Fisher Inn Resort & Marina

Hotels
9 (1001 reviews)
84951 Overseas Highway , Islamorada , us

Free
Children allowed
Pets allowed

Facilities

WiFi available
Free WiFi
Parking
Free Parking
Non-smoking rooms
Air conditioning
Swimming pool
Heating
Pets allowed
Luggage storage
See all facilities

Review Highlights

Pros:
Friendly staff
Beautiful location
Comfortable beds
Cons:
Cleanliness issues
Inadequate breakfast
Room amenities not matching description

Categories

Cleanliness
8.16
Concerns about cleanliness due to reports of cockroaches and dirty areas.
Service
10
Many positive mentions of the staff, particularly Thomas, indicating high service quality.
Location
9.63
Repeatedly highlighted as excellent, with beautiful views and easy access to nearby attractions.
Room Quality
8.67
Generally good quality described, but some negative experiences regarding furnishings.
Amenities
8.62
Some amenities offered were appreciated; however, there were issues with the stove and barbecue.
Value for Money
9.65
Affordability highlighted, especially for the value during the holiday season.
Food and Beverage
7.61
Criticism regarding breakfast and limited variety.
Overall Experience
9.66
Most guests expressed a very positive overall experience.
* This sentiment is summarized by AI based on user reviews.
Updated at: 2026-01-07 17:06

Property Description

Beachfront Location

Situated on the shores of Islamorada, Fisher Inn Resort & Marina offers guests a prime beachfront location, just a stone's throw away from Key Largo. Enjoy direct beach access and a boat ramp for aquatic adventures.

Comfortable Accommodations

Each room at this Islamorada hotel comes equipped with free Wi-Fi, cable TV, and some even feature a kitchenette for added convenience. Relax in well-appointed rooms after a day of exploring the area.

Exciting Activities

From fishing to paddle boarding, guests at Fisher Inn Resort & Marina can partake in a variety of activities without leaving the property. Explore the waters with kayaking and snorkeling, or simply unwind by the outdoor pool.

Experience the perfect blend of relaxation and adventure at Fisher Inn Resort & Marina. Book your stay now for an unforgettable beachfront getaway.

Important information:

Please note: guests must be at least 21 years of age to check in.

Please note: the same credit card used to book the reservation must be presented at check in. The name used to make the reservation must match the name on the credit card. The cardholder must be present at check-in, and this property will not accept third-party reservations.

Guests expecting to arrive outside check-in hours must inform Harbor Lights Islamorada in advance.Guests are required to show a photo ID and credit card upon check-in. Please note that all Special Requests are subject to availability and additional charges may apply.
A deposit may be required at the property.

Check-in and check-out hours:
Check-out: 11:00 AM
Airport code: MIA

Property Policies

  • Parking

    Free public parking is possible on site (reservation is not needed).

  • Internet

    WiFi is available in all areas and is free of charge.

  • Pets

    Pets are allowed. Charges may be applicable.

  • Children and extra bed policy

    Children of any age are allowed.
    Children up to and including 12 years old stay for free when using an existing bed.
    You haven't added any cots.
    You haven't added any extra beds.

  • Groups

    No special conditions apply for groups.

Location

Guest Reviews

9
Based on 1001 reviews
Cleanliness: 8.16
Service: 10
Location: 9.63
Room Quality: 8.67
Amenities: 8.62
Value for Money: 9.65
Food and Beverage: 7.61
Overall Experience: 9.66
Y
Yadira family_with_children us
10
2026-07-04 via Nuitee
I
Ian couple gb
8
Pros:

Really nice ocean view room, with a nice balcony. Room had everything needed sitting area, small kitchen and separate bedroom.

Cons:

Noisy air conditioning unit.

2026-07-03 via Nuitee
C
courtneypX9537OY Family
10
Fun in sun
Pros:

My parents just got back from there visit and they had an amazing time and I would like to recognize Michelle steadmam and Riley Alfie for making one of the best experiences they have every had great customer service and just hard working women that other extra to keep the guests happy so thank you

2026-07-02 via Tripadvisor
R
Ricardo extended_group us
10
Very cozy, quiet, clean and beautiful ocean view from the villas.
Pros:

I love the location, the views, how quiet it is, the staff very friendly, the rooms were clean and comfortable.

2026-07-01 via Nuitee
I
I6175OFmorganl Family Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
8
Best Stay!
Pros:

We had a great experience at Fisher Inn that was made even better by the front desk employee, Alfie. Upon checking in, one part of our reservation was not as we had intended it and she went far above and beyond to solve our problem. We had an amazing stay because of her hospitality!

2026-06-26 via Tripadvisor
M
Marlon couple us
7
Cons:

There’s someplace in the room not very clean, and the AC was not cooling

2026-06-23 via Nuitee
S
Sonya couple us
8
Overall wonderful stay. Beautiful place and we will be back.
Pros:

Beautiful spot. Clean and nicely maintained. Pool was nice. Smaller facility with less people which was nice for relaxing quietness and enjoying the surroundings.

Cons:

Our room needed updated sofa and chairs due to age, wear and tear and very uncomfortable.
Night shift front office person was not very welcoming or friendly at all. No smile, we seemed to have been bothering her when asking for pool towels and the time to fill out the log.
Cleaners weren’t very welcoming. They did respond when we said good morning or hello. But that was all.
Upon arrival, Michelle saw us trying to figure out the room and parking and jumped right in to help and she is in laundry. She was very kind and helpful.
Quicker response time with maintenance as our air went out in the middle of the night and still not fixed by checkout the next morning.
We reported at 8am and 3 hours with out being fixed.

