Beachcomber Resort at Montauk

Hotels
Independent
9.2 (159 reviews)
727 Old Montauk Highway, Montauk, New York, 11954 , Montauk , US

Children allowed
Pets allowed

Facilities

Fitness facilities
Nature reserve
Free WiFi
Sauna
Outdoor pool - seasonal
Fitness facilities
Front desk (limited hours)
Smoke-free property
Free wired internet
Housekeeping on request
See all facilities

Review Highlights

Pros:
Great location
Friendly staff
Cons:
Outdated rooms
Service issues

Categories

Cleanliness
8.8
Several reviews mentioned cleanliness, but one noted outdated rooms with water stains, indicating some inconsistency.
Service
9.3
Mixed feedback on service; while many found staff friendly, there were serious complaints about the treatment of a guest with a service dog.
Location
10
Location is frequently praised for its proximity to the beach and town.
Room Quality
8.3
Many rooms were described as dated, but some were noted to be updated and comfortable.
Amenities
8.8
The property offers decent amenities, including a pool and gym, but some rooms lacked certain essentials.
Value for Money
9.8
Guests found the pricing reasonable given the location, though some felt the rooms didn't match expectations.
Food and Beverage
8.8
Food and beverage options were not specifically mentioned; hence, standard quality for this hotel tier.
Overall Experience
9.8
Overall, guests had a positive experience, with many expressing a desire to return.
* This sentiment is summarized by AI based on user reviews.
Updated at: 2026-01-07 08:01

Property Description

Discover your coastal retreat at Beachcomber Resort at Montauk, where relaxation meets adventure!

Beachside Bliss
Just a minute's stroll from The Hamptons Beaches, our prime location invites you to soak in the sun and surf. Enjoy immediate access to Kirk Park Beach and Fort Pond for endless outdoor fun and exploration.

Home Away From Home
Unwind in one of our 72 uniquely designed guestrooms, featuring private balconies or patios. Each room is equipped with a kitchen, perfect for whipping up your favorite meals and enjoying the ocean breeze.

Recreational Retreat
Stay active with our outdoor tennis court, relax in the sauna, or energize your day in our fitness center. Complimentary wireless internet ensures you stay connected while you unwind.

Elevate your getaway—book your stay at Beachcomber Resort at Montauk today!

Important information:

  • Only registered guests are allowed in the guestrooms.
  • Contactless check-in and contactless check-out are available.

Check-in and check-out hours:
Check-out: 11:00 AM
Airport code: LGA

Location

Guest Reviews

9.2
Based on 159 reviews
Cleanliness: 8.8
Service: 9.3
Location: 10
Room Quality: 8.3
Amenities: 8.8
Value for Money: 9.8
Food and Beverage: 8.8
Overall Experience: 9.8
S
Susan partner
10
Pros:

Had a beautiful ocean view room with a lovely balcony..Room was spacious & very clean. Would definitely stay here again.

2025-10-12 via Nuitee
A
Antoinette
10
Pros:

Kitchen was fully equipped and the Heat was plentiful!

2025-10-12 via Nuitee
A
Anjel
10
Pros:

Staff was accommodating, room was clean. The view was amazing and the location to stores was perfect. Will definitely come back..

2025-10-10 via Nuitee
L
Lynda partner
10
Pros:

We love the Beachcomber Resort! The grounds are beautiful, the pool is just the right temperature, and the room was lovely. The staff is always nice and super helpful. Two thumbs up!!

2025-10-10 via Nuitee
C
Carol
10
Pros:

This was a much needed short getaway!!!! It was exactly what my family needed. Everything was neat and clean all staff was excellent and friendly. I would highly recommend this place and we intend on going back for a week next year!

2025-10-06 via Nuitee
B
Barbara
10
Pros:

Exceptional in every way

2025-10-06 via Nuitee
K
Kevin
10
Pros:

Wonderful views and spacious studio. Very clean and well maintained.

2025-10-03 via Nuitee
J
Jacqueline partner
10
Pros:

Beachcomber is great! Beach is right across the street, and the pool is heated with fresh towels and plenty of room to sit or lounge! The staff is very friendly and helpful, and the grounds are well maintained! We love to stay here when we go to Montauk!

2025-09-29 via Nuitee
J
James family
10
Pros:

Beautiful room right across from the ocean and by town. Definitely go back!

2025-09-29 via Nuitee
U
Ulrike
10
Pros:

Very relaxing property, beautiful views of the ocean, short walk to the beach, nice and very clean pool, friendly staff.

2025-09-27 via Nuitee
K
Kaitlyn
10
Pros:

Perfect location fir a weekend getaway. The beach access was right across the road. You coul walk into town easily or if you wanted to d6ive everything was a close location to here.

2025-09-23 via Nuitee
E
emily
10
Pros:

Lovely stay and great staff!

2025-09-22 via Nuitee
S
Sigfredo friends
10
Pros:

Very enjoble

2025-09-21 via Nuitee
M
Michael partner
10
Pros:

Loved everything about the resort.

2025-09-14 via Nuitee
J
jessica partner
10
Pros:

4th year, and keeps getting better!

2025-09-13 via Nuitee
C
Callie
4
Pros:

Don't let the landscaping and pictures on the internet fool you - we were duped. We booked 2 rooms; both were very outdated. One room had water stains on the wallpaper and the other felt like you were in a trailer when you went into the bathroom. Both had full sized beds.
We asked for a nicer room or larger bed, staff was not friendly and dismissed us. Would never stay here again.

2025-09-12 via Nuitee
J
James
4
Great location but dated property with rude staff
Pros:

Upon arriving after 6 hours of travel with my 8 lbs hypoallergenic service dog I wasn’t even greeted with a hello before an angry old woman at the front desk went on a monologue for berating me about the dog. She falsely claimed their listing on hotels.com claimed service dogs must be pre registered when dogs aren’t even mentioned in the rules or regs. Hotels.com claims to have talked to them, but they didn’t reach out at all let alone apologize. I left early as felt extremely unwelcome and the property is very much early 90s 3 star vibe despite being across from the ocean. Mean and awful experience especially to someone with PTSD.

2025-09-08 via Nuitee
T
Thomas partner
10
Pros:

Beautiful views quiet

2025-09-06 via Nuitee
C
Christopher
10
Pros:

Great

2025-09-02 via Nuitee
C
Cammi partner
10
Pros:

It was excellent but the art on the walls was embarrassingly bad.

2025-09-01 via Nuitee