Oddfellows Hotel

Hotels
7.9 (66 reviews)
Oddfellows hotel, High Street , Carlton , gb

Facilities

Offsite parking discounted rates available
Non-smoking rooms
Restaurant
Terrace
Soundproof rooms
Facilities for disabled guests
Non-smoking throughout
Private check-in/check-out
Shared lounge/TV area
Wheelchair accessible
See all facilities

Review Highlights

Pros:
Friendly staff
Clean rooms
Good food quality
Convenient location
Cons:
Irregular service
Heat in rooms
Amenity concerns

Categories

Cleanliness
7.98
Overall, rooms were clean and well-maintained, but there were some cleanliness concerns mentioned.
Service
8.45
The staff were praised for their friendliness and willingness to help in various situations.
Location
8.49
The location is convenient and well-suited for guests attending events nearby.
Room Quality
7.94
Rooms were generally comfortable, though several reviews mentioned some drawbacks like heat.
Amenities
7.47
Some amenities like the towel rail were mentioned as potentially needing improvement.
Value for Money
6.93
The value perceived by guests varied, with some feeling certain costs were too high.
Food and Beverage
7.98
Food quality was highlighted positively, but service issues with food were noted.
Overall Experience
7.95
Overall enjoyable experience despite some specific issues that impacted certain stays.
* This sentiment is summarized by AI based on user reviews.
Updated at: 2025-12-20 12:30

Property Description

Modern Comforts and Convenience

Oddfellows Hotel offers modern amenities like free WiFi, flat-screen TVs, and private bathrooms with complimentary toiletries. Guests can also enjoy free private parking and a shared lounge to unwind after a day of exploration.

Dining Variety

Guests can savor a diverse culinary experience at Oddfellows Hotel with options ranging from American, Caribbean to British cuisine. Special dietary requirements are catered to with vegetarian, dairy-free, and halal options available upon request.

Scenic Surroundings

Situated in Carlton, the hotel boasts a serene garden, a relaxing terrace, and certain rooms with balconies for picturesque views. Enjoy the tranquility of the countryside while still being within reach of popular attractions like Cusworth Hall and York Minster.

Don't miss out on the chance to experience the perfect blend of comfort and convenience at Oddfellows Hotel. Book your stay now for an unforgettable getaway.

Important information:

This property does not accommodate bachelor(ette) or similar parties.

Check-in and check-out hours:

Location

Guest Reviews

7.9
Based on 66 reviews
Cleanliness: 7.98
Service: 8.45
Location: 8.49
Room Quality: 7.94
Amenities: 7.47
Value for Money: 6.93
Food and Beverage: 7.98
Overall Experience: 7.95
J
Julie family_with_children gb
8
Nice place to stay - would stay again.
Pros:

Great place. Near Carlton Towers where event was. Staff pleasant and helpful. Lovely breakfast. Nice & Clean.

Cons:

Everything was fine for us.

2026-01-19 via Nuitee
M
Morgana family_with_children gb
10
2026-01-19 via Nuitee
L
Lindsay couple gb
7
A lovely place to stay for a night.
Pros:

The location to the wedding venue was perfect, the food we had was exceptional, staff were lovely ☺️

Cons:

The room was very hot, and there were no glasses only cups for drinks, felt sorry for the staff member on Monday as he was on his own, serving, cooking, checking people out, not ideal.

2026-01-15 via Nuitee
C
Carolann couple gb
10
2025-11-25 via Nuitee
R
Richard solo_traveller gb
10
Pros:

The breakfast was perfect for me ,
Well presented more than enough .
Extra coffee at no extra cost which was nice a very often you get charged !!

Cons:

The price for a breakfast inclusive stay was i thought quite cheap, the rooms being separate to the main building gave a quiet nite sleep ample parking. Very friendly staff .
The eve meal was for me very very good , overall highly recommended

2025-11-25 via Nuitee
B
Brenda couple gb
8
2025-11-14 via Nuitee
A
Andrew solo_traveller gb
6
It was okay, but far better then the cold damp and mouldy room I left at Premier Inn
Pros:

Comfortable room, which was very hot. Great shower and bathroom was a nice size.

Cons:

Only 2 plug sockets next to bed, so no plug sockets by kettle or the desk area making work impossible.
Heated towel rail gives off a lot of heat - and found switch was next to bed as part of a 2-gang light switch

2025-11-01 via Nuitee
P
paul solo_traveller gb
8
2025-10-31 via Nuitee
M
Michael solo_traveller gb
10
Very good value
Pros:

Clean and friendly

Cons:

Nothing

2025-10-27 via Nuitee
S
simon solo_traveller gb
9
Pros:

Pub and rooms stunning

Cons:

Nothing

2025-10-09 via Nuitee
J
Jane couple gb
10
Perfect stay especially if a guest to a wedding at Carlton towers
Pros:

Our room was absolutely spotless
It was large and the mattress was comfortable
Lots of tea/coffee and biscuits
Nice having a patio outside too
Also a large car park attached
Breakfast and the roast dinner was delicious and definitely recommend

Cons:

Nothing

2025-09-20 via Nuitee
D
Dave couple tr
6
Unfortunately the fire alarm started at around 11.30 pm and no member of staff was there to be seen.
Pros:

Excellent cook. Breakfast was hot and very tasty

Cons:

Bar closed at 9.00pm on the Friday, would have liked the pub to be open longer.

2025-09-15 via Nuitee
J
Jonathan couple gb
10
Excellent staff, excellent stay
Pros:

The staff were excellent. The beds were superb, and it was very clean and modern.

Cons:

When we stayed, it was very very hot, a fan or Aircon would’ve helped, but I guess it’s never normally this warm

2025-08-16 via Nuitee
D
Daniel couple gb
9
Pros:

Breakfast (full english) was cooked to perfection.
Nice pleasent pub.
Nice clean room, comfy bed and good shower.

2025-08-15 via Nuitee
T
Trevor couple gb
6
2025-08-08 via Nuitee
D
Debbie couple gb
5
2025-08-07 via Nuitee
J
Janet solo_traveller gb
8
It was a very short stay but enjoyable
Pros:

Nice clean, comfortable room.
Wayne was very friendly and helpful, he’d been let down by staff and was doing everything himself, he was a star

Cons:

No hooks in the bathroom for towels/robes etc

2025-08-04 via Nuitee
C
Crook young couple gb
5
Don't eat there, use the hotel/pub as a hub
Pros:

Location, cleanliness

Cons:

Hot room, smelly bathroom, and a constant wet floor. One person, serving drinks, making the food and booking in guests, yes one person did it all, at the same time. Some members of our party had to wait 2 1/2hrs for pizzas! All our food was slow to produce. It was tasty and hot when it eventually arrived, but it wasn't good enough. We had called to pre-warn them that their was going to be a few of us eating that night, 15 plus. It was the same for breakfast too. The man did an exception job though, but i certainly wouldn't return for food including breakfast. On the website it says breakfast included. We were informed after we had ate it, that it wasn't, not before we ordered it.

2025-08-01 via Nuitee
C
Christopher review category business travellers gb
10
Exceptional
Pros:

great food, great bar.

Cons:

Nothing not to like

2025-07-31 via Nuitee
E
Ewan review category business travellers gb
7
Good
Pros:

Good old country pub, nice and clean

Cons:

Shower took a while to get hot,

2025-07-31 via Nuitee