The Pridwin Hotel

Hotels
9.1 (143 reviews)
81 Shore Road , Shelter Island , us

Free
Children allowed

Facilities

Health or beauty spa nearby
Offsite parking discounted rates available
Fitness facilities (surcharge)
Non-smoking rooms
Air conditioning
Swimming pool
Restaurant
Terrace
Lift / Elevator
Safety deposit box
See all facilities

Review Highlights

Pros:
Beautiful location
Friendly staff
Comfortable rooms
Cons:
Staff training needed
Cleanliness issues
Food quality inconsistent

Categories

Cleanliness
7.93
Specific mention of better cleanliness needed and unclean coffee table.
Service
9.4
Some staff were disorganized, but many reviews highlighted friendly and helpful service.
Location
9.94
Frequently praised as beautiful with great views and a charming spot.
Room Quality
9.39
Mentioned as very nice and comfortable, but some issues with noise and pillows.
Amenities
9.42
Great amenities mentioned, including food and activities.
Value for Money
8.38
Experiences of being overcharged detracted from perceived value.
Food and Beverage
8.43
Food quality received mixed reviews; could be better.
Overall Experience
9.9
Overall positive sentiments with many guests looking forward to a return.
* This sentiment is summarized by AI based on user reviews.
Updated at: 2025-12-11 02:38

Property Description

Welcome to The Pridwin, a picturesque waterfront resort on Shelter Island!

Nestled in a serene natural setting, The Pridwin offers 33 luxurious guest rooms and 16 private cottages, perfect for couples, friends, and families.

Indulge in All-American Dining and Scenic Views

Enjoy delectable meals at our on-site restaurant and unwind at the lively lounge with breathtaking water views.

Relaxation and Recreation at Your Fingertips

Pamper yourself at the full-service spa, take a dip in the scenic pool, and partake in seasonal activities suitable for all ages.

Book your stay at The Pridwin now and create unforgettable memories in this tranquil oasis.

Important information:

Please note that the number of occupants stated for a room during reservation should include adults and children.

Please note that the seasonal on-site restaurant will be open from 19th June to 5th September, Labor Day.Guests are required to show a photo ID and credit card upon check-in. Please note that all Special Requests are subject to availability and additional charges may apply.

Check-in and check-out hours:
Check-out: 11:00 AM
Airport code: ISP

Property Policies

  • Parking

    Free private parking is possible on site (reservation is not needed).

  • Internet

    WiFi is available in public areas and is free of charge.

  • Pets

    Pets are not allowed.

  • Groups

    No special conditions apply for groups.

  • Children and extra bed policy

    Children of any age are allowed.
    Children up to and including 1 year old stay for US$25 per person per night when using an available cot.
    Children up to and including 5 years old stay for free when using an existing bed.
    You haven't added any extra beds.
    Any type of extra bed or child's cot/crib is upon request and needs to be confirmed by management.
    Supplements are not calculated automatically in the total costs and will have to be paid for separately during your stay.

Location

Guest Reviews

9.1
Based on 143 reviews
Cleanliness: 7.93
Service: 9.4
Location: 9.94
Room Quality: 9.39
Amenities: 9.42
Value for Money: 8.38
Food and Beverage: 8.43
Overall Experience: 9.9
S
Sue family_with_children gb
7
Great place lacking trained staff
Pros:

Great location. Comfortable. Good food. Great vibe Lots to do

Cons:

The staff were disorganized and lacked basic knowledge of the place or customer service.

2026-01-19 via Nuitee
I
IRENE couple us
10
The Pridwin is a perfect place to stay & like a little slice of heaven.
Pros:

From the moment we arrived, we were treated with respect & kindness. The hotel is in a lovely location with a stunning view from the back covered patio & deck. Our room was comfortable and clean. We had a nice view of the grounds, ocean & pool area. The breakfast buffet was simple, but fine for our taste. Chefs were preparing made to order omelets which is what we ordered, along with avocado toast, fresh fruit, & pastry.

Cons:

Nothing. Everything was perfect

2026-01-19 via Nuitee
T
Trudy couple us
10
2026-01-19 via Nuitee
C
Chris couple us
10
2025-10-14 via Nuitee
C
Concetta
10
Pros:

Clean room excellent staff

2025-10-11 via Nuitee
D
Demetria family
10
Pros:

The staff was amazing

2025-10-06 via Nuitee
A
Anthony family_with_children us
7
2025-09-30 via Nuitee
J
Jennifer family
10
Pros:

The Pridwin is a beautiful property with a stunning view and old New England, Americana historic vibe. It is a quintessential experience if you want to have quiet yet convenience to both the north and south forks. The ferry is quick and the island is beautiful and quiet if you go during off season. Lovely long weekend trip for me and my husband. Highly recommend.

2025-09-28 via Nuitee
D
Dulce couple us
8
Very relaxing... enjoyed the pool and all amenities.
Pros:

Excellent breakfast, beautiful location, room was very nice but too close to staff quarters..

Cons:

Better cleanliness. The Nooks coffee table was not cleaned for 4 nights.

2025-09-14 via Nuitee
P
Paul
10
Pros:

Shelter Island is definitely a gem

2025-09-11 via Nuitee
C
Caroline Jeana family
10
Pros:

Best resort in the Hamptons / Long Island area! My family and I loved this resort before and after renovations- which are incredible. The staff is outstandingly well trained and so kind. We come to Shelter Island / North Fork annually so we love that The Pridwin has been renewed.

2025-09-03 via Nuitee
R
Richard couple us
7
Pros:

Location

Cons:

Short on staff

2025-08-28 via Nuitee
J
Jacob
10
Pros:

Awesome all around! Staff was super nice

2025-08-24 via Nuitee
B
Brendan partner
10
Pros:

We had such an amazing stay at the Pridwin! Their staff truly goes above and beyond to make your experience positive.

Phenomenal food/ drinks great views. Couldn’t ask for a better trip!

Can’t wait to go back!

2025-08-23 via Nuitee
D
David
10
Midweek getaway
Pros:

We had a lovely time with our mid-week get away... no complaints! Charming spot!

2025-08-22 via Nuitee
S
Sigalit family_with_children us
10
2025-08-18 via Nuitee
J
Janice couple us
10
Great
Pros:

Its a great escape with so much to do!!

2025-08-17 via Nuitee
A
Amy couple us
8
4th time there and already dreaming of next year.
Pros:

Almost everything! Food, amenities, location, decor, bbq, all amazing.

Cons:

The walls are thin, the valet isn’t always available, the pillows are awful, not enough people making eggs at the breakfast.

2025-08-15 via Nuitee
J
Jakub couple sk
8
Pros:

Great location, amenities and overall a place worth to stay at.

Cons:

We found a big cut nail close to our bed and we were overcharged. We contacted the staff at the property and they told us that they refunded the amount, but the money never came.

2025-08-15 via Nuitee
J
Jena
10
Romantic
Pros:

The Wednesday barbecue was so much fun!

2025-08-15 via Nuitee