Hampton Bays Hotel On Main

Hotels
6.2 (66 reviews)
2 West Montauk Highway , Hampton Bays , us

Facilities

WiFi available
Free WiFi
Non-smoking rooms
Air conditioning
Restaurant
Room service
Bar
Non-smoking throughout
Staff adhere to local safety protocols
Cashless payment available
See all facilities

Review Highlights

Pros:
Clean rooms
Good location
Friendly staff
Cons:
Noisy environment
Small room size
Limited amenities

Categories

Cleanliness
6.7
Several reviews indicate that the rooms were clean, but there were some concerns about size and noise.
Service
7.2
Mixed feedback on service with some frustrations regarding check-in and support during luggage access.
Location
7.7
Good location near attractions, though noisy due to nearby bar and traffic.
Room Quality
5.2
Rooms described as too small with noise issues, although clean and equipped.
Amenities
4.7
Limited amenities; no on-site parking, and noise from the bar affects relaxation.
Value for Money
5.7
Pricing is considered affordable relative to location, but quality may not match expectations.
Food and Beverage
6.2
The bar downstairs received positive feedback, but noise levels were a concern.
Overall Experience
6.2
Mixed feelings about the stay, with some guests enjoying it and others disappointed.
* This sentiment is summarized by AI based on user reviews.
Updated at: 2025-12-11 02:49

Property Description

Modern Accommodations
Indulge in our stylish non-smoking rooms equipped with all the comforts you need for a relaxing stay.

On-Site Dining
Savor delectable dishes at our convenient on-site restaurant featuring a diverse menu to satisfy every palate.

Prime Location
Explore nearby attractions like Splish Splash and Montauk Point Lighthouse, all within a short drive from our hotel.

Ready to experience the best of Hampton Bays? Book your stay at Hampton Bays Hotel On Main now!

Important information:

This property offers online self-check-in only.

There's no reception desk at the property.Guests are required to show a photo ID and credit card upon check-in. Please note that all Special Requests are subject to availability and additional charges may apply.
This property does not accommodate bachelor(ette) or similar parties.
Payment before arrival by bank transfer is required. The property will contact you after you book to provide instructions.
A deposit may be required at the property.

Check-in and check-out hours:
Check-out: 11:00 AM

Location

Guest Reviews

6.2
Based on 66 reviews
Cleanliness: 6.7
Service: 7.2
Location: 7.7
Room Quality: 5.2
Amenities: 4.7
Value for Money: 5.7
Food and Beverage: 6.2
Overall Experience: 6.2
R
Rafael couple es
10
Correcte i preu a la zona inmillorable
Pros:

Entrada codificada, envien al correo habitació i codi d'entrada
Molt net i nou

Cons:

No té parking propi, sí n'hi ha a centres comercials i supermercats a 50 m
Aire condicionat fort central sense regulació individual ( cal tancar una mica sortida del sostre.

2026-07-06 via Nuitee
K
Karen solo_traveller us
1
2026-06-11 via Nuitee
E
Elizabeth solo_traveller us
8
2026-05-09 via Nuitee
M
Meghan extended_group us
8
Cons:

No AC in room

2026-04-20 via Nuitee
F
Frances couple us
3
If you don’t mind being a part of the action then this place is for you; otherwise go somewhere else.
Pros:

Our room was big with a comfortable bed and a large bathroom.

Cons:

No parking on property, loud street noise and from the bar downstairs, no one to contact, not enough towels, no USB ports to charge phones, felt like a hostel not a hotel.

2026-03-18 via Nuitee
M
Marjolaine solo_traveller us
5
2026-01-19 via Nuitee
H
HELLYN couple us
10
10\10
Pros:

Everything.. i deff loved it and also loved that even tho its on main street there was a minimum outside noise !! 10/10

Cons:

I did not dislike anything

2025-12-22 via Nuitee
D
Dennis couple cr
10
2025-12-22 via Nuitee
P
Paul couple us
9
2025-12-14 via Nuitee
F
Francesco couple it
3
Un’esperienza negativa, albergo troppo piccolo e poco confortevole.
Pros:

La posizione era comoda nel centro di Hampton Bays, che è comodo per tutte le città degli Hamptons.

Cons:

La prima sera il pub al piano terra sotto la stanza aveva la musica altissima, da discoteca, fino alle tre di notte e senza insonorizzazione. L’aria condizionata non si può regolare, ma al massimo chiudere la bocchetta senza nemmeno poter spegnere il motore. Non è previsto il servizio di pulizia in camera durante il soggiorno. La camera è troppo piccola, non si riesce a stare in due con i bagagli. Il bagno è troppo piccolo.

