 nights stay. Room was clean and the bed was perfect for a good night's sleep. Only minor concern was the noisy extractor fan in the bathroom. Food in the restaurant was great.

2025-01-01 via Nuitee
J
Josie
10
Great Stay
Pros:

Great place to stay in Carlton I have been a regular here now for over a year and always get a great welcome. Breakfast is to die for.

2024-11-22 via Nuitee
A
Ann
8
Pros:

Nice small pub - good size room for 2 - modern facilities- clean & comfortable

2024-11-14 via Nuitee
S
susan partner
8
Pros:

First class accommodation except no shelf in the bathroom/wet room and the duvet felt more like a mattress (solid and heavy)

2024-11-11 via Nuitee
M
Margot partner
10
Pros:

Owner operated. Very friendly. Great food. Made us a super packed lunch in leiu of breakfast. Great value for money. Would highly recommend.

2024-09-27 via Nuitee
V
Verified traveler
2
Pros:

Ignored by staff when checking in. Took 15 minutes whilst they dried glasses and tried to get a beer pump to pull without fobbing.
Awful service

2024-08-30 via Nuitee
A
Alex
8
Pros:

Comfortable bed and pillows, clean bathroom with great shower. Nice tea and coffee tray. The best part was the delicious breakfast, cooked to order.

2024-08-29 via Nuitee