Sheridan's Bed & Breakfast

Hotels
Independent
9.7 (115 reviews)
Cudahy, Wisconsin, 53110 , Cudahy , US

Facilities

Free breakfast
Fitness facilities
Proposal/romance packages available
Express check-out
Firepit
Terrace
Express check-in/check-out
Outdoor furniture
Fitness facilities
Bicycle rentals nearby
See all facilities

Review Highlights

Pros:
None mentioned
Cons:
Cleanliness issues
Poor service
Overpriced for the area and amenities
Old and uncomfortable rooms
Lack of amenities

Categories

Cleanliness
3
Several guests mentioned cleanliness as a major issue, with reports of rooms smelling old.
Service
2
Poor service was a common complaint, with guests feeling overpriced for the level of service provided.
Location
4
Guests found the hotel overpriced for its location and lack of amenities nearby.
Room Quality
2
Rooms were described as old and not well-maintained, contributing to a negative guest experience.
Amenities
2
Guests were disappointed with the lack of amenities and felt the hotel was not worth the price paid.
Value for Money
2
Most guests felt that the hotel was severely overpriced based on the quality of services provided.
Food and Beverage
2
There were no specific mentions of food and beverage in the reviews provided.
Overall Experience
2
The overall experience was negative, with guests stating they would not recommend the hotel due to various shortcomings.
* This sentiment is summarized by AI based on user reviews.
Updated at: 2025-09-14 06:02

Property Description

Charming Accommodations:
Indulge in a cozy retreat in one of the 12 uniquely decorated guestrooms, featuring fireplaces and flat-screen TVs for your comfort and relaxation.

Rejuvenating Amenities:
Start your day with a complimentary full breakfast and make use of facilities like the fitness center, terrace, and coffee/tea in a common area. The perfect way to unwind and recharge during your stay.

Convenient Location:
Explore nearby attractions such as Lake Michigan, South Milwaukee Downtown Market, and other points of interest all within a short distance from Sheridan's Bed & Breakfast. Take advantage of our proximity to General Mitchell Intl. Airport for easy travel access.

Plan your escape at Sheridan's Bed & Breakfast for a memorable and enriching experience.

Important information:

  • The property has connecting/adjoining rooms, which are subject to availability and can be requested by contacting the property using the number on the booking confirmation.
  • Contactless check-in and contactless check-out are available.

Check-in and check-out hours:
Check-out: 11:00 AM
Airport code: MKE

Property Policies

  • Pets

    Pets not allowed

  • Check-in & Check-out

    Contactless check-out is available

  • Accessibility

    No elevators

  • General

    Professional property host/manager

  • Check-in & Check-out

    Contactless check-in is available

Location

Guest Reviews

9.7
Based on 115 reviews
Cleanliness: 3
Service: 2
Location: 4
Room Quality: 2
Amenities: 2
Value for Money: 2
Food and Beverage: 2
Overall Experience: 2
W
William
10
Great location inclusive of breakfast and parking
Pros:

Very comfortable room and bed. Extra large bathroom with a top tier shower. Breakfast was delivered and it was substantial and tasty too. Nice hardworking innkeepers and staff!

2025-08-22 via Nuitee
R
Ruth
10
Wish the stay was longer
Pros:

This is an absolutely beautiful B&B. A very relaxing, quiet area. This is the first time in 27 years we have stayed at a B&B. We loved it. The parking lot could use some spucing up and the flight of stairs were a bit of a challenge with luggage for an 11 day trip. Other than that it was perfect.

2025-08-15 via Nuitee
J
Jeff
10
Pros:

Quiet and comfortable

2025-08-02 via Nuitee
K
Kaila
10
Pros:

.

