Collective Retreats Governors Island

Hotels
8.6 (147 reviews)
825 Gresham Rd , New York , us

Children allowed

Facilities

Guest education on local ecosystems and culture
Non-smoking rooms
Air conditioning
Restaurant
Terrace
BBQ facilities
Safety deposit box
Facilities for disabled guests
Massage services
Non-smoking throughout
See all facilities

Review Highlights

Pros:
Great atmosphere
Unique location
Cons:
Issues with cleanliness
Poor communication regarding extra charges

Categories

Cleanliness
6.49
Several issues with cleanliness noted, including a dirty bathtub.
Service
9.46
Overall good service experience mentioned, though communication issues noted.
Location
9.5
The unique location and sunset views praised.
Room Quality
8.95
Comfort of the bed and quality of products well-received.
Amenities
8.98
Good selection of wines and food at happy hour praised.
Value for Money
7.94
Some users felt it was low cost value despite being unique.
Food and Beverage
8.99
Happy hour bar offerings were a highlight.
Overall Experience
8.46
Many positive aspects, but some serious comfort issues detracted.
* This sentiment is summarized by AI based on user reviews.
Updated at: 2025-12-18 10:53

Property Description

Luxurious Accommodation with Stunning Views

Unmatched Amenities for a Relaxing Stay

Exciting Activities and Convenient Location

Experience the beauty of Collective Governors Island in New York with breathtaking city and garden views. Indulge in luxury with free WiFi, a terrace, and a restaurant. Enjoy private entrances, fireplaces, and coffee machines in select units. Unwind with yoga and fitness classes, outdoor fireplaces, and a picnic area. Conveniently located near popular landmarks and offering a range of activities, including walking tours. Don't miss the chance to book your stay at this exceptional property for an unforgettable experience.

Important information:

Guests are required to show a photo ID and credit card upon check-in. Please note that all Special Requests are subject to availability and additional charges may apply.
Please inform of your expected arrival time in advance. You can use the Special Requests box when booking, or contact the property directly using the contact details in your confirmation.
Guests under the age of 18 can only check in with a parent or official guardian.

Check-in and check-out hours:
Check-out: 10:00 AM

Property Policies

  • Internet

    WiFi is available in all areas and is free of charge.

  • Parking

    No parking available.

  • Pets

    Pets are not allowed.

  • Children and extra bed policy

    Children of any age are allowed.
    Children up to and including 6 years old stay for free when using an existing bed.
    Children up to and including 12 years old stay for US$100 per person per night when using an available extra bed.
    You haven't added any cots.
    Any type of extra bed or child's cot/crib is upon request and needs to be confirmed by management.
    Supplements are not calculated automatically in the total costs and will have to be paid for separately during your stay.

Location

Guest Reviews

8.6
Based on 147 reviews
Cleanliness: 6.49
Service: 9.46
Location: 9.5
Room Quality: 8.95
Amenities: 8.98
Value for Money: 7.94
Food and Beverage: 8.99
Overall Experience: 8.46
A
Aisha solo_traveller us
10
2026-01-19 via Nuitee
E
Erika couple us
7
Pros:

Llegamos alrededor de las 9:20 al desayuno no había café y poca fruta

Cons:

El personal de admisión

2026-01-19 via Nuitee
M
Melinda family_with_children us
8
Comfortable and beautiful. Would have loved a higher end concierge experience.
Pros:

The vibe and concept was great. Having golf cart concierge was amazing. The Peak Lodge food was delicious. I would recommend and would consider coming again.

Cons:

The team was so nice, but there was a lot of misinformation. One staff member said we had to get the water ourselves, next staff member packed our ice box with water. We were told coffee was available all day, and then it wasn't. We came to dinner 5 minutes late after waiting for a very late golf cart pick up at the spa, and they refused to give us dinner, even though it's the only spot on the island to eat dinner. There was no compassion; we even asked for bread, and they made it seem like we were so wrong for even asking. The bartender continued the same vibe, unfortunately. It would be nice if there were some alternatives and clear supportive communication around it all. Made a great trip, but feel not so great on our last night. We saw the next day that the concierge had a fridge with oatmeal, and no one even mentioned that. Very unfortunate at the level of cost this trip is, it should be top-notch concierge communication. Also, it would have been nice to know ahead of time that loud party boats keep you up until 2 AM in the morning, which would have made different choices in booking if that information had been shared.

2026-01-19 via Nuitee
V
Viorel couple us
10
2025-11-29 via Nuitee
E
Eduard couple us
10
2025-11-15 via Nuitee
M
Mensah couple us
10
Lovely place would do again.
Pros:

Great atmosphere

Cons:

N/A

2025-11-06 via Nuitee
F
Fadi couple eg
10
2025-11-03 via Nuitee
L
Liudmyla family_with_children us
10
2025-10-23 via Nuitee
K
Karen solo_traveller us
10
Perfect stay in the city!
Pros:

Everything was just perfect!

