Colonial Inn

Hotels
7.8 (117 reviews)
305 Main Street , Pine Hill , US
1-845-2545577

listing image 1
Show all photos
Free
Children allowed

Facilities

Restaurant
Bar
24-hour front desk
Non-smoking rooms
Free parking
Internet services
Billiards
Darts
WiFi
Free WiFi
See all facilities

Review Highlights

Pros:
Very friendly, hospitable owners/staff (Heather & Steve)
Cozy, quirky ambience and charming antiques/lobby
Clean sheets and comfortable beds reported by multiple guests
Good value / affordable price
Quiet location and easy parking
Unique character/mascots (dog Zeus, friendly bird)
Cons:
Property is very old / 'funky' — not for everyone
Safety concerns (reported lack of sprinklers, melted extension cords)
Exterior appearance may not match photos
Ants reported in at least one room
Limited or unclear modern amenities

Categories

Cleanliness
6.2
Mixed signals in reviews: several guests said rooms and sheets were clean and beds comfortable, but others described the property as very old, reported ants in a room and even hazardous wiring—overall cleanliness and upkeep are below average.
Service
8.7
Consistently praised: multiple guests called Heather, Steve and staff very friendly, hospitable and helpful; owners described as genuine and generous, so service is a strong positive for most stays.
Location
8
Location described as quiet with easy parking and tucked off the beaten path (charming for some), though one guest noted the exterior didn’t match photos—overall a generally positive but mixed view.
Room Quality
7.5
Rooms noted as cozy with comfortable beds and nice antiques by some guests; others mentioned the property is very old and ‘funky,’ so room quality is acceptable but variable.
Amenities
6.5
Few formal amenities mentioned; guests highlighted unique touches (mascot dog Zeus, bird) and a quirky lobby, but there are also safety concerns (no sprinklers reported) and limited modern amenity mentions.
Value for Money
9.5
Several reviewers commented on excellent value and a great price for an overnight stay; strong consensus that this is a good-value option.
Food and Beverage
7.8
No comments about food or beverage in the reviews; assigned target overall rating (standard quality for this hotel tier).
Overall Experience
8.2
Generally positive and memorable stays were reported (personal interactions with owners, cozy/quirky charm), but a small number of serious negative reports about safety and extreme age of the property temper the overall score.
* This sentiment is summarized by AI based on user reviews.
Updated at: 2026-10-30 19:25

Property Description

Charming Colonial Inn in Pine Hill

Luxurious Amenities: Enjoy a relaxing stay with a bar, restaurant, and free WiFi. The 24-hour front desk ensures all your needs are met promptly.

Recreational Activities: Have a blast with billiards, darts, and discounted access to Belleayre Ski Center. Take advantage of complimentary use of a local recreation center with a pool and exercise facility.

Convenient Location: Explore Belleayre Ski Center just 4.8 km away and Belleayre Beach only 1.6 km away.

Book your stay at Colonial Inn for a delightful experience!

Important information:

Guests are required to show a photo ID and credit card upon check-in. Please note that all Special Requests are subject to availability and additional charges may apply.
Managed by a private host
A deposit may be required at the property.

Check-in and check-out hours:
Check-out: 11:00 AM

Property Policies

  • Check-in / check-out

    Check-in from 15:00, check-out until 11:00.

  • Minimum age

    Guests must be at least 18 years old to check in.

  • Pets

    Pets are not allowed. Service animals are always welcome.

  • Parking

    Free self-parking is available.

  • Internet

    Wifi is available free of charge.

See all policies

Location

Guest Reviews

7.8
Based on 117 reviews
Cleanliness: 6.2
Service: 8.7
Location: 8
Room Quality: 7.5
Amenities: 6.5
Value for Money: 9.5
Food and Beverage: 7.8
Overall Experience: 8.2
A
Alex Mesman • couple • nl
7
Beestachtig goed.
Pros:

Schitterende ambiance, en een prachtige host. Amerikaanser dan dit krijg je het niet. Niet heengaan als je niet van opgezette dieren houdt

Mexicaans restaurant aan de overkant.

Cons:

Als er op de website had gestaan dat er geen ontbijt en geen restaurant was. Daar zoek je toch vaak de plek op uit en als het er staat maar er niet is, valt dat tegen.

2026-10-31 • via Nuitee
C
Carmen • couple • us
8
We'd certainly recommend and return again for a really great value and more local experience.
Pros:

The owner, Steve, was super friendly and offered us our first round of beers in the bar upon check-in. His daughter Heather showed us the room and how to adjust the heater. The king bed was super spacious and very comfortable. The decor is very 'grandma's house meets a hunting lodge' but it was clean and everyone we interacted with was very friendly. It was a really laidback, small town, and the lobby bar is akin to a great dive bar vibe with folks playing free pool, darts, a jukebox and really cheap drinks (think beers for about $4-$6 each). We happened to be staying the night in this 10 room B&B with a motorcycle crew that was passing through and they were a fun and friendly group to chat with. There were also several folks in their 30's or so who seemed like they were either passing through on a weekend getaway to the Catskills or could be new locals to the area.

