Commodore Resort

Hotels
6 (188 reviews)
272 Delaware Avenue , Put-in-Bay , us

Facilities

Nightclub
Non-smoking rooms
Air conditioning
Swimming pool
Restaurant
Lift / Elevator
Luggage storage
Fax/photocopying
Facilities for disabled guests
Shared lounge/TV area
See all facilities

Review Highlights

Pros:
Friendly staff
Great location
Cons:
Dirty rooms
Uncomfortable beds
Musty smells

Categories

Cleanliness
4.14
Multiple reviews mentioned dirty rooms, mold, and unclean areas.
Service
8.11
Staff were frequently praised as friendly and attentive.
Location
8.15
Comments noted the hotel's central location and proximity to attractions.
Room Quality
4.6
Several reports of musty smells, uncomfortable beds, and various issues with the rooms.
Amenities
6.13
Pool area mentioned positively, though some had complaints about cleanliness.
Value for Money
5.09
The hotel was considered overpriced for the quality of experience.
Food and Beverage
6.14
Limited comments but noted subway in lobby positively.
Overall Experience
5.61
Mixed experiences with notable issues affecting overall satisfaction.
* This sentiment is summarized by AI based on user reviews.
Updated at: 2026-01-06 13:38

Property Description

Luxurious Adults-Only Accommodation
Commodore Resort in Put-in-Bay offers a sophisticated stay for adults, featuring a shared lounge, restaurant, and bar. Guests can enjoy the seasonal outdoor pool and air-conditioned rooms with free WiFi. The 3-star hotel's amenities include a 24-hour front desk, ATM, and luggage storage.

Modern Comforts and Entertainment
Each room at Commodore Resort is equipped with a flat-screen TV, cable channels, and cozy bed linens. The private bathrooms come with fresh towels for convenience.

Relaxation and Exploration
Guests can unwind on the sun terrace or venture to nearby attractions like Perry's Cave. Conveniently located just 112 km from Toledo Express Airport, this hotel is the perfect choice for a tranquil getaway.

Book your stay at Commodore Resort now for a memorable and relaxing experience.

Important information:

Guests under 21 years of age are not permitted in the pool area. Please contact the property for additional details.

The property offers limited parking based on availability at time of arrival.

Be advised that Put-in-Bay is only accessible via the Miller Ferry or Jet Express. Contact property for more details.Guests are required to show a photo ID and credit card upon check-in. Please note that all Special Requests are subject to availability and additional charges may apply.

Check-in and check-out hours:
Check-out: 11:00 AM
Airport code: TOL

Property Policies

  • Internet

    WiFi is available in all areas and is free of charge.

  • Parking

    No parking available.

  • Children and extra bed policy

    Children are not allowed.
    You haven't added any cots.
    You haven't added any extra beds.

  • Pets

    Pets are not allowed.

Location

Guest Reviews

6
Based on 188 reviews
Cleanliness: 4.14
Service: 8.11
Location: 8.15
Room Quality: 4.6
Amenities: 6.13
Value for Money: 5.09
Food and Beverage: 6.14
Overall Experience: 5.61
S
Steven
8
Pros:

Great stay for cheap and right downtown. You can walk through the hotel into Mr. Ed’s, and there is a subway in the lobby. However, take the Jet Express so you can just walk to your room. You will save $80 a day on a cart and if you park out back in the alley, you will get your golf cart stolen. You don’t need one anyway, since you’re right in the heart of downtown.

2025-10-12 via Nuitee
M
Mallory
10
Pros:

Great stay.

2025-10-08 via Nuitee
B
Brittney partner
2
Pros:

There is no one here. Sign says to go to a bar down the street and ask them to check in. We have an issue with the fridge and called the "on site manager" but no one has answered or called back. The room smells musty and is not in great condition (floor tile is crumbling, especially in bathroom). It was also difficult to find.

2025-10-07 via Nuitee
E
Earl
10
Pros:

Pool bar and cart rental

2025-10-07 via Nuitee
R
Ray
10
Pros:

Not a 5 star but is equal to all other of the properties in the area.

2025-10-03 via Nuitee
L
Lesley
6
Pros:

It really wasn’t that great. Limited parking. Rooms weren’t very clean, very weird area lol but the places around weren’t too bad.

2025-09-26 via Nuitee
J
Jeffrey Forest
4
Pros:

Given a room which had a bathroom commode so large that the door could not be closed. Remote TV wouldn’t work only to find wiring in back of TV had to be ‘jiggled’ and remote batteries replaced.

2025-09-24 via Nuitee
S
Susan
4
Pros:

We stayed in a king bed room. As soon as we walked in there was a weird, kind of musty/moldy smell that was present during our entire stay. The bathroom looked like it hadn't been deep cleaned in a very long time. There was a water leak coming from under the toilet tank and moldy grime caked into the caulk. Every time you sat on the toilet seat, the entire toilet moved and made a noise.
There was a very annoying water drip coming from somewhere the entire night. (We presumed it was from the air conditioning unit but couldn't pin point it for sure)

2025-09-21 via Nuitee
I
india
2
Pros:

The only thing that I liked about this property was that it near everything you’re right in the heart of it. What I didn’t like about this place was that the room smells very bad it’s very small. The pool closed super early the tv did not work the shower was dirty and it took forever to find.

2025-09-20 via Nuitee
P
Patricia friends
8
Pros:

the staff were great pool area was nice but the floors in the rooms were dirty ,your socks or feet were black and per staff that came and mopped the room the floors had not been sealed when they were put down ,area was great,loud at night when people were walking by but you are in a area that nosie is expected over all i would stay there again

2025-09-19 via Nuitee
M
Marco
10
Pros:

Room was clean and staff was friendly on hand and prepared to meet my needs

2025-09-16 via Nuitee
H
Hamilton partner
10
Pros:

Everything was good.

2025-09-15 via Nuitee
K
Kimberly
2
Pros:

So gross, the mattresses were stained and everything was dirty. Very load at night.

2025-09-14 via Nuitee
K
Kristen
8
Pros:

Great pool.... and had a subway in the lobby

2025-09-08 via Nuitee
Z
Zacarias
10
Pros:

Good place to stay

2025-09-07 via Nuitee
M
MICHAEL partner
6
Pros:

Room was musty. Running vent or a/c clears it up. Some rooms don't have windows. Bed was absolutely awful. I can't say enough how bad the bed was. Staff was nice. Hotel was clean. Overpriced for the quality.

2025-09-07 via Nuitee
J
Jennifer
10
Pros:

Staff was very friendly! Excellent location too!

2025-09-07 via Nuitee
G
GARY family
2
Pros:

The staff was the best part. It was downhill from there. Room smelled musty and had a mildew smell. We were close to the pool area but the view from this room was a broken fence and a dumpster area. Also at 3am we had a bang on the door from sheriff’s office looking for someone that was having a domestic dispute. I can’t see myself returning, for any reason. This hotel is good for someone maybe single looking to just be on the island for parties. But the smell of the room was too much to enjoy the island knowing you had to return to your room.

2025-09-04 via Nuitee
S
Stephannie
10
Pros:

Right in the center of it all

2025-09-03 via Nuitee
D
Darrick family
10
Pros:

The room was clean,staff friendly,and wife was happy..we had a great time.

2025-09-02 via Nuitee