The Montauk Beach House

Hotels
8.4 (142 reviews)
55 South Elmwood Avenue , Montauk , us

Free
Children allowed

Facilities

WiFi available
Free WiFi
Parking
Free Parking
Non-smoking rooms
Air conditioning
Swimming pool
24-hour front desk
Restaurant
Heating
See all facilities

Review Highlights

Pros:
Good location
Friendly staff
Modern rooms
Cons:
Rude staff
Pool maintenance
Value for money

Categories

Cleanliness
7.98
Clean room but overall cleanliness mentioned negatively in reviews about the shower and pool.
Service
9.25
Generally positive service experiences, though some staff were mentioned as rude.
Location
9.49
Consistently praised for great location near attractions.
Room Quality
8.44
Rooms were modern and clean but some concerns about amenities.
Amenities
7.47
Pool maintenance issues and lack of coffee and water in rooms noted.
Value for Money
6.93
Many reviews felt the price did not match the quality of the offerings.
Food and Beverage
8.68
Food was positively remarked upon at the bar, but some inconsistencies in service noted.
Overall Experience
8.95
Mixed experiences, but overall satisfaction about aspects like location and service.
* This sentiment is summarized by AI based on user reviews.
Updated at: 2025-12-11 01:15

Property Description

Luxurious Amenities
The Montauk Beach House offers an outdoor swimming pool, gift shop, café, and snack bar. Guests can enjoy cocktails by the poolside and shop for clothing and beauty products at the on-site gift shop.

Comfortable Accommodations
Each air-conditioned guest room features a flat-screen cable TV and a private bathroom with free toiletries. Some rooms even offer a refreshing pool view for a more relaxing stay.

Convenient Location
Situated just off Route 27, the hotel provides easy access to Camp Hero State Park and Hither Hills State Park. With dining options like South Edison within walking distance, guests can explore the area conveniently.

Book your stay at The Montauk Beach House for a perfect blend of luxury, comfort, and convenience.

Important information:

Please note, there is a DJ every weekend until Labor Day.Guests are required to show a photo ID and credit card upon check-in. Please note that all Special Requests are subject to availability and additional charges may apply.
A deposit may be required at the property.

Check-in and check-out hours:
Check-out: 11:00 AM
Airport code: ISP

Location

Guest Reviews

8.4
Based on 142 reviews
Cleanliness: 7.98
Service: 9.25
Location: 9.49
Room Quality: 8.44
Amenities: 7.47
Value for Money: 6.93
Food and Beverage: 8.68
Overall Experience: 8.95
S
Scott family_with_children us
7
Stay somewhere else with direct beach access
Pros:

Close to the plaza

Cons:

The outdoor bar and food was not open the day and evening that we stayed. Nowhere did we see nor was it mentioned by staff during check in that those were going to be closed that day.

2026-08-05 via Nuitee
Айгерим extended_group us
5
There’s no condition for the guests, only the pool is best part
Pros:

Just pool

Cons:

No hot water or fridge , water at the shower was broken we find out at night and moved for another when we was so tired (( nobody check the room before the guests , no hot drinks for breakfast at all

2026-07-10 via Nuitee
I
Ilire couple us
9
2026-05-25 via Nuitee
E
Evans couple us
9
The Montauk Beach Hotel is a both hip and cozy between the beach and town.
Pros:

I didn't have breakfast, but a great cappuccino at 8 AM
The Montauk Beach House has artistic flair. It's laid out beautifully and the property is walking distance from restaurants and art exhibits on the square. The staff is super friendly. We checked in at 10:00 PM and someone was still there to great us. I loved it. The rooms are super clean and cozy with balconies.

Cons:

The hotel was very quiet, which was good for sleep. Because the front desk person leaves at 11:00, it would have been helpful to have small signage, booklet, bulletin board with the routine or activities... I know everyone is on-line, but a little old school info about what to expect that week as far as entertainment, dining or things going on in town would have been cool.