2025-10-25 via Nuitee
A
Augustus Cochran couple us
3
Pros:

Room was clean and comfortable, although fairly small. Location is good, near several cute coffee shops and restaurants. Bar downstairs was nice, and bartender was very friendly and tun to talk to.

Cons:

We experienced several problems. The rooms are over a bar, but that is not the real problem since the sound is muffled and the bar closes at midnight. The problem was the loud, drunken conversations that took place outside and lasted until about 2 a.m. Because there is no a/c, it was uncomfortable to close the windows, and even closing the windows didn't really diminish the noise. The real problem was that the morning when we were ready to check out, we left our luggage in the room while eating breakfast and the door code did not work, denying us access (the outside door codes did work, so the problem was specific to the room door). We texted, called, and emailed the help number, but it was two hours before we were able to get access to our luggage. This caused us to miss some sightseeing we had planned for the day - thank goodness we didn't have anything more critical like a plane to catch.

2025-10-12 via Nuitee
A
Anna couple us
3
Cons:

Felt like a hostel. Loud music playing downstairs until 2am

2025-10-04 via Nuitee
A
Aleksandar partner
2
Pros:

The rooms are decent. However, for a one-night stay that cost $424.64, this experience only deserves one star.
If you’re planning to sleep, don’t expect to get any rest until at least 4 AM. The music from the bar downstairs is unbelievably loud, and the main door is so squeaky and slams loudly that you hear every person coming and going all night long.
To make matters worse, the toilet was dirty, with the bottom of the seat soiled upon arrival. There is also no hotel parking—you have to search for street parking (though at least they do disclose this in advance).
A place like this might be worth around $150 a night, but at over $400, it’s simply unjustifiable.

2025-10-03 via Nuitee
P
Pitz couple us
9
Pros:

Clean room

Cons:

Parking

2025-10-01 via Nuitee
A
Antonia partner
6
Pros:

It's affordable and clean. You're unable to adjust the thermostat and sleep above a bar so hear them all night.

2025-09-15 via Nuitee
M
Maylan
10
Pros:

The highlights: Communication by the property manager was excellent. I was able to contact the landlord directly via text and that was very helpful. Instructions were very clear. The location felt safe despite being above a bar, which made it feel safer since there are people in the area keeping an eye on everything. You need to pass through three coded doors to get to your room. There's plenty of parking on the street like the manager states. The room was incredibly neat and clean and felt new. Sems like it's recently renovated. The bed and comforter were incredibly comfortable and I was very pleasantly surprised. The room, bed, and experience really felt like hotel quality. The room is small but excellent for one person or a couple that is out and about and just need a place to rest their head overnight. They had complimentary coffee and the location is in a walkable area with coffee shops and bars all around.

Lowlights: the only minor issue I had with the location was that for two nights out of my 3-day stay the location was so loud that it was hard to sleep. I couldn't tell if the loud music and karaoke were coming from the bar downstairs or from the other guests in the rooms. It was difficult to sleep for 2/3 nights I spent there. Make sure you are exhausted or drunk before heading back to your room to sleep soundly. The next day in the morning there were trucks and cars all around you. You can hear pretty much everything. Despite that, I enjoyed my stay and felt safe.

2025-09-03 via Nuitee
E
Elizabeth extended_group us
7
Pros:

Clean room, conveniently located. Not very spacious and could hear other neighbors who were staying as well

2025-09-02 via Nuitee
J
Jane solo_traveller us
1
You should not endorse this place. It was horrible.
Pros:

Noisy location. I should’ve read the reviews more carefully. This place sucks

Cons:

It’s over a bar it was vibrating. It was close to traffic. It was no

2025-08-30 via Nuitee
M
Monique friends
8
Pros:

The hotel room was compact but spotless, equipped with a coffee maker, fridge, closet, bathroom, and small desk. We had a minor issue with the self check-in, so make sure to press the home button and enter the code upon arrival; don’t forget to press the lock button when you leave!

There’s no parking on-site, but you can find offsite parking along Main Street or at the Post Office for up to 2 hours. The bar downstairs can be noisy until 3 AM, so be prepared for a late night. The location is excellent, with easy access to Southampton, Bridgehampton, and East Hampton, plus a nearby train station.

We mainly slept at night and spent our days exploring, which worked perfectly for us.

2025-08-30 via Nuitee
D
Diana partner
8
Pros:

It is rather small but extremely clean, very comfortable bed and linens and well equipped with very nice toiletry products. It is everything you would need to be close to all the Hamptons activities but priced affordably. You would not want to spend too much time in the room as although very comfortable, not much space to walk around.
There is no front desk or anyone on premises. You are texted a code.
They should state that there is no elevator and could be difficult for people getting luggage up two flights of stairs. We were very pleased with our stay and will definitely be back.

2025-08-22 via Nuitee