2025-10-17 via Nuitee
I
Irene couple us
8
Charming place with some cons
Pros:

The location of the property is obviously unique and the has the sunset view in New York City.
I liked the comfort of the bed and the quality of products in the room.
It was the end of the season and the place was serene. The happy hour bar with good selection of wine and food added charm to the experience.

Cons:

- it was impossible to switch from the bath tub to the shower.
- the AC didn’t react to the remote
- no slippers in the room
- bath tub was dirty
With everything said it was low cost value performance even for being unique place in NYC

2025-10-17 via Nuitee
S
Simone couple de
8
Einmaliger Standort und nettes Glamping-Erlebnis bei hohen Kosten
Pros:

Glamping-Erlebnis, Blick auf Freiheitstatue und Manhattan im Sonnenuntergang, tolle Atmosphäre durch Feuerschalen

Cons:

Uns wurde nicht vorab klar kommuniziert, dass wir zusätzlich 50 Dollar für einen ca. 2 Stunden früheres Einchecken bezahlen müssen. In der Visacard-Abrechnung war der Bezug zum Retreat nicht zu erkennen, so dass wir eingangs an einen Kartenbetrug glaubten. Es hat dann noch ein länger währenden Nachrichtenaustausch über die Booking.com Plattform gegeben, wobei mehrfach behauptet wurde, dass die Nebenkostenabrechnung per E-Mail an mich verschickt worden sei. Nicht schön und nur formal kundenorientiert

2025-10-15 via Nuitee
P
Parvizi couple us
6
Always love the location and the tents - need to communicate better w your guests
Pros:

This is one of my favorite places in NYC - I find the whole experience magical, the view, the tents, governors island etc etc

Cons:

I booked on a Friday specifically to avoid the construction noise I experienced when I stayed the month before but construction started even earlier on that Saturday morning and the entire hotel was woken up at 6:30am but the loudest possible banging - it lasted well over 90 min. And then I went to take a shower and there was no hot water, bc of course the entire camp went to the showers at the same time bc we were woken up at the same time. It was a miserable morning.

2025-10-14 via Nuitee
Сережа couple us
1
Cons:

я забронировал эти апартаменты увидев красивую картинку. так как в Нью Йорке я в первые. я прочитал все внимательно. в описании написано что можно добраться на автомобиле что не соответствует действительности. апартаменты находятся на острове на который можно только доплыть. последний паром отправляется в 10 вечера, что не указано в описании. я поехал на станцию паром в течении часа , узнал всю эту информацию и захотел отменить бронирование. на что мне ответили что снимут 100% стоимости. на письма и звонки они больше не отвечали. мошейники , никому не советую

2025-10-14 via Nuitee
E
Elizabeth family_with_children us
6
Lovely, but overpriced and wouldn’t come again.
Pros:

The location is breathtaking. It’s such a special part of NYC that many folks are unaware of. The novelty of camping/glamping in New York Harbor is really special. The bonfire at night was so lovely and the s’mores were a delight.

Cons:

This place is incredibly expensive for what it is. The basecamp cabin was $575, and it was comfy, but fine. The tents cost us $375, and the heat didn’t work in them and the sound of the boats and helicopters led to a pretty sleepless night, event though they provide earplugs. In general, it was a lovely, but wayyyyyyyyy overpriced. You can enjoy the magic of this place without sleeping there, which is what I would do next time. I would come and visit for the day and grab a drink at the bar, but the cost was outrageous given how uncomfortable the accommodation was.

2025-10-14 via Nuitee
T
Thomas
8
Pros:

So beautiful, an escape from the city. Our tent rattled so loud throughout the night it felt like someone shaking a saucepan full of cutlery over our heads—even with white noise on and noise cancelling headphones in.
Dinner at the restaurant was incredible, but breakfast was stingy AF.
Highly recommend for families

2025-10-12 via Nuitee
M
Morgan couple us
8
2025-10-11 via Nuitee
D
D
10
Pros:

Kaliek, Felix, Ruda go above and beyond. The Three Peaks Lodge restaurant bar and staff kept drinks flowing and Dinner menu is perfect.

This a great retreat from real life!! 5minutes on the Ferry!

We will be back next season!

2025-10-05 via Nuitee
N
NORIKO solo_traveller jp
9
流れゆく時間
Pros:

マンハッタンからすぐの場所にゆったりした時間を過ごせる事があることを聞いて今回は、ニューヨーク旅行に組み込みました。
大正解です。
マンハッタンと自由の女神が見えるこの場所、ベッドの中からも見渡せます。
夕焼けを見ながらディナー!
とても贅沢な時間を過ごせました。
お気に入りの場所となりました。

Cons:

ルームサービスを現在されていなかったので不便さをかんじました。

2025-10-03 via Nuitee
N
Naomi extended_group us
10
2025-09-29 via Nuitee
S
Sherry extended_group us
10
Glamping sunsets smores
Pros:

Unique experience

2025-09-28 via Nuitee