2026-06-20 via Nuitee
M
maureenrQ9217WN Family
10
Great customer service
Pros:

Absolutely phenomenal front desk service from Giselle! So helpful and pleasant! For our trip off to the perfect start!

2026-06-19 via Tripadvisor
D
Denize solo_traveller us
9
Pros:

Me gustó la ubicación, esta cerca de la playa,restaurantes,museos.
Muy tranquilo

Cons:

Debían dar ofertas mas variadas en el desayuno

2026-06-19 via Nuitee
O
orit solo_traveller il
8
מיקום מעולה, יש תמורה בעד המחיר
Pros:

צוות אדיב מאוד. עזרו לנו בכל נושא אפילו ניסו לעזור בהזמנת מלון במיאמי. הבריכהנעימה. החדר בבקתה מול הים. מושלם

Cons:

מיטות חורקות, מזרן קפיצים נוראי

2026-06-19 via Nuitee
1
143lydiam Family Clermont, Lake County, Florida
10
Great location with an awesome oceanview!
Pros:

Perfect location with an amazing ocean view! Clean, comfortable and close to restaurants, breweries, and shops! Our King Oceanview room had the BEST views! The staff was helpful and friendly! Shout out to Michelle who helped make our stay extra special with her assistance!! Looking forward to booking here again!

2026-06-17 via Tripadvisor
G
Gabriela couple ar
7
Para 2 noches está ok
Pros:

La comodidad de la habitación

Cons:

El olor a podrido y la recepcionista

2026-06-16 via Nuitee
E
Erika extended_group us
3
Las áreas comunes tenían mal olor; el servicio de recepción del hotel es pésimo no existe empatía con los huéspedes.
Pros:

La habitación estaba limpia
The room was clean

Cons:

The room was clean and big
La habitación estaba limpia y grande

2026-06-16 via Nuitee
E
Espinoza solo_traveller us
8
Pros:

Muy acogedor y tranquilo.

Cons:

Se debe mejorando un poco el desayuno.

2026-06-15 via Nuitee
E
Elias couple us
10
Great spot and staff. Loved Alfie at check in.
Pros:

Perfect views, quiet, and great location.

Cons:

Loved it all.

2026-06-13 via Nuitee
V
Vitol extended_group us
8
Very nice place to enjoy Islamorada. Close to both fishing options and some nightlife.
Pros:

The room, located on the third floor of the main building, was spacious, well air conditioned, generally clean and had a comfortable bed, a functional bathroom kitchenette and a spacious balcony that provided an ocean view (Note: the main building is situated perpendicular to the shore, so just about everyone on the upper floors had an "ocean view"). The front desk staff was friendly, helpful and very professional. The continental breakfast was actually more than I expected, containing a number of options, including fresh baked muffins (offered once during our four day stay), cereal, yogurt, bagels, Danish and hard-boiled eggs. The hotel grounds and outdoor shaded seating areas were well maintained with ample seating and beach area provided some incredible ocean views. Overall (and despite the comments below), we enjoyed our visit, appreciated the property's location, and will definitely consider staying here again the next time we visit the Keys.

Cons:

The metal chairs in the room were uncomfortable and difficult to sit in for more than a few minutes. Chair pads would have been a big help. Also, I only found out on the second day of our trip that our rooms would not be cleaned unless we notified the front desk at least 24 hours in advance. This requirement would have been good to know when we first checked in. Note: Our party rented two rooms. A card stating this requirement for 24 hours' notice was only found in one of the rooms (i.e., the room I didn't stay in). Finally, while I was generally impressed with the continental breakfast options, you need to arrive early. Once the breakfast items are gone, they do not appear to be restocked. Additionally, I found out the hard way that the hotel allows pets; a barking dog woke me up every morning at 6:00AM (I guess there's not much a hotel can do about inconsiderate guests), and since the main property is located reasonably close to the highway, some road noise did come through the walls/windows.

2026-06-08 via Nuitee
J
joanh271 Family
10
Great
Pros:

Allie was great at the front desk. Love our room so close to the ocean. Clean, quiet and good service.

2026-06-04 via Tripadvisor
A
Allison couple us
5
It was ok not great
Pros:

Private

Cons:

Ac in room, ants in kitchen, water pressure in tub, hard seating at pool

2026-06-02 via Nuitee
S
Shannon family_with_children us
5
Property is easy to access especially if you plan on boating. The pool is clean.
Pros:

We stayed in a villa. It was easy access to and from the pool and the boat. It’s nice they have a boat ramp accessible.

Cons:

Our room wasn’t very clean when we arrived. There was a ton of dust on the fan and blinds like it had been sitting there for a while. We asked for a cleaning the next day and they said they would come in the morning but never showed. Thankfully the following day, our friends who were staying in the villa next to us requested a cleaning for both rooms and it was better. But they never touched the fans or blinds for the whole 4 day stay.

2026-06-01 via Nuitee
S
Sébastien family_with_children fr
10
Pros:

Super emplacement et équipements !

Cons:

Le petit déjeuner est un peu vite fait mais nous ne venions pas pour cela donc ça n’a pas déranger outre mesure mais je n’ai rien à dire sur tout le reste

2026-05-31 via Nuitee