Cons:

The one option for dining nearby happened to be a really great Mexican restaurant across the street. The only downside was that, even on a Saturday, their staff was ready to close both the kitchen and do last call at 8:30pm so we raced over to place an order minutes after checking in. We did discover a few more late night bar options within 10 minutes drive but food options after 8:30pm in the area are super limited and driving on the winding roads after sunset in an area we were unfamiliar with was not the easiest.

2026-10-26 • via Nuitee
C
Carlos • solo_traveller • us
9
I Will come Back Again !!!
Pros:

Employees very Friendly and always ready to Help , Family Run Business !!!!

2026-10-19 • via Nuitee
R
Robert • couple • us
8
A touch of nostalgia coupled with great hospitality.
Pros:

The room was clean, the sheets were clean and the bed was very comfortable. The whole place did not smell bad at all. Some older properties have a funky smell but that was not the case here. The staff were very friendly, nice and polite. Made you feel comfortable and welcome.

Cons:

The outside did not match the pictures at all. If it was dark we would have driven right by. I think they might have used AI to enhance the outside or it was a very old picture. But I would stay there again.

2026-09-14 • via Nuitee
J
Jonathan • couple • us
8
Pros:

Loved the ambience and the quirky lobby. The staff was very friendly!

2026-09-07 • via Nuitee
G
Gurdip • solo_traveller • us
6
2026-08-19 • via Nuitee
S
Stuart • family_with_children • gb
9
Despite mixed reviews, this stay has been the most enjoyable and memorable of our 18 day road trip.
Pros:

The owner Steve is the most genuine, generous man I’ve ever met, we really enjoyed meeting him, listening to his life experiences and having a drink with him.
If I’m ever back in the area, I would book back in here to see the place again.

2026-08-13 • via Nuitee
R
Richard • couple • us
10
Will stay here again.
Pros:

Exceptional service and the owners were amazing.

2026-08-02 • via Nuitee
A
Alexandra • couple • us
7
Heather and her dad were absolutely amazing and super hospitable
Pros:

LOVED Heather and Steve - so sweet and inviting!!! Sunny, the dog was lovely and Zeus, the bird, so friendly

Cons:

Funky- if you don’t mind funky, then this is for you- I got a kick out of it - my friend, not so much

2026-07-19 • via Nuitee
L
Louise • family_with_children • us
9
Perfect
Pros:

Great for an overnight. Money was good

Cons:

Nothing. Beautiful antiques

2026-07-17 • via Nuitee
R
Rebecca • solo_traveller • us
10
Pros:

This place has the delightful confidence to be unapologetically itself—and that's exactly its magic. Equal parts quirky hideaway and cozy hometown treasure, it's tucked just far enough off the beaten path to feel like you've stumbled onto a secret, while still being close enough that adventure is always within easy reach. Come for the peaceful sleep, stay for the local character. A hidden gem!

Cons:

We couldn't stay longer!

2026-07-12 • via Nuitee
A
Alexander • solo_traveller • us
3
Cons:

Very old place. Everything is old inside..

2026-06-25 • via Nuitee
C
Chantal • solo_traveller • ca
9
2026-06-11 • via Nuitee
M
Mark • couple • us
7
2026-06-05 • via Nuitee
M
Marie • couple • se
7
2026-05-28 • via Nuitee
L
Lora • couple • us
1
You couldn't pay me to stay here again.
Pros:

Definitely unlike any place I have ever stayed before! I will have stories to tell.

Cons:

DO NOT RISK YOUR LIFE BY STAYING HERE! No Sprinklers, melted extension cords, junk under windows making escape hazardous and difficult. Worried all night about sleeping in a death trap.

2026-05-27 • via Nuitee
A
Agata • couple • us
7
2026-05-19 • via Nuitee
J
Jodie • couple • ca
8
Pros:

Very friendly and helpful staff
Their mascot Zeus

Cons:

Ants in room

2026-05-18 • via Nuitee
H
Hannah • couple • us
10
Pros:

Easy parking, quiet location. Rooms were clean and cozy. Heather and Steve were kind and welcoming. Couldn't have asked for a better getaway, and for a fantastic price too!

2026-05-11 • via Nuitee
F
Filip • couple • sk
10
A true timeless inn experience
Pros:

What an experience. Felt like staying at grandma’s, with the most cozy bed. You can feel the place’s history seeping through every single item. Atmospheric & beautiful!

2026-04-23 • via Nuitee