2026-01-19 via Nuitee
V
Viacheslav couple us
6
2025-10-04 via Nuitee
C
Caley couple gb
2
Below average for the price
Pros:

Good location

Cons:

No coffee/ water in room
Pool was full of leaves and not maintained well
Couldn’t charge anything to your room
Some staff a little rude

2025-09-15 via Nuitee
N
Noelle partner
4
Pros:

Property pics and description makes u think your on the water. No water view at all anywhere. Booked $700 a night and found same room cheaper $400. I feel taken. The coffee shop doesn’t open until 8am. Pool closes early and it’s very noisy. Super disappointed 😔

2025-09-14 via Nuitee
F
Flora partner
10
Pros:

Loved it. Cant wait to go back

2025-09-13 via Nuitee
G
Gemma Fox couple gb
6
It wouldn't take much effort to make it really great
Pros:

Great coffee and love the maiden grass. The young woman with the red hair was very sweet to us.

Cons:

The footsteps from upstairs are loud, the shower curtain is gross, burning my arse on the scalding hot pipe in the shower was painful, not being allowed to use the pool one day because of a private event.

2025-09-08 via Nuitee
J
Janet couple gb
6
2025-09-06 via Nuitee
L
LaScala extended_group us
8
Loved the resort and its amenities. Rooms were very modern and clean. Staff were friendly. Just because they are not as
Pros:

Beautiful grounds clean and modern

Cons:

We were there during the week and the bar restaurant and pool all closed at 6 which was very disappointing

2025-08-30 via Nuitee
L
Lily extended_group us
3
Unpleasant staff and poor property upkeep do not make for s great stsy
Pros:

Great location, excellent bar and food.

Cons:

However, our experience was tainted by a lack of property maintenance and deplorable staff service. The TV did not work and my shower had scalding hot water only. The check-in process was an extreme challenge. But the worst was the pool towel staff who were rude and untrained. When we complained to the property hotel manager, Ms A, she was respectful and offered solutions. The pool manager Ms N, overheard our conversation and confronted us at the pool in front of both staff and guests. A 15 minute discourse was unwelcome and comical to be reprimanded by someone who knows nothing about guest relations and hospitality.
The three of us are executives snd travel extensively. This was a personal trip , one that we had planned for many months only for it to be marred.

2025-08-28 via Nuitee
A
Anne solo_traveller us
10
2025-08-19 via Nuitee
V
Victoria couple nl
9
Perfect location and service.
Pros:

The service, location and flexibility.

Cons:

We were in downstairs room and there were in the upstairs room and you would hear even when they walk.

2025-08-09 via Nuitee
C
Christine family
6
Pros:

Nice staff, quaint spot with a good location. We had to leave a day early bc my daughter was quite sick. No allowances were given which wasn't great. Loud music by the pool was a bit much with young kids.

2025-08-07 via Nuitee
H
heather
10
Pros:

Super staff and beautiful location!

2025-08-07 via Nuitee
J
Justyna family
10
Pros:

Had a wonderful and peaceful time. Great location, walkable everywhere. Loved the landscaping and the vibe. Was wondering if only our room didn’t have a small refrigerator or others too. That was the only part missing

2025-08-03 via Nuitee
F
Frank family_with_children us
9
Pros:

Very attentive staff. Decoration and setting were amazing definitely worth the fee.
Look forward to going back.
Couldn't be better located walk score 10

2025-08-02 via Nuitee
J
Jacob couple us
4
I would not stay here again.
Pros:

The room was clean.

Cons:

The value of what we paid was not met. They charge $750 a night for what basically amounts to a spruced up motel. One of the servers at the pool singled me out to give him my credit card before ordering food by the pool. We asked him if we could use ApplePay, and he said “yes, but we still need a physical card to start a tab”. But the following day, we had a different server that didn’t ask me for that at all. I felt racially discriminated against.

2025-08-02 via Nuitee
C
Christy extended_group us
10
2025-08-01 via Nuitee