2025-07-26 via Nuitee
A
Ann partner
10
Pros:

This was our first time experiencing a bed and breakfast so we didn't quite know what to expect. The building was very nice and easy to access. Very cozy and quiet area. Room was perfect and very clean. Bed and pillows were delightful and extremely comfortable! The shower was amazing with great water pressure. Breakfast was delicious! The only constructive recommendation from us is that being we aren't big sweet breakfast eaters, we were left a little hungry one morning bc there was french toast- 3 small thick pieces and the other dish was a small breakfast sandwich with extra bacon on the side. If doing an English muffin breakfast sandwich for a dish for 2 people to share, having 2 sandwiches would be my only recommendation bc 1 sandwich was only 2-3 bites a piece and not very filling. But the food was delicious and full of flavor! Definitely would come back! Thank you for a wonderful stay!

2025-07-23 via Nuitee
C
Caroline partner
10
Pros:

The room we stayed in was very cozy with an electric fire place and jacuzzi tube. Would definitely come back.

2025-07-20 via Nuitee
C
Ciara partner
8
Pros:

Cobwebs in main areas. Asked for no onions with the breakfast that was offered because of an allergy and everything besides the fruit has onions. The fitness center was closed which they didn’t indicate anywhere or put up a which they didn’t indicate anywhere or put up a sign, and the coffee bar didn’t have refrigerated creamer, which was a little bizarre. Overall, the place was pretty clean, but the room did smell like varnish or something. Self check in and check out made things easier and the area itself felt safe. Just wish there was a bar or restaurant in the hotel and maybe that you got to select what you ate for breakfast. Also a little bizarre having to send a photo of my personal drivers license. I’ve never had to do that booking any other property or hotel before, but maybe this is standard protocol, I’m not sure.

2025-07-20 via Nuitee
A
amy
10
Pros:

Perfect stay

2025-07-20 via Nuitee
R
ROLANDO friends
10
Pros:

The Sheridan was conveniently located close to downtown Milwaukee which was great since we were attending a festival at Veteran's Park. The town of Cudahy is a very nice little town right near Lake Michigan. Very safe and quiet area. The free parking lot across the street was super convenient and the room was fabulous. Breakfast was right on time and delicious. Jane, the owner, and her staff were very friendly and courteous throughout our stay. I would highly recommend this boutique style B&B and will be booking again in the future. Thank you, Jane and Staff!!

2025-07-14 via Nuitee
M
Mark partner
10
Pros:

Just what we needed for our babymoom! The hosts were great, the breakfast was fresh. No complaints.

2025-07-10 via Nuitee
S
sharon
8
We were slightly dissapointed
Pros:

We were slightly dissapointed and not sure it lives up to its reputation or the £250 per night price tag. On a basic level the wifi was awful, there was nowhere to eat breakfast and the big ugly air con unit in the room spoiled the ambiance somewhat. No access to outside space without going outside the front of the hotel and walking around through the car park. No acknowledgement when checking out. Overall it was good, hence our 4/5 rating, but it could and probably should be better.

2025-06-30 via Nuitee
C
Crystal partner
10
Pros:

Very nice five star

2025-06-29 via Nuitee
J
John partner
10
Pros:

Easy to get to. Check in is quick and straightforward

2025-06-27 via Nuitee
T
tresa
10
Pros:

The whole experience from beginning to end was very enjoyable, smooth and quite an unexpected treat

2025-06-20 via Nuitee
B
Barbara friends
4
Pros:

Very old and smelled like it. Way overpriced for the area and amenities. Would not recommend

2025-06-08 via Nuitee
A
Anthony family
10
Pros:

Great place! Very clean and a great full breakfast!

2024-09-23 via Nuitee
K
keith partner
10
Pros:

Huge room, everything in excellent shape, best shower ever, excellent breakfast. There is nothing negative about this property.

2024-09-16 via Nuitee
B
Beth
10
Pros:

Wonderful place.

2024-09-10 via Nuitee
R
Rebecca partner
10
Pros:

The room was beautifully decorated and clean. The hotel was quiet. Breakfast was amazing. Would stay here again!!

2024-09-02 via Nuitee
K
Kathleen
10
Best stay ever in Wisconsin ❤️
Pros:

Sheridan's was a beautiful place and the amenities were above and beyond.
The breakfast they serve every morning was phenomenal! We will definitely stay again ❤️

2024-08-19 via Nuitee