Island Magic Villas

Hotels
9.8 (12 reviews)
1018 Northside Caye Caulker , Caye Caulker , bz

Facilities

Offsite parking discounted rates available
Non-smoking rooms
Air conditioning
Restaurant
Room service
Terrace
Non-smoking throughout
Free wired internet
Self parking (surcharge)
Offsite parking discounted rates available
See all facilities

Review Highlights

Pros:
Great staff
Wonderful location
Excellent amenities
Cons:
Inconsistent housekeeping
Construction noise

Categories

Cleanliness
8.88
Some inconsistencies noted in housekeeping and remnants from construction debris.
Service
10
Great staff, very helpful and willing to go above and beyond expectations.
Location
9.88
Great location on the North Side of Caye Caulker, with beautiful views.
Room Quality
9.88
The furnishings were great and comfortable.
Amenities
9.88
The pool, bed swings, and kayaks were excellent.
Value for Money
10
The property is worth the price considering its quality, especially in Belize.
Food and Beverage
9.88
The restaurant was a good place to hang out during rain storms.
Overall Experience
10
Despite minor issues, the stay was enjoyable and would gladly return.
* This sentiment is summarized by AI based on user reviews.
Updated at: 2026-01-06 10:40

Property Description

Spectacular Sea Views
Indulge in breathtaking sea views from the comfort of your own private balcony at Island Magic Villas.

Delicious Dining Options
Treat your taste buds to a variety of dining choices, with an on-site restaurant serving up delectable à la carte, continental, or American breakfast options.

Convenient Amenities
Enjoy modern conveniences such as free WiFi, room service, and air conditioning in every room, making your stay at Island Magic Villas a truly comfortable one.

Book your stay now at Island Magic Villas for an unforgettable experience by the sea!

Important information:

This property does not accommodate bachelor(ette) or similar parties.

Check-in and check-out hours:
Check-out: 11:00 AM

Location

Guest Reviews

9.8
Based on 12 reviews
Cleanliness: 8.88
Service: 10
Location: 9.88
Room Quality: 9.88
Amenities: 9.88
Value for Money: 10
Food and Beverage: 9.88
Overall Experience: 10
N
Natacha couple be
8
Comfortable and quiet place to stay
Pros:

We had an overall pleasant stay at Island Magic Villa.
Our main reason for visiting the island was to enjoy marine activities such as snorkeling and diving, so we did not spend a great deal of time at the property.
That said, we still appreciated coming back to a quiet and relaxing environment and the pool was definitely a nice bonus, with enough loungers available.

The rooms are spacious, comfortable, and well-equipped, with very good bedding and a reliable hot shower.
The location on the quieter north side of the Split makes it a good option for those looking to stay away from busier areas.

We also appreciated the calm and respectful atmosphere among most guests, which contributed positively to the experience.

Cons:

There are a few aspects that could be improved. Maintenance could be more consistent, for example, an empty beer bottle remained by the stairs leading to our room throughout our five-night stay, which was surprising. Additionally, given the price point (around $300 per night), we feel that boat transfers across the Split could reasonably be included.
While there are paid options available, it would improve the overall value for money if this were part of the stay.

2026-04-20 via Nuitee
J
Johan couple gb
10
2026-04-20 via Nuitee
D
Denise family_with_children us
10
2026-04-09 via Nuitee
M
Mike Dirven extended_group nl
10
Pros:

Prachtige locatie aan de noordkant van Caye Caulker. Het complex is ruim opgezet met een mooi uitzicht op de zee. De villa was ruim en had veel faciliteiten (grote keuken, tv). We hebben heerlijk gegeten bij het restaurant ter plaatse.

We kwamen aan met de ferry aan de zuidkant van het eiland. Van tevoren kregen wij een bericht dat we werden opgehaald met een privé transfer. De transfer hielp ons naar de noordkant waar het hotel ligt. We voelden ons direct welkom. Ook op de terugreis werden we met een transfer bij de ferry afgezet.

Cons:

Toevallig werd er naast het hotel een ander gebouw gebouwd. Hier sliepen wij pal naast waardoor we erg vroeg wakker werden. Hier kan het hotel natuurlijk niets aan doen.

2026-04-03 via Nuitee
J
Jennifer solo_traveller us
10
2026-03-23 via Nuitee
J
Jenny family_with_children ca
10
It was a super fun stay no complaints.
Pros:

The pool and setting were great, nice contrast to the bustle of the South Island, friendly staff who noticed and corrected billing issues right away and organized rides. Hotel was clean and spacious and great value for rooms.

Cons:

Nothing

2026-03-18 via Nuitee
L
Louisa couple de
10
Pros:

For sure one of the best hotels I’ve ever been to! The hotel manager Remi and the whole staff are just so welcoming, kind and helping at all time!
The rooms are amazing - super clean, nice kitchen, rooftop with daybeds, and a balcony.
The way to the South Island is short and simple. Anyways, they would arrange everything for you at all time!
I would love to come back every year- miss this place already!

2026-02-25 via Nuitee
K
Kathy extended_group ca
10
2026-01-24 via Nuitee
C
Claudia couple li
7
2026-01-09 via Nuitee
M
michael family_with_children us
9
Great place to stay on the North Side of Caye Caulker
Pros:

Great staff, very helpful and willing to do things above and beyond expectations. The view, the pool, the furnishings, the location were all great. The restaurant was a good place to hang out during the rain storms. The upstairs bed swing and other swings were a great place to get some protection when the sun was out. The dock was a nice place to be at night and to look at the stars. We took the kayaks out and the staff was very helpful in getting them from storage as well as getting us floatation devices. We truly enjoyed our stay.

Cons:

This is definitely a 9.5 property and for Belize a 10+. It could be a 10 in other countries with just a few changes. There was construction going on right behind our building that started at 7:00am on two of the days of our 10 day stay. I know there is nothing that Island Magic Villas could do to stop it, but it would have been nice to know that before arrival. Secondly, the property is about a year old, but there is still some remnants from the construction, especially along side the dock in the rocks. Stuff like a paint roller and misc. construction debris. Out one of the bedroom windows on top of a walkway cover there was another paint roller, rust nails etc. Lastly, the housekeeping seemed to be inconsistent. There was no mat inside the door to put your shoes on so sand gets tracked inside and the villas really could using sweeping everyday or a broom in them. None of this was a deal breaker and I am pretty picky but I would definitely stay at Island Magic Villas again.

2025-12-23 via Nuitee
V
Vernicia group us
10
Relaxing and peaceful
Pros:

The breakfast (food in general) was hot and fresh! The staff was so accommodating and welcoming! My friend lost her phone on the last day after checkout and the villa staff went above and beyond to help locate the phone! The owner personally inquired about the situation as well. They called, sent updates and was able to send the phone back to us in record time! Love this peaceful place and tasty food & drinks. I will be back again! Much love to my belizean family there after my week stay lol

Cons:

Only thing I didn’t like was the villas location was on the north island but that was very minor since we had the passes available for the ferry. The ride is literally 1 min across the water. The staff drove us everyday to the ferry pickup location so not even a bad ordeal! Not to mention they text you when you arrive to come get you from the water taxi, get your luggage and take you to the ferry then meet you at the north island and take your bags to the room. Just superior customer service from beginning to end!

2025-04-22 via Nuitee
H
Huff group us
10
Exceptional
2025-04-14 via Nuitee
D
Dan family with young children us
9
Superb
2025-01-02 via Nuitee
M
Mays review category business travellers us
10
Exceptional
2024-12-16 via Nuitee