Harboring Secrets Murder Mystery Quest

Show all photos
1 hour (approximately)

A centuries-old secret and a missing captain await in this interactive murder mystery quest through the historic South Street Seaport. Participants will unravel a chilling tale as they solve riddles and crack codes, tracing the ghostly story of Captain Elias Fortescue, a sailor lost to time.

Perfect for puzzle enthusiasts and mystery lovers, this adventure spans approximately half a mile and lasts 1-2 hours, ensuring an engaging experience while exploring the cobblestone streets. Begin your quest at McNally Jackson Books, and be ready to download the free ClueKeeper app to guide you through the clues and challenges.

What's Included

3 printed sheets will be emailed to you for you to print off for the Quest!
You end at a spot to grab a drink and food - make sure you have money to celebrate with their fantastic menu!

Meeting and pickup

Meeting point

This is a self-guided hunt - there will be no guide to meet you. This Quest requires the use of our free Cluekeeper app, plus 3 printed off sheets. If you don’t have access to a printer you can use your own notebook, however puzzles will be more challenging.

End point
This activity ends back at the meeting point.

Ticket Redemption Point

What to expect

You’ll explore South Street Seaport while solving a murder mystery that blends history with puzzles. Starting at a local bookstore, you’ll follow clues through cobblestone streets, old warehouses, and waterfront views. At each stop, you’ll answer riddles, unlock hidden details, and piece together the story of a betrayed pirate.

Along the way, you’ll work as a team to crack codes, solve challenges, and uncover evidence that leads to the truth. The experience ends at a nearby bar, where the final reveal takes place.

It’s part walking tour, part scavenger hunt, and part mystery game - a unique way to see the city and test your detective skills.

Additional info

  • Infants and small children can ride in a pram or stroller
  • Service animals allowed
  • Public transportation options are available nearby
  • Suitable for all physical fitness levels
  • Do you have to be 21+? No
Supplied by Questing NY

Tags

Historical Tours
Self-guided Tours
Escape Rooms
Fun & Games
Scavenger Hunts
Short term availability

Cancellation Policy

For a full refund, cancel at least 24 hours before the scheduled departure time.

Show more

from per group (up to 4)
Was {{currencySymbol}}{{ summaryFromPriceBeforeDiscount }}